Point at Issue

Help Questions

LSAT Logical Reasoning › Point at Issue

Questions 1 - 10
1

Sam: No person should ever be made to alter their religious beliefs by government decree, which the new law threatens with its vague language.

John: The new law does not allow anyone to violate another person's religion, which is precisely why the language in the law had to be vague.

The point at issue in this argument is best stated as __________.

whether the language in the law allows someone's religion to be violated

whether religion should be protected by legislative means

whether vague laws are able to be effective in reality

whether religion has a role to play in government

whether government should do anything to interfere in religious beliefs

Explanation

While the argument is over a law about the protection of religion, the issue is not about the relation between religion and government, as both sides agree that religion should be in some way protected from interference. The issue is whether the law's language, and especially its vagueness, appropriately protects an individual's religious beliefs.

2

Director: The most influential movie in history is likely Orson Welles’ classic Citizen Kane. No other single film has helped so many filmmakers in their craft. Indeed, a recent study showed that nearly 85% of modern films implemented at least one filmmaking technique pioneered by Citizen Kane. The film was especially noteworthy in its cinematography, its use of multiple narrators in storytelling, and in its use of music to set a scene.

In evaluating the director’s argument it would be most helpful to know whether

there is evidence showing whether filmmaking techniques from any other films have been as widely implemented as have those from Citizen Kane

filmmakers who implemented techniques pioneered by Citizen Kane gave credit to Orson Welles after doing so

the study cited in the argument took into account every single modern film rather than merely accounting for a majority of them

audiences regard Citizen Kane as highly as do modern filmmakers

Citizen Kane is studied in more film schools than any other movie

Explanation

The conclusion, found in the first and second sentences of the paragraph, is that Citizen Kane is the single most influential film as far as filmmakers are concerned. To evaluate this claim, it is necessary to know whether filmmaking techniques from other films have been as widely implemented. Note that the argument does not claim that Citizen Kane is the most popular film among audiences or in film schools.

3

Sam: No person should ever be made to alter their religious beliefs by government decree, which the new law threatens with its vague language.

John: The new law does not allow anyone to violate another person's religion, which is precisely why the language in the law had to be vague.

The point at issue in this argument is best stated as __________.

whether the language in the law allows someone's religion to be violated

whether religion should be protected by legislative means

whether vague laws are able to be effective in reality

whether religion has a role to play in government

whether government should do anything to interfere in religious beliefs

Explanation

While the argument is over a law about the protection of religion, the issue is not about the relation between religion and government, as both sides agree that religion should be in some way protected from interference. The issue is whether the law's language, and especially its vagueness, appropriately protects an individual's religious beliefs.

4

Jeans have been a staple of fashion for many decades. They may have remained fashionable for so long because they are durable, comfortable, and easy to maintain. It seems unlikely that any one of these factors alone could account for the popularity of jeans. After all, many articles of clothing have gone out of style even though they were comfortable. The same can be said of clothing items that were durable and clothing that was easy to maintain.

With which of the following would the author most likely agree?

Jeans are durable but this fact alone does not explain why they have been popular for so long

Jeans are popular for three reasons--they are durable, comfortable, and easy to maintain

It is impossible to explain why jeans have been popular for so long

Jeans have been popular for longer than any other clothing item

Clothing items will be popular for decades if a variety of factors are all met

Explanation

The author acknowledges that jeans are durable, but also makes clear that none of the three factors, alone, can explain why jeans have been so popular. The author does not reach a firm conclusion as to what is the correct explanation.

5

Director: The most influential movie in history is likely Orson Welles’ classic Citizen Kane. No other single film has helped so many filmmakers in their craft. Indeed, a recent study showed that nearly 85% of modern films implemented at least one filmmaking technique pioneered by Citizen Kane. The film was especially noteworthy in its cinematography, its use of multiple narrators in storytelling, and in its use of music to set a scene.

In evaluating the director’s argument it would be most helpful to know whether

there is evidence showing whether filmmaking techniques from any other films have been as widely implemented as have those from Citizen Kane

filmmakers who implemented techniques pioneered by Citizen Kane gave credit to Orson Welles after doing so

the study cited in the argument took into account every single modern film rather than merely accounting for a majority of them

audiences regard Citizen Kane as highly as do modern filmmakers

Citizen Kane is studied in more film schools than any other movie

Explanation

The conclusion, found in the first and second sentences of the paragraph, is that Citizen Kane is the single most influential film as far as filmmakers are concerned. To evaluate this claim, it is necessary to know whether filmmaking techniques from other films have been as widely implemented. Note that the argument does not claim that Citizen Kane is the most popular film among audiences or in film schools.

