Comprehension Skills: Generating Questions Before During And After Reading (TEKS.ELA.6.5.B)
Help Questions
Texas 6th Grade ELA › Comprehension Skills: Generating Questions Before During And After Reading (TEKS.ELA.6.5.B)
On the first Saturday of spring, Maya and her classmates met behind the cafeteria to plan a community garden. The principal had donated a sunny strip of land, but that was all they agreed on. Some students wanted rows of vegetables to stock the food pantry. Others argued for a butterfly garden to help pollinators. Time was a problem, too: the only hour the hose could be used overlapped with basketball practice, and very few students could come early. As voices grew tense, Mr. Lopez asked them to list priorities on sticky notes. Patterns appeared. Nourishing families mattered to everyone. So did conserving water and attracting helpful insects. The group chose raised beds around a central pollinator patch, planted drought-tolerant herbs, and created a rotating schedule that paired athletes with students who preferred mornings. When they finally patted soil smooth, Maya noticed how different ideas had shaped the design. The garden, she thought, was more than vegetables—it was a map of their compromises.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
What time did the meeting start?
How do the students' different priorities shape the final garden plan?
How many raised beds were built in total?
Which brand of gloves worked best?
Explanation
B pushes readers to think about cause and effect—how differing priorities lead to specific decisions—deepening comprehension of the group's process and theme of collaboration. A, C, and D are literal or irrelevant details that do not build overall understanding. Extension: Generate one "before reading" and one "after reading" question about a self-selected text. Scaffold stems: "Why might the group choose…?" "How does the problem affect…?" Enrichment: Compare your questions for a narrative vs. an informational text to see how strategies differ.
Sometimes, on warm nights, a shoreline flashes with blue sparks at every splash. The glow comes from tiny plankton that release light when disturbed. Inside each cell, a safe chemical reaction briefly produces energy as a soft shine. To people, it looks magical. To plankton, it can mean survival. A sudden glow can startle a hungry fish, much like a porch light surprises you in the dark. The light may also work like an alarm, drawing bigger predators to chase the first attacker away. In calmer water, the glow helps plankton find one another to reproduce. Not every beach sparkles, and the brightness changes with temperature, nutrients, and waves. Scientists study these flickers to learn about ocean health, because large blooms can signal shifts in the food web. When you watch glowing footprints fade at the edge of the tide, you are seeing countless living signals, each a tiny strategy for staying alive in a restless sea.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
How does bioluminescence help plankton survive in their environment?
What color are most glowing waves?
How many tourists visited beaches last summer?
Which scientist first named the glow?
Explanation
A targets the passage's central idea—bioluminescence as a survival strategy—deepening understanding of purpose and cause/effect. B, C, and D are surface-level or irrelevant and do not aid overall comprehension. Extension: Create one "before reading" and one "after reading" question about a text you choose. Scaffold stems: "Why might organisms…?" "How does this feature help…?" Enrichment: Compare your questions for science articles vs. memoirs to see how strategies differ.
I thought fixing a flat would be quick. I watched two videos and lined up the tools on the garage floor like chess pieces: pump, patches, levers. The first tire lever snapped. The inner tube hissed like a kettle when I pried too fast. Frustrated, I stuffed the wheel back on and considered walking to the store. Mr. Patel from next door peeked in. He didn't take over; he asked what step I was on. Together we re-read the tiny diagram on the patch kit. Slow down, he said. Dust the tube with a pinch of chalk so the patch won't slide. Wait a full minute for the glue to turn dull. We talked about the time he taught his daughter to braid rope. My second attempt sealed. When the tire finally held air, I felt proud—but not just because my bike worked. I'd learned when to pause, when to ask, and how a patient voice can make a hard job feel possible.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
What is the exact model of the bicycle?
How long did the repair take from start to finish?
Which tools were stored in the garage drawer?
What does the narrator learn about persistence and when to ask for help?
Explanation
D focuses on the narrator's insight, moving beyond events to theme and character growth, which deepens comprehension. A, B, and C are overly literal details that do not reveal the passage's meaning. Extension: Write one "before reading" and one "after reading" question for a text you choose. Scaffold stems: "Why might the narrator…?" "How does this experience change…?" Enrichment: Compare questions you'd ask of memoirs vs. news articles to see how strategies differ.
Our school is considering a hallway map app to reduce tardies. The app would show less crowded routes and suggest when to leave class to arrive on time. Supporters point to data from a pilot at another campus: fewer traffic jams, calmer passing periods, and teachers spending less time writing tardy slips. But the proposal also raises questions. The app tracks movement, which means storing location patterns. Who would see that information? How long would it be kept? The plan includes limits—anonymous IDs, opt-in settings, and deleting records after a week—but trust matters as much as code. Some students worry that a tool meant to help could be used to monitor them. Others say walking without bumping into people is worth it. Before we vote, we should look closely at the evidence and the safeguards. If the app reduces crowding while protecting privacy, it deserves a trial. If not, we should find a simpler solution, like staggered passing times.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
How many students have phones at school?
Which hallway is most crowded after lunch?
How does the author use both benefits and privacy concerns to build the argument?
What is the exact map scale used by the app?
Explanation
C targets the author's reasoning—how evidence and counterarguments are balanced—deepening understanding of the argument's structure. A, B, and D are irrelevant or overly specific and do not support big-picture comprehension. Extension: Draft one "before reading" and one "after reading" question for a self-selected text. Scaffold stems: "Why might the author include…?" "How does the evidence support…?" Enrichment: Compare your questions for opinion pieces vs. narratives to see how strategies differ.
