Natural Selection - MCAT Biological and Biochemical Foundations of Living Systems

Card 1 of 40

0
Didn't Know
Knew It
0
1 of 2019 left
Question

Which of the following is an example of natural selection?

I. Horses are bred for strength and endurance, and over time, the population of horses is more robust.

II. A late spring storm kills all the young plants in a region, but they are spared outside the storm zone.

III. Ancient ancestors of giraffes instinctively wanted to have longer necks to reach food higher in the trees, leading to the present appearance of giraffes.

IV. A flower that happens to be more attractive to pollinators is more likely to have reproductive success.

V. A mutation of a bacterium caused by exposure to ultraviolet light causes the originally red colonies to be yellow instead.

Tap to reveal answer

Answer

It is always difficult to rephrase "survival of the fittest" in some new, clever way. The flowers which BY CHANCE have developed a different color, pattern, or odor that better attracts pollinators are indeed more likely to experience reproductive success and pass on these genes to their offspring. Competing plants might do well for a while, but they are already disfavored, and further environmental changes may put them even more at risk (or have no effect, or again favor them over the presently more attractive plants).

The horse choice is an example of intentional breeding—artificial selection.

The storm option does not imply any condition in any of the plants which conferred an advantage against freezing to death, or even any difference between species of plants; it is more akin to a question about mass extinction than to one about evolution.

The giraffe choice relates to the Lamarckian fallacy of being able to pass on acquired characteristics; species that are more successful just plain "luck out" relative to environmental stresses.

The bacterial response discusses a mutation without likely survival implications for the bacterium.

← Didn't Know|Knew It →