6

Jeans have been a staple of fashion for many decades. They may have remained fashionable for so long because they are durable, comfortable, and easy to maintain. It seems unlikely that any one of these factors alone could account for the popularity of jeans. After all, many articles of clothing have gone out of style even though they were comfortable. The same can be said of clothing items that were durable and clothing that was easy to maintain.

With which of the following would the author most likely agree?

Jeans are durable but this fact alone does not explain why they have been popular for so long

Jeans are popular for three reasons--they are durable, comfortable, and easy to maintain

It is impossible to explain why jeans have been popular for so long

Jeans have been popular for longer than any other clothing item

Clothing items will be popular for decades if a variety of factors are all met

Explanation

The author acknowledges that jeans are durable, but also makes clear that none of the three factors, alone, can explain why jeans have been so popular. The author does not reach a firm conclusion as to what is the correct explanation.

7

Jane: Nowadays 3D effects are seen as a distracting gimmick that most people no longer appreciate. The recent trend toward producing more 3D movies is not a good financial strategy for movie studios. In fact, I and my friends refuse to attend movies in 3D, and I know many others that feel the same way.

Bill: But you fail to take into account the fact that 3D ticket prices are higher than 2D ticket prices. The difference in price offsets the lower attendance at 3D movies. I, for one, appreciate having the choice between 2D and 3D films.

The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Jane and Bill disagree about whether

it is financially wise for movie studios to continue producing movies in 3D

people appreciate 3D effects in movies less now than they used to

2D movies are superior to 3D movies in overall quality

ticket price differentials between 2D and 3D movies are reasonable

movie studios ought to offer audiences the option to choose between 2D and 3D films

Explanation

Bill’s rebuttal to Jane’s argument is that studios can make up for the lower attendance at 3D films through increased ticket prices. Hence, he does not agree with Jane that producing 3D movies “is not a good financial strategy for movie studios.” The remaining answer choices do not contain statements about which Jane and Bill necessarily disagree, even though the topics may have been mentioned in the dialogue.

8

John: There are very few reasons to support the new state immigration laws, and several reasons to oppose them. Most importantly, the laws fail to include any "Dream Act" provision for immigrant college students, and thus provide no incentive for persons here illegally to gain a higher education.

Mary: But you've failed to mention the sweeping reforms to the residency process included in the laws. Those reforms make understanding levels of citizenship much simpler for those who don't speak English. If parents of college students can't even figure out their own statuses, they're unlikely to understand how to improve the status of their children.

The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that John and Mary disagree over whether

the lack of a "Dream Act" provision is the most important consideration in supporting or opposing the new state immigration laws

there are several reasons to oppose the new state immigration laws

a "Dream Act" provision will be effective for the majority of immigrant college students

college students should be able to gain residency based on completion of a higher education

the new state immigration laws are superior in some ways to the prior laws

Explanation

John specifically states that the lack of a “Dream Act” provision is the most important omission in the new laws. Mary implies that process reforms are more important, as they make the laws easier to understand for non-English speakers and thus are a precursor to other substantive provisions.

9

Teacher: Textbooks are just not effective for teaching some subjects to children. They don't take an interest in the topics, don't really understand them, and certainly won't remember them long term. To solve these problems we need to regularly take students to museums. Textbooks aren't a good option anymore.

Principal: It does seem that students are often distracted in the classroom. However, there are alternatives to textbooks that do not involve taking students to museums. Documentaries, for instance, can be an effective learning tool.

The teacher and principal are most likely to disagree about which of the following statements?

Taking students to museums is necessary

Students often do not understand the topics in textbooks

Documentaries can be an effective learning tool

Textbooks are not effective

Students won't remember what they learn in textbooks long term

Explanation

The principal seems to suggest that museums are one of multiple alternatives to textbooks. The teacher, on the other hand, states that students must be brought to museums. The principal and teacher are most likely to disagree about whether taking students to museums is necessary.

10

Director of the transportation department: We could save money over the next few years by closing lanes on highways and deferring repairs. The cost savings would be well worth the moderate increase in traffic jams. The roads will eventually need to be repaired, but the department could stay within budget over the next several years, which should be a top priority. If we continue to overspend, we may face a financial disaster.

Deputy Director: Closing road lanes would lead not only to a considerable increase in traffic jams but would also lead to increased accidents and death. That said, we’ve explored other options and closing the lanes seems to be our only viable plan to save money, and there is no question that we must accomplish that.

The Director and Deputy Director most likely disagree about whether?

closing road lanes will lead to a considerable increase in traffic jams

the roads eventually should be repaired

the department is at risk of overspending

road lanes should be closed

there are alternative ways to save money

Explanation

Both people seem to agree that road lanes must be closed and that reducing spending should be a top priority. The Director and Deputy Director disagree about whether closing road lanes will lead to a considerable increase in traffic jams. The Director stated that the lane closures would lead only to a moderate increase.

Page 1 of 5