Gather Information and Assess Credibility
Help Questions
8th Grade Writing › Gather Information and Assess Credibility
You are researching: How does sleep affect middle school students’ learning? You read this sentence in a book (print source) by Dr. Lila Chen:
Original sentence (page 42): “Students who regularly get 8–10 hours of sleep show better attention and memory during lessons.”
In your notes, you wrote: “Students who regularly get 8–10 hours of sleep show better attention and memory during lessons.”
You did NOT use quotation marks or cite the book. Does this count as plagiarism?
Yes, because you copied the author’s exact words without quotation marks and without a citation.
Yes, but only if the book is more than 10 years old.
No, because you only copied one sentence.
No, because it is a fact and facts never need citations.
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Plagiarism occurs when someone uses another person's words, ideas, or work without proper attribution - in this case, the student copied Dr. Chen's exact sentence word-for-word without quotation marks or citation, which is a clear example of plagiarism regardless of the content being factual. Even when information seems like common knowledge or fact, if you copy the specific wording from a source, you must either use quotation marks with a citation or paraphrase the information in your own words with a citation. The correct answer C accurately identifies this as plagiarism because copying exact words without quotation marks and citation is intellectual theft, whether the content is one sentence or many. The incorrect options reflect common misconceptions: A wrongly assumes facts don't need citations when copied verbatim, B incorrectly suggests the amount copied matters for plagiarism, and D introduces an irrelevant factor about the source's age. To avoid plagiarism, students must always use quotation marks when copying exact words and include proper citations, or better yet, paraphrase the information in their own words while still providing attribution to the original source.
Research question: “What are the main causes of the Dust Bowl in the 1930s?”
Which piece of information is MOST relevant to include as evidence?
Data from a history book explaining how severe drought and poor farming practices left soil dry and vulnerable to wind erosion.
A list of famous baseball players from the Great Depression era.
An opinion post arguing the 1930s were “the best decade,” without mentioning farming or weather.
A description of popular radio shows families listened to during the 1930s.
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). When researching the causes of the Dust Bowl, students must identify information that directly addresses the "causes" aspect of their research question - the Dust Bowl was an environmental disaster caused by a combination of severe drought and poor farming practices that left soil vulnerable to wind erosion. The data about drought and farming practices (option B) directly explains what caused the Dust Bowl by identifying both the natural factor (drought) and human factor (poor farming methods) that created the conditions for massive dust storms. The correct answer demonstrates relevant information gathering by providing specific, factual evidence from a credible source (history book) that directly answers the "what caused" aspect of the research question. The incorrect options show common relevance mistakes: option A describes entertainment during the time period but doesn't address causes, option C lists sports figures which is completely unrelated to environmental causes, and option D presents an opinion without factual evidence about farming or weather conditions. To gather relevant information effectively, students should constantly refer back to their research question, look for evidence that directly answers the specific aspect being researched (in this case, "causes"), and distinguish between interesting contextual information and essential evidence. This focused approach ensures that research papers stay on topic and build strong, evidence-based arguments.
You are writing a report on food waste in the United States. You want to use this exact sentence from a print magazine article.
Original sentence from the magazine: “About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year.”
Source details:
- Author: Jamie Lee
- Article title: “The Hidden Cost of Food Waste”
- Magazine: Science Weekly
- Year: 2022
- Page: 18
Which option shows the correct way to use the sentence in your paper (quote + simplified MLA in-text citation)?
A) About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year. (Lee 18) B) Jamie Lee says that “About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year” (Lee 18). C) “About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year” (Jamie 2022). D) “About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year.” (Science Weekly)
About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year. (Lee 18)
“About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year.” (Science Weekly)
“About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year” (Jamie 2022).
Jamie Lee says that “About 30 to 40 percent of the U.S. food supply is wasted each year” (Lee 18).
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B correctly demonstrates how to incorporate a direct quote with proper attribution and citation: it introduces the quote with the author's name (Jamie Lee), uses quotation marks around the exact words from the source, and includes a proper parenthetical citation with the author's last name and page number (Lee 18). This format gives credit to the original author, clearly indicates which words are quoted, and provides the information needed to find the source. The correct answer shows the proper integration of quoted material with appropriate MLA citation format for 8th grade. The incorrect options demonstrate common citation errors: choice A presents the quote as the student's own words without quotation marks (plagiarism), choice C uses the author's first name instead of last name in the citation, and choice D cites the magazine title instead of the author. When using direct quotes, students must use quotation marks around the exact words, provide attribution through an introduction or parenthetical citation with the author's last name and page number, and ensure the quote is integrated smoothly into their own sentence structure.
