DSQ: Calculating the surface area of a cylinder - GMAT Quantitative

Card 1 of 136

0
Didn't Know
Knew It
0
1 of 2019 left
Question

Of Cylinder 1 and Cylinder 2, which, if either, has the greater surface area?

Statement 1: Cylinder 1 has bases with radius twice those of the bases of Cylinder 2.

Statement 2: The height of Cylinder 1 is half that of Cylinder 2.

Tap to reveal answer

Answer

We will let and stand for the radii of the bases of Cylinders 1 and 2, respectively, and and stand for their heights.

The surface area of Cylinder1 can be calculated from radius and height using the formula:

;

similarly, the surface area of Cylinder 2 is

Therefore, we are seeking to determine which, if either, is greater, or .

Statement 1 alone tells us that , but without knowing anything about the heights, we cannot compare to . Similarly, Statement 2 tells us that

, or, equivalently, , but without any information about the radii, again, we cannot determine which of and is the greater.

Now assume both statements to be true. Substituting for and for , Cylinder 1 has surface area:

.

Cylinder 2 has surface area

, so , and Cylinder 1 has the greater surface area.

← Didn't Know|Knew It →