Drawing Conclusions
Help Questions
ISEE Lower Level: Reading Comprehension › Drawing Conclusions
At the community center, a jar of donation coins sat on the counter. On Saturday afternoon, the jar looked lighter than usual. Ms. Rivera noticed the lid was still screwed on tightly. She also saw a narrow line of coins on the floor, as if they had rolled. A volunteer said the jar had been moved to wipe the counter. Later, Ms. Rivera found the jar behind a stack of flyers. The jar was tipped sideways, but the lid had not been opened. She checked the counter camera, which showed a gust of wind from the open door. The wind knocked over a tall flyer stand, which bumped the jar. Coins spilled, and a volunteer quickly swept them into a cup. The volunteer forgot to pour them back. Which statement best summarizes the conclusion of the passage?
Ms. Rivera hid the jar to test the volunteers’ honesty.
Someone stole the coins by opening the jar lid.
The coins spilled by accident and were not returned yet.
The jar was empty because no one donated that day.
Explanation
This question tests ISEE Lower Level reading comprehension skills, specifically the ability to draw a conclusion supported by passage details. Drawing a conclusion involves synthesizing information from the text to make a logical inference. It requires careful attention to key details that guide the reader toward an understanding that is not explicitly stated. In this passage, details such as the camera showing wind knocking over a flyer stand that bumped the jar, coins spilling out, and a volunteer forgetting to pour swept coins back work together to support the conclusion that the coins spilled by accident and were not returned yet. Choice B is correct because it accurately reflects the logical outcome based on these details, showing an understanding of how the sequence of accidental events explains the missing coins. Choice A is incorrect because it overlooks the fact that the lid remained tightly screwed on and misinterprets the situation as theft, leading to a common error where students might jump to suspicious conclusions without considering all evidence. To help students master this skill, encourage them to identify and underline key details in a passage that contribute to the main idea or outcome. Remind them to distinguish between details that are central to the conclusion and those that are merely descriptive.
On Monday, Mr. Ortiz placed a jar of colored pencils on his desk. By Wednesday, the blue pencil was missing. He asked the class to check backpacks and desks. No one found it. On Thursday, he noticed tiny blue marks on the class sign-in sheet. The marks looked like short, straight lines. During art time, Mr. Ortiz watched quietly. Tessa used a blue pencil, but she had brought her own set. Jordan borrowed a blue pencil, then returned it. Liam did not draw at all. Near the end, Mr. Ortiz saw Ava carefully outlining letters on a poster. She pressed hard, making the same short, straight lines. When the bell rang, Ava hurried to put supplies away. A blue pencil slipped from her folder and rolled under the table. Ava froze, then whispered that she had taken it to finish the poster. What is the most logical conclusion based on the passage details?
Liam took the pencil because he avoided art time.
Jordan took the pencil because he borrowed supplies often.
Ava took the pencil to use on the class poster.
Tessa took the pencil because she liked the color blue.
Explanation
This question tests ISEE Lower Level reading comprehension skills, specifically the ability to draw a conclusion supported by passage details. Drawing a conclusion involves synthesizing information from the text to make a logical inference. It requires careful attention to key details that guide the reader toward an understanding that is not explicitly stated. In this passage, details such as the blue marks on the sign-in sheet matching Ava's outlining technique, the blue pencil falling from Ava's folder, and her admission of taking it work together to support the conclusion that Ava took the pencil to use on the class poster. Choice B is correct because it accurately reflects the logical outcome based on these details, showing an understanding of how the evidence points directly to Ava's specific purpose. Choice C is incorrect because it overlooks the fact that Tessa had her own blue pencil set and misinterprets the evidence by focusing on color preference rather than the actual clues. To help students master this skill, encourage them to identify and underline key details in a passage that contribute to the main idea or outcome. Remind them to distinguish between details that are central to the conclusion and those that are merely descriptive.