Perfect Competition

Help Questions

AP Microeconomics › Perfect Competition

Questions 1 - 6
1

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, should the firm shut down in the short run? Assume the firm is a price taker with $P = MR = $11$.

Cost Table

  • Fixed cost (FC) = $25$
  • Variable cost (VC) by output: $Q=0:0$, $1:9$, $2:19$, $3:30$, $4:44$, $5:65$

Yes; shut down because $P < ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

Yes; shut down because $P < AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

No; produce because $P > AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

No; produce because $P = ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

Yes; exit immediately because $P < ATC$.

Explanation

The key skill here is understanding firm behavior in perfect competition, where firms decide output to maximize profit or minimize losses. A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker, meaning it accepts the market price as given, so its marginal revenue (MR) equals the price (P). To maximize profit, the firm produces the output level where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC), or the largest Q where MR >= MC in discrete data. Profit or loss is determined by comparing P to average total cost (ATC) at that output, while shutdown occurs if P < average variable cost (AVC), as this means variable costs aren't covered. A common misconception is confusing short-run shutdown with long-run exit; shutdown means temporarily producing zero to avoid variable costs, while exit means permanently leaving the market. A useful strategy is to first calculate MC from changes in VC and find the Q where MR >= MC. Then, compare P to ATC for profit/loss and to AVC for shutdown decisions.

2

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, should the firm shut down in the short run? Assume the firm is a price taker and the market price is $P = $12.

Cost Table

Quantity (Q): 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

Total Cost (TC): 25, 35, 42, 50, 65, 90

Yes; shut down because $P < ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output

No; produce because $P \ge ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output

No; produce where market demand intersects market supply

Yes; shut down because $P < AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output

No; produce because $P \ge AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output

Explanation

This question tests perfect competition firm behavior, specifically the shutdown decision in the short run. As a price taker at P = $12, the firm's marginal revenue equals $12 per unit. First, we find the profit-maximizing output by calculating marginal costs: MC from Q=2 to Q=3 is ($50-$42)/(3-2) = $8, and MC from Q=3 to Q=4 is ($65-$50)/(4-3) = $15. The firm produces where MR = MC, which occurs at Q = 3 (since $8 < $12 < $15). To determine shutdown, we need average variable cost (AVC) at Q = 3: with fixed cost of $25 (TC at Q=0), variable cost at Q=3 is $50-$25 = $25, so AVC = $25/3 = $8.33. Since P = $12 > AVC = $8.33, the firm should continue producing despite losses. A common misconception is that firms shut down whenever P < ATC; the correct rule is to shut down only when P < AVC. The transferable strategy is: find optimal output where MR = MC, calculate AVC at that output, and continue producing if P ≥ AVC.

3

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, what output level maximizes profit in the short run? Assume the market price is $P = MR = $20$.

Cost Table

  • Fixed cost (FC) = $36$
  • Variable cost (VC) by output: $Q=0:0$, $1:8$, $2:17$, $3:27$, $4:40$, $5:58$, $6:82$

$Q = 3$ units

$Q = 6$ units

$Q = 2$ units

$Q = 4$ units

$Q = 5$ units

Explanation

The key skill here is understanding firm behavior in perfect competition, where firms decide output to maximize profit or minimize losses. A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker, meaning it accepts the market price as given, so its marginal revenue (MR) equals the price (P). To maximize profit, the firm produces the output level where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC), or the largest Q where MR >= MC in discrete data. Profit or loss is determined by comparing P to average total cost (ATC) at that output, while shutdown occurs if P < average variable cost (AVC), as this means variable costs aren't covered. A common misconception is confusing short-run shutdown with long-run exit; shutdown means temporarily producing zero to avoid variable costs, while exit means permanently leaving the market. A useful strategy is to first calculate MC from changes in VC and find the Q where MR >= MC. Then, compare P to ATC for profit/loss and to AVC for shutdown decisions.

4

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, is the firm earning profit, loss, or normal profit at the profit-maximizing output in the short run? Assume the firm is a price taker with $P = MR = $16$.

Cost Table

  • Fixed cost (FC) = $28$
  • Variable cost (VC) by output: $Q=0:0$, $1:7$, $2:15$, $3:24$, $4:35$, $5:50$, $6:70$

The firm shuts down because $P < ATC$.

The firm exits in the short run because $P < AVC$.

The firm earns normal profit (break-even).

The firm earns an economic profit.

The firm earns a loss.

Explanation

The key skill here is understanding firm behavior in perfect competition, where firms decide output to maximize profit or minimize losses. A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker, meaning it accepts the market price as given, so its marginal revenue (MR) equals the price (P). To maximize profit, the firm produces the output level where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC), or the largest Q where MR >= MC in discrete data. Profit or loss is determined by comparing P to average total cost (ATC) at that output, while shutdown occurs if P < average variable cost (AVC), as this means variable costs aren't covered. A common misconception is confusing short-run shutdown with long-run exit; shutdown means temporarily producing zero to avoid variable costs, while exit means permanently leaving the market. A useful strategy is to first calculate MC from changes in VC and find the Q where MR >= MC. Then, compare P to ATC for profit/loss and to AVC for shutdown decisions.

5

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, should the firm shut down in the short run? Assume the firm is a price taker with $P = MR = $8$.

Cost Table

  • Fixed cost (FC) = $16$
  • Variable cost (VC) by output: $Q=0:0$, $1:6$, $2:13$, $3:21$, $4:32$

No; produce because $P > ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

No; produce because $P > AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

Yes; shut down because $P < ATC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

Yes; exit immediately because $P < ATC$.

Yes; shut down because $P < AVC$ at the profit-maximizing output.

Explanation

The key skill here is understanding firm behavior in perfect competition, where firms decide output to maximize profit or minimize losses. A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker, meaning it accepts the market price as given, so its marginal revenue (MR) equals the price (P). To maximize profit, the firm produces the output level where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC), or the largest Q where MR >= MC in discrete data. Profit or loss is determined by comparing P to average total cost (ATC) at that output, while shutdown occurs if P < average variable cost (AVC), as this means variable costs aren't covered. A common misconception is confusing short-run shutdown with long-run exit; shutdown means temporarily producing zero to avoid variable costs, while exit means permanently leaving the market. A useful strategy is to first calculate MC from changes in VC and find the Q where MR >= MC. Then, compare P to ATC for profit/loss and to AVC for shutdown decisions.

6

Based on the perfectly competitive firm’s cost and price information in the table, what output level maximizes profit in the short run? Assume the firm is a price taker and the market price is $P = $18.

Cost Table

Quantity (Q): 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

Total Cost (TC): 12, 24, 34, 45, 58, 74, 96

Produce $Q = 4$ units

Produce $Q = 6$ units

Produce $Q = 5$ units

Produce $Q = 3$ units

Produce $Q = 2$ units

Explanation

This question tests perfect competition firm behavior, where firms maximize profit by producing where marginal revenue equals marginal cost. As a price taker at P = $18, the firm's MR = $18 for each unit. Calculating marginal costs between quantities: MC from Q=4 to Q=5 is ($74-$58)/(5-4) = $16, and MC from Q=5 to Q=6 is ($96-$74)/(6-5) = $22. The firm produces where MR = MC; since $16 < $18 < $22, the optimal output is Q = 5. At this quantity, the firm earns total revenue of 5 × $18 = $90 versus total cost of $74, yielding profit of $16. A common error is choosing output based on lowest average cost rather than the MR = MC condition. The transferable strategy is: calculate MC for each interval, find where MC crosses the price level, and produce at the quantity just before MC exceeds price.