Research question: How do invasive zebra mussels affect Great Lakes ecosystems?
You found these notes from different sources. Which note is most relevant to the research question?
A) “Zebra mussels were first found in the Great Lakes in the late 1980s after arriving in ballast water.”
B) “The Great Lakes contain about 20% of the world’s surface freshwater.”
C) “Zebra mussels filter large amounts of water, which can reduce plankton available for native species and change the food web.”
D) “Mussels are a type of bivalve that can be found in both saltwater and freshwater habitats.”
“Zebra mussels were first found in the Great Lakes in the late 1980s after arriving in ballast water.”
“Mussels are a type of bivalve that can be found in both saltwater and freshwater habitats.”
“The Great Lakes contain about 20% of the world’s surface freshwater.”
“Zebra mussels filter large amounts of water, which can reduce plankton available for native species and change the food web.”
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice C provides the most relevant information because it directly addresses how zebra mussels affect Great Lakes ecosystems by explaining their impact on the food web through filtering water and reducing plankton for native species. This note contains specific cause-and-effect information that answers the "how" in the research question about ecosystem effects. While the other notes provide context or background information, only choice C explains the actual ecological impact that is central to the research question. The correct answer demonstrates effective information gathering by identifying content that directly addresses the research focus on ecosystem effects. The incorrect options show common relevance mistakes: choice A provides historical context but not current effects, choice B offers general Great Lakes information unrelated to zebra mussels, and choice D gives broad mussel classification without specific Great Lakes ecosystem impacts. When gathering information for research, students should evaluate each source or note by asking whether it directly helps answer their specific research question, prioritizing information that addresses the key concepts and relationships in their inquiry.
You are researching: Should schools start later to improve middle school student sleep?
A student writes this sentence in the draft:
“Teen brains naturally fall asleep later, so early school start times reduce total sleep and can harm learning.”
The student got this idea from a 2022 article on the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) website but did not use quotation marks or a citation.
Does this count as plagiarism?
A) No, because it is common knowledge that teens like to stay up late
B) Yes, because the student used an idea from a source without giving credit
C) No, because the student changed the wording and did not copy exact sentences
D) Yes, but only if the student also copied pictures or graphs from the AAP website
Yes, but only if the student also copied pictures or graphs from the AAP website
No, because it is common knowledge that teens like to stay up late
No, because the student changed the wording and did not copy exact sentences
Yes, because the student used an idea from a source without giving credit
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B correctly identifies this as plagiarism because the student used specific information from a source (the AAP article about teen sleep patterns) without providing any attribution, even though the wording was changed. Plagiarism includes using someone else's ideas, not just their exact words, without giving credit through proper citation. The fact that the student paraphrased rather than quoted directly does not excuse the lack of attribution - both direct quotes and paraphrases require citations to avoid plagiarism. The correct answer recognizes that using source material without credit violates academic integrity, regardless of whether the words were changed. The incorrect options reflect common misconceptions: choice A wrongly assumes general topics don't need citations, choice C mistakenly believes paraphrasing eliminates the need for attribution, and choice D incorrectly limits plagiarism to visual materials. To avoid plagiarism, students must cite all information that comes from sources, whether quoted directly or paraphrased, unless it is truly common knowledge (facts known by most people without needing to look them up).
You are writing a report on plastic pollution in oceans. You used a webpage from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
Source details:
- Organization/Author: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
- Page title: “Marine Debris: Plastics”
- Website: noaa.gov
- Published/Updated: 2023
- URL: https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris
Which is the best simplified MLA Works Cited entry for an 8th-grade paper?
A) NOAA. “Marine Debris: Plastics.” noaa.gov. 2023. https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris B) National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. “Marine Debris: Plastics.” NOAA, 2023, https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris. C) “Marine Debris: Plastics.” 2023. https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris D) National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (2023). Marine Debris: Plastics. Retrieved from https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris
NOAA. “Marine Debris: Plastics.” noaa.gov. 2023. https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris
“Marine Debris: Plastics.” 2023. https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (2023). Marine Debris: Plastics. Retrieved from https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. “Marine Debris: Plastics.” NOAA, 2023, https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/marine-debris.