Last fall, our neighborhood transformed a weed-filled vacant lot into a community garden. Science club students mapped the sunniest spots, while volunteers cleared trash and built raised beds from donated lumber. To measure the garden's effect, we set thermometers in the lot and on the nearby sidewalk. On hot afternoons, the soil stayed a few degrees cooler than the concrete, and the shade from young trees made the benches comfortable. We also started a compost bin to reuse cafeteria scraps, and a local diner agreed to buy our extra herbs. By spring, bees hovered over purple blossoms, and families stopped by after dinner to water seedlings. The principal noticed fewer complaints about the heat during recess, and the city council asked our club to present our findings. The garden became more than a place to grow tomatoes; it became proof that small changes can cool a block, reduce waste, and bring neighbors together.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
Why does the author include temperature readings and community partnerships, and how do these details show the garden's impact?
How many shovels did volunteers bring to the lot?
What is the exact street address of the vacant lot?
During which month did the weeds grow the tallest?
Explanation
A focuses on cause and effect and how evidence supports the main idea, deepening comprehension. Others are overly literal or irrelevant. Extension: Students write one before-reading and one after-reading question for a self-selected text. Scaffold: Use stems like "Why might…?", "What do I predict…?", "How does…?", "What evidence shows…?". Enrichment: Compare questions across genres (informational vs. narrative vs. argumentative) to see how strategies differ.
On Saturday morning, I boarded the bus for River Clean Day with my headphones on and my expectations low. The forecast promised gray skies, and I figured we would just pick up a few bags of trash and go home. When we stepped off, the air smelled like mud and rain. Our team leader handed out grabbers and buckets. At first, I kept to myself, snapping bottle caps from the bank. Then Mateo pointed to a turtle tangled in fishing line near a rock. We worked together, steady hands and slow breaths, until the turtle slipped free and paddled into the current. After that, the trash bags seemed lighter, and the sky less heavy. By noon, the riverbank looked like a different place—green, open, and ours. On the ride back, I took out my headphones. The bus hummed with stories: a glove found, a heron spotted, a joke shared. I realized I hadn't just cleaned a river; I'd joined a community.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
What color were the work gloves the team used?
How long was the bus ride to the river?
How does the narrator's attitude change, and what causes that change?
What was the river's exact depth at noon?
Explanation
C targets character change and its causes, which clarifies the passage's central meaning. The other choices are trivial or irrelevant. Extension: Students craft one before-reading and one after-reading question for a self-selected text. Scaffold: Try stems like "Why might…?", "What do I predict…?", "How does…?", "What did I learn, and why does it matter?". Enrichment: Compare questions across genres to notice shifts from character-focused to evidence-focused inquiry.
Building a simple weather station at home doesn't require fancy tools, just careful observation over time. Start by placing a clear cup outside to collect rain, a ruler to measure depth, and a thermometer shaded from direct sun. Choose one location and keep it the same so your readings are comparable. Each day, write down the temperature, wind notes, cloud type, and rainfall. One day's numbers can be surprising, but patterns appear when you record for a week or more. For example, a storm might make temperatures drop quickly, then rise the next afternoon. When you compare your log to a local forecast, ask why predictions were right or wrong. Was a front slower than expected? Did shade from a tree affect your thermometer? By questioning what you see and checking it against other sources, you turn simple tools into a way to understand how weather changes, not just what it is at a single moment.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
How many batteries does a thermometer usually need?
Why does the writer emphasize recording observations over several days, and how does that help you interpret data?
What day of the week is mentioned first in the passage?
Which brand of cup is best for a rain gauge?
Explanation
B probes purpose and process, connecting details to the passage's main idea about patterns and interpretation. The others are trivial or off-topic. Extension: Students write one before-reading and one after-reading question for a self-selected text. Scaffold: Use stems like "Why might…?", "What do I predict…?", "How does…?", "What new questions do I have?". Enrichment: Compare how questions differ in procedural texts versus narratives and arguments.
Middle schoolers are often told to "go to bed earlier," but biology doesn't always cooperate. Sleep researchers explain that during adolescence, internal clocks shift, making it harder to fall asleep early and wake up at dawn. When schools start before sunrise, many students arrive groggy, which affects attention, mood, and safety. Districts that moved the first bell later report fewer tardies and improved grades. Critics worry about bus routes and after-school activities, yet solutions exist: staggered transportation, rotating practice times, and community partnerships for childcare. Changing a schedule won't solve every problem, but it aligns school hours with how growing brains work. If our goal is to help students learn, we should listen to the science and adjust the day so minds are awake when lessons begin.
Which question would best help a reader understand the passage?
How many schools are in the district?
What time does the writer wake up on weekends?
Which scientist first invented the term for circadian rhythms?
How does the evidence about sleep and bus schedules support the author's claim for later start times?
Explanation
D connects claim and evidence, revealing how support builds the argument. The other choices are irrelevant. Extension: Students create one before-reading and one after-reading question for a self-selected text. Scaffold: Stems like "Why might…?", "What do I predict…?", "How does…?", "What evidence supports…?" help. Enrichment: Compare student questions across genres to see how inquiry changes from claims/evidence to plot/character or process/cause-effect.