Draw Information From Multiple Sources
Help Questions
5th Grade Reading › Draw Information From Multiple Sources
Source A: Passage — “Weather Tools and Forecasts”
Meteorologists are scientists who study weather. They use tools to measure conditions in the air. A thermometer measures temperature. A rain gauge measures how much rain falls. An anemometer measures wind speed. When meteorologists collect data each day, they can notice patterns, such as a rainy season or a dry season. Patterns help them make better forecasts for the next week.
Source B: Table — “Daily Weather Data for One Week”
According to Source A and Source B, which tool would be most useful for explaining why plants might need extra watering during this week?
Anemometer, because wind speed was zero all week.
Thermometer, because temperatures were below freezing.
Thermometer, because temperatures were exactly the same every day.
Rain gauge, because rainfall was low on most days.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about weather tools, explaining that 'A rain gauge measures how much rain falls' and that meteorologists use these tools to notice patterns like 'a rainy season or a dry season.' The table provides specific weather data showing very low rainfall throughout the week: only 0.1 inches on Monday and 0.0 inches all other days, despite varying temperatures (45-72°F) and wind speeds (0-15 mph). To answer this question, students must connect the low rainfall data with the passage's information about dry conditions and plant watering needs. Choice B is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows extremely low rainfall (only 0.1 inches total for the entire week), and the passage mentions dry seasons as a pattern meteorologists notice, which would explain why plants need extra watering. This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice A represents focusing on the wrong data - while temperatures varied, they weren't below freezing (lowest was 45°F), and temperature alone doesn't explain watering needs as directly as lack of rainfall does. Students who select this may have misread the temperature data or not understood the connection between rainfall and plant watering. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (tool to explain need for watering plants), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (passage describes what each tool measures, table shows actual measurements), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find rain gauge description, check rainfall data in table), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create a chart matching each weather tool to its data column in the table, then analyze which data best explains plant watering needs. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (match tool descriptions to data columns), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks which tool explains why plants need extra water. Let me check each tool's data: temperatures are above freezing, wind varies but isn't extreme, but rainfall is almost zero all week! A rain gauge would show this dry condition.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) select based on extreme values without considering relevance to the question, (b) don't connect weather conditions to plant needs, (c) confuse which tool measures which type of data. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'according to Source A and Source B,' 'most useful for explaining'—these require matching information across sources to solve a specific problem.
Source A: Passage — “Why Cities Have Heat Islands”
A heat island is a part of a city that gets warmer than nearby areas. Dark roofs and roads absorb sunlight and hold heat. Trees and plants can cool places because they provide shade and release water vapor. On hot days, shaded parks may feel cooler than streets with no trees. Some cities paint roofs lighter colors and plant more trees to reduce heat.
Source B: Table — “Afternoon Temperatures in Different Places”
Use information from both sources to choose the location that most likely has the strongest heat island effect.
City park with many trees, 86°F
Downtown street with dark pavement and few trees, 94°F
Lakeside trail with water nearby, 85°F
Neighborhood with light-colored roofs, 88°F
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about heat islands, explaining that 'Dark roofs and roads absorb sunlight and hold heat' while 'Trees and plants can cool places because they provide shade and release water vapor.' The table provides specific temperature data for different locations: City park with many trees (86°F), Neighborhood with light-colored roofs (88°F), Downtown street with dark pavement and few trees (94°F), and Lakeside trail with water nearby (85°F). To answer this question, students must identify which location has characteristics of a heat island (from the passage) and the highest temperature (from the table). Choice C is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the passage explains that dark pavement and lack of trees create heat islands, and the table shows this location has the highest temperature at 94°F. This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice D represents the opposite - it has the coolest temperature and features (water, trail) that reduce heat rather than create heat islands. Students who select this may have confused which conditions create versus prevent heat islands. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (strongest heat island effect), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (passage explains what causes heat islands, table shows temperatures), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find heat island characteristics in passage, find highest temperature in table), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create a chart with 'Heat Island Characteristics from Passage' (dark surfaces, few trees) and 'Temperature Data from Table' then match characteristics to locations. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find data matching description), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks for the strongest heat island effect. The passage says dark pavement and few trees cause heat islands. Let me check the table - the downtown street has dark pavement, few trees, AND the highest temperature at 94°F. That matches!' Common difficulties: Students often (a) focus only on temperature without considering the described characteristics, (b) confuse cause and effect (what creates heat vs. what reduces it), (c) select based on keywords without full comprehension. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'use information from both sources,' 'most likely'—these mean you need to synthesize information from multiple sources to draw conclusions.
Source A: Passage — “Reading a Food Label”
Food labels help people compare foods. The serving size tells how much the nutrition numbers describe. Calories show how much energy a food gives. Some nutrients, like fiber, can help digestion. Other nutrients, like added sugar, are best in smaller amounts. When comparing two snacks, it helps to look at the serving size first. Then you can compare calories and nutrients fairly.
Source B: Table — “Two Snack Labels (Per Serving)”
Based on Source A and Source B, which snack is the better choice for someone trying to eat less added sugar while keeping serving sizes the same?
Snack A, because it has fewer calories.
Snack B, because it has less added sugar per serving.
Snack B, because it has a larger serving size.
Snack A, because it has more fiber.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about reading food labels, explaining that 'added sugar, are best in smaller amounts' and emphasizing the importance of comparing serving sizes first to make fair comparisons. The table provides specific nutritional data: Snack A has 8g added sugar with 1 cup serving size, while Snack B has 5g added sugar with 1 cup serving size (same serving sizes make comparison straightforward). To answer this question, students must identify which snack has less added sugar when serving sizes are equal, as specified in the question. Choice B is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows Snack B has only 5g of added sugar compared to Snack A's 8g, and since both have the same serving size (1 cup), this is a fair comparison as the passage recommends. This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice A represents focusing on the wrong nutrient - the question specifically asks about added sugar, not calories. Students who select this may have defaulted to looking at calories without carefully reading what the question asked for. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (less added sugar, same serving sizes), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (passage explains how to compare, table has the numbers), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find added sugar row in table, note serving sizes are equal), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create a comparison chart highlighting only the relevant data (added sugar and serving size) from the table. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find specific data matching criteria), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks for less added sugar while keeping serving sizes the same. First, I check serving sizes - both are 1 cup, so that's equal. Now I compare added sugar - Snack A has 8g, Snack B has 5g. Since 5 is less than 8, Snack B is the better choice.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) compare the wrong nutrient (calories instead of sugar), (b) ignore the serving size requirement, (c) get confused by multiple numbers in tables. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'based on Source A and Source B,' underlined words, 'while keeping serving sizes the same'—these provide specific criteria that must be met using both sources.
Source A: Passage — “How a Community Saves Water”
A town can save water by using it wisely at home and outdoors. Shorter showers and turning off the faucet while brushing teeth can reduce daily water use. Outdoors, watering early in the morning helps because less water evaporates in the heat. Planting native plants can also help, since they often need less watering. When many families make small changes, the town can save a large amount of water over time.
Source B: Table — “Water Used by One Family in One Week”
Use information from both sources to decide which change would most likely save the most water for this family in one week.
Reduce dishwashing by 10 gallons.
Reduce cooking and drinking water by 5 gallons.
Reduce handwashing by 15 gallons.
Reduce lawn watering by 100 gallons.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides strategies for saving water, emphasizing that outdoor watering can be reduced by watering early in the morning and using