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B demonstrates the correct simplified MLA format for a website citation appropriate for 8th grade: it begins with the full organization name (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration), includes the page title in quotation marks, lists the website name in italics (NOAA), provides the year, and ends with the URL followed by a period. This format properly attributes the source to avoid plagiarism while following standard MLA conventions adapted for middle school students. The correct answer includes all essential elements in the proper order and punctuation, making it easy for readers to locate the original source. The incorrect options show common citation errors: choice A uses only the abbreviation instead of the full organization name, choice C omits the author/organization entirely, and choice D uses APA format with parentheses and "Retrieved from" which is not MLA style. When creating Works Cited entries, students should include the author or organization, title in quotes, website name in italics, publication year, and URL, ensuring proper punctuation and order to maintain academic integrity and allow verification of sources.
You are researching: What are the health effects of vaping on teenagers? You gathered sources from print and digital places:
-
Print book (library): “Teen Health Today” (2021), written by a pediatrician, published by an educational publisher
-
Digital: CDC webpage on e-cigarettes (cdc.gov), updated 2024
-
Digital: Peer-reviewed journal article (2020) about nicotine addiction in adolescents
-
Digital: Influencer video (no sources listed) claiming vaping is “just water vapor”
Which research plan shows the best credibility assessment and use of sources?
A) Use the influencer video as the main source because it is the most recent and easiest to understand; ignore the journal article because it is too technical
B) Use the CDC webpage and the peer-reviewed journal article as primary evidence, use the print book for background definitions, and mention the influencer video only as an example of misinformation
C) Use only the print book because online sources can be edited; do not use any digital sources
D) Use all four sources equally because using more sources automatically makes the report accurate
Use the CDC webpage and the peer-reviewed journal article as primary evidence, use the print book for background definitions, and mention the influencer video only as an example of misinformation
Use the influencer video as the main source because it is the most recent and easiest to understand; ignore the journal article because it is too technical
Use all four sources equally because using more sources automatically makes the report accurate
Use only the print book because online sources can be edited; do not use any digital sources
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B demonstrates the best research plan by prioritizing the most credible sources (CDC webpage and peer-reviewed journal) for primary evidence due to their authority and scientific rigor, using the print book appropriately for background information, and acknowledging the influencer video only as an example of misinformation rather than ignoring it completely. This approach shows sophisticated source evaluation that considers authority (government health agency, peer review, medical author), currency (2024 CDC update), accuracy (peer review process), and bias (identifying the influencer's lack of sources). The correct answer reflects proper credibility assessment across multiple source types and appropriate use based on each source's strengths. The incorrect options show poor source evaluation: choice A prioritizes the least credible source, choice C dismisses all digital sources based on a misconception, and choice D fails to differentiate between source quality. When gathering information from multiple sources, students should assess each source's credibility individually, use the most authoritative sources for main evidence, acknowledge less credible sources appropriately, and recognize that more sources don't automatically mean better research if the sources lack credibility.
You are researching: How does climate change affect the frequency of extreme heat events in the United States? You found four digital sources.
Which source is most credible to use for scientific evidence in your report?
A) NASA Climate website article (climate.nasa.gov), updated 2024, written by NASA staff and explaining temperature trends with links to data
B) Personal blog post on “RealWeatherTruth.com,” no author last name, no date, claims heat waves are “a hoax,” no sources cited
C) Social media thread with screenshots of graphs, posted by an anonymous account, no links to original data
D) Online store page selling “heat-proof” supplements, includes a short paragraph about climate change but mainly promotes products
Personal blog post on “RealWeatherTruth.com,” no author last name, no date, claims heat waves are “a hoax,” no sources cited
Social media thread with screenshots of graphs, posted by an anonymous account, no links to original data
Online store page selling “heat-proof” supplements, includes a short paragraph about climate change but mainly promotes products
NASA Climate website article (climate.nasa.gov), updated 2024, written by NASA staff and explaining temperature trends with links to data
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). The NASA Climate website (choice A) demonstrates the highest credibility because it comes from a government scientific agency (.gov domain), has expert authors (NASA staff), is current (updated 2024), provides transparent data links, and focuses on scientific evidence rather than opinion or commercial interests. The personal blog lacks author credentials and sources, the social media post is anonymous without verifiable data, and the commercial site has a clear bias toward selling products rather than providing objective information. The correct answer shows proper source evaluation by identifying authority (NASA), currency (2024), accuracy (data links), and lack of bias. The incorrect options fail credibility tests: choice B lacks author credentials and sources while making extreme claims, choice C provides no attribution or original sources, and choice D has commercial bias. When gathering information for research, students should prioritize sources from established scientific or educational institutions, check for recent updates, verify author expertise, look for citations to original data, and avoid sources with commercial interests or extreme claims without evidence.
