Multiple Genres: Analyzing Argumentative Texts By Explaining How Authors Use Evidence To Support Arguments (TEKS.ELA.6.8.E.ii)
Help Questions
Texas 6th Grade ELA › Multiple Genres: Analyzing Argumentative Texts By Explaining How Authors Use Evidence To Support Arguments (TEKS.ELA.6.8.E.ii)
Many middle schools start classes before 8:00 a.m., but they shouldn't. Early bells fight the biology of growing kids. During puberty, sleep cycles shift later, so students naturally fall asleep later at night. When school starts too early, they lose needed rest, and the results show up in behavior and grades. In one nearby district that moved the first bell from 7:25 to 8:45, students reported about 45 more minutes of sleep per night, and tardies fell by 25 percent within the first quarter. A national group of pediatricians also recommends that middle schools begin after 8:30, citing studies that link later starts to better attendance and higher test performance. Some people worry that starting later would ruin sports or after-school jobs. Yet schools that adjusted practice times found teams still finished before dark, and participation stayed steady. If we want students to be alert, safe, and ready to learn, we should set schedules that match how their bodies actually work.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
A coach says players like sleeping in more.
Bus routes are complicated and expensive to change.
A national pediatric group recommends middle schools start after 8:30, and districts that shifted saw more sleep and fewer tardies.
One student says she drinks coffee to wake up.
Explanation
Choice C directly supports the claim by combining expert opinion with measurable results (more sleep and fewer tardies) tied to later start times.
Planting native trees along our streets is a smart investment for our city. Native species are adapted to local weather, so they need less watering and fewer costly treatments. They also support the insects and birds that keep our urban ecosystem balanced. In a two-year study by a state university, blocks planted with native oaks and maples hosted three times more pollinators than blocks with imported ornamentals, and required 25 percent less irrigation during summer heat. When our parks department tested a native-tree pilot on three streets last year, crews logged fewer pest calls and saved eight hours of maintenance per month. Some homeowners prefer exotic trees because they look unusual, but eye-catching leaves cannot shade bus stops or cool sidewalks any better than native canopies can. If we want shadier, healthier streets that are cheaper to maintain, choosing native trees will deliver benefits we can measure, not just admire.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
A two-year university study found native trees supported three times more pollinators and needed 25 percent less irrigation.
Some neighbors think exotic trees look more unique.
A photo online showed a street with pretty palm trees.
The city once ordered new trash cans for downtown.
Explanation
Choice A provides specific, measurable results from a study that directly support the claim that native trees offer environmental and maintenance benefits.
Students should learn accurate keyboarding earlier, not wait until middle school. By third grade, many assignments already require typing, yet most students hunt-and-peck. That slows thinking and makes writing harder. When students can type without looking, they focus on ideas, not keys. In classrooms that taught keyboarding as a short, daily routine, teachers noticed improvements beyond speed: fewer spelling errors and clearer organization. In one district, a 12-week program for fourth graders led to essays that were 20 percent longer on state prompts, with fewer editing mistakes, compared with classes that did not practice. Some argue that tablets make typing less important, but even on touch screens, knowing where keys are matters. Keyboarding is like handwriting: it takes guided practice to become automatic. If schools spend just fifteen minutes a day in grades three and four, students will gain a lifelong tool that helps them express their thinking more clearly.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
My cousin typed a story faster after a weekend of gaming.
Tablets are popular in many schools today.
A teacher prefers students to write by hand.
After a 12-week keyboarding program, fourth graders wrote essays 20 percent longer with fewer errors than classes without practice.
Explanation
Choice D offers comparative data showing a clear improvement from instruction, directly linking keyboarding practice to better writing outcomes.
Cafeterias should reduce single-use plastic by switching to durable trays, cups, and water stations. Every lunch period, trash cans overflow with crinkly wrappers, forks, and bottles used for only minutes. That waste is expensive to haul and harmful to the environment. When our school piloted reusable trays and lids for one week, the custodians measured trash bags per day dropping from 18 to 7, and the weight of landfill waste fell by nearly one-third. They also reported finishing cleanup sooner because fewer bags had to be tied, carried, and compacted. Some worry that washing reusables takes water, but modern dishwashers are efficient; the kitchen already washes pans and serving utensils. Students adjusted quickly: lines moved at the same speed after the first day, and the cafeteria stayed cleaner with fewer spills. If we want to save money and reduce waste, cutting single-use plastic is a simple change that makes a big difference.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
A student group designed a cool logo for reusable bottles.
During a one-week pilot with reusables, daily trash bags fell from 18 to 7 and cleanup time dropped.
Plastic forks come in many colors.
Some parents collect plastic utensils for crafts at home.
Explanation
Choice B gives concrete, measured results from a pilot, directly supporting the claim that reducing single-use plastic cuts waste and saves time.