You are writing about how social media affects teen mental health. You read this sentence from a digital article:
Original source sentence (from a 2023 report on a .gov public health website):
“Frequent social media use is associated with higher levels of anxiety symptoms among adolescents, although it does not prove that social media causes anxiety.”
Which option is the best paraphrase that avoids plagiarism and includes a simple citation?
A) Frequent social media use is associated with higher levels of anxiety symptoms among adolescents, although it does not prove that social media causes anxiety. (U.S. Public Health Agency)
B) Teens who use social media a lot may show more anxiety symptoms, but this connection does not mean social media is definitely the cause. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
C) Social media causes anxiety in adolescents who use it frequently. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
D) Using social media is linked to anxiety symptoms in adolescents, although it does not prove that social media causes anxiety. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
Frequent social media use is associated with higher levels of anxiety symptoms among adolescents, although it does not prove that social media causes anxiety. (U.S. Public Health Agency)
Teens who use social media a lot may show more anxiety symptoms, but this connection does not mean social media is definitely the cause. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
Using social media is linked to anxiety symptoms in adolescents, although it does not prove that social media causes anxiety. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
Social media causes anxiety in adolescents who use it frequently. (U.S. Public Health Agency, 2023)
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B demonstrates the best paraphrase because it successfully rewrites the original idea in completely different words ("teens who use social media a lot" instead of "frequent social media use," "may show" instead of "is associated with"), maintains the original meaning including the important caveat about causation, and includes a proper parenthetical citation with the source and year. This paraphrase avoids plagiarism by thoroughly changing the sentence structure and vocabulary while preserving the accurate meaning and providing attribution. The correct answer shows proper paraphrasing technique with appropriate citation format for 8th grade. The incorrect options demonstrate common paraphrasing errors: choice A copies the exact original text (which requires quotation marks), choice C changes the meaning by incorrectly stating causation when the original only claimed association, and choice D keeps too much of the original wording and structure. When paraphrasing, students should completely rewrite ideas in their own words, maintain the original meaning without distortion, and always include a citation to credit the source and avoid plagiarism.
You are researching: How do wildfires affect air quality and health? You found an online article and want to decide if it is credible.
Source details:
- Title: “Wildfire Smoke: What You Need to Know”
- Author: Dr. Elena Ruiz, MPH (public health researcher)
- Website: statehealth.gov
- Date: Updated 2024
- Includes: links to studies, explains limitations, no products for sale
Which credibility judgment is best?
A) Not credible because it is on the internet, so anyone could change it B) Credible because it is a government public health site, has an expert author, is recently updated, and links to evidence C) Not credible because it does not include personal stories from wildfire survivors D) Credible only if it agrees with the first website you find on Google
Not credible because it is on the internet, so anyone could change it
Not credible because it does not include personal stories from wildfire survivors
Credible because it is a government public health site, has an expert author, is recently updated, and links to evidence
Credible only if it agrees with the first website you find on Google
Explanation
This question tests gathering relevant information from multiple print and digital sources using effective search terms, assessing source credibility and accuracy (authority, publication type, currency, bias), quoting or paraphrasing data and conclusions properly (with citation), avoiding plagiarism (attributing all source material), and following standard citation format (MLA or APA simplified for 8th grade). Choice B correctly identifies this source as credible because it meets multiple reliability criteria: it's published on a government health website (.gov domain indicating official status), has an expert author with relevant credentials (Dr. with MPH degree), provides current information (updated 2024), includes links to supporting studies showing transparency, acknowledges limitations demonstrating objectivity, and has no commercial bias. These factors combine to make it a trustworthy source for academic research on wildfire health effects. The correct answer demonstrates proper credibility assessment using multiple evaluation criteria. The incorrect options reflect common misconceptions about source credibility: choice A dismisses all internet sources despite many being highly reliable, choice C incorrectly requires personal anecdotes for credibility when scientific sources often exclude them for objectivity, and choice D suggests verification through agreement with random searches rather than evaluating the source itself. When assessing digital source credibility, students should examine the publisher's authority, author expertise, publication date, presence of citations, acknowledgment of limitations, and absence of commercial bias rather than making blanket judgments about internet sources.