Middle schools should start later in the morning. Doctors who study teen sleep say adolescents naturally fall asleep later, so a 7:30 bell forces them to wake before their brains are ready to learn. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends middle schools begin no earlier than 8:30 so students can reach the 8–10 hours they need. When teens are rested, they make safer choices, focus longer, and remember more. In districts that moved the first period back, nurses reported fewer visits for headaches, and coaches noticed athletes had more energy after school. Some people argue that after-school activities would run too late, but schools that shifted schedules adjusted bus routes and practice times without major problems. A later start is not about laziness; it is about aligning school with how teen bodies work. If we want higher attendance, better grades, and healthier students, we should ring the first bell closer to 9:00.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
A review of 30 school districts found that starting after 8:30 raised attendance and first-period grades within one semester.
Some teens enjoy staying up late to text friends.
Our school band already meets before sunrise on Fridays.
One teacher said mornings feel rushed.
Explanation
Choice A is strongest because it provides data linking later start times to higher attendance and better grades, directly supporting the claim. The other options are opinions or isolated examples that do not show a clear connection to the claim. Extension: List one type of evidence used in the passage. Scaffold: Evidence categories to consider—fact, statistic, expert opinion. Enrichment: Evaluate whether the statistic in A seems strong or weak and explain why.
Schools should offer a daily salad bar in the cafeteria. When students can build their own plates, they are more likely to try vegetables they actually like. In one nearby district, the cafeteria staff added a salad bar for a month and tracked what went into the trash. Plate waste dropped, and more students reported feeling full without extra snacks. Nutrition guidelines ask students to eat a variety of colors; a salad bar makes that choice visible and easy. Some worry about cost, but reused pans and seasonal produce keep prices steady, and community gardens can supply herbs. A principal from a similar-sized school said lines moved faster once students knew the routine. Most important, healthy habits learned at lunch can follow students home. Students who choose their toppings tend to eat what they select, reducing leftovers. If our goal is better nutrition and less waste, a daily salad bar is a simple step that works.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
Salad bars look colorful and fun to set up.
In a two-school pilot, plate waste fell by 18% after adding a daily salad bar.
One student said croutons are the best part.
Our cafeteria already owns tongs and trays.
Explanation
Choice B is strongest because it offers a specific statistic showing that salad bars reduce waste, which directly supports the claim. The other choices are about appearance, personal preference, or equipment and do not prove the claim. Extension: List one type of evidence used in the passage. Scaffold: Evidence categories to consider—fact, statistic, expert opinion. Enrichment: Decide whether the 18% statistic is strong or weak; explain what would make it stronger.
Students should learn keyboarding before cursive handwriting. In middle school, most assignments are typed, from lab reports to essays. When students can type accurately, they can focus on their ideas instead of hunting for keys. A statewide technology survey found that the majority of middle school work is submitted digitally. In a study of sixth graders, those who practiced keyboarding for 20 minutes a day wrote longer responses in the same time than those who practiced cursive. An occupational therapist noted that keyboarding can reduce hand fatigue for students with fine-motor challenges. Cursive still has value for signatures and history, but class time is limited. Teaching keyboarding first gives students a practical tool they use daily; cursive can be an optional unit later. If we want clearer thinking to show up on the screen, we should teach the skill that students use most.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
A teacher loves receiving handwritten notes from students.
Some laptops run out of battery during the day.
A sixth-grade study showed students with daily keyboarding practice wrote longer responses in the same time.
Cursive looks elegant in invitations.
Explanation
Choice C is strongest because it presents study results connecting keyboarding practice to better writing output, directly supporting the claim. The other options are opinions or unrelated issues that do not prove the argument. Extension: List one type of evidence used in the passage. Scaffold: Evidence categories to consider—fact, statistic, expert opinion. Enrichment: Judge whether the study evidence is strong or weak and explain what details would help you decide.
Planting more trees around our school would help students and the neighborhood. Trees provide shade that cools sidewalks and playgrounds on hot days, making outdoor time safer. Leaves also filter some pollution from the air, which benefits kids who walk or bike to school. In cities that added street trees near schools, afternoon surface temperatures fell, and students reported that metal benches were no longer too hot to touch. Science classes could use the trees for real-world observations of seasons and wildlife. Some people worry that leaves create extra cleanup, but scheduled maintenance and student clubs can manage it. Others ask whether trees take too long to grow, yet nurseries offer young trees that provide shade within a few years. If we want a healthier, more comfortable campus, planting trees is a smart, long-lasting investment.
Which evidence best supports the author's claim?
Our art club wants to paint a mural on the gym wall.
One neighbor likes cactus gardens better than trees.
Tree planters come in many sizes and colors.
Studies show adding street trees near schools lowers afternoon surface temperatures and can improve local air quality.
Explanation
Choice D is strongest because it cites studies that directly link more trees to cooler temperatures and cleaner air, which matches the author's claim. The other options are preferences or unrelated details. Extension: List one type of evidence used in the passage. Scaffold: Evidence categories to consider—fact, statistic, expert opinion. Enrichment: Decide if the study evidence seems strong or weak; explain what information (sample size, location, time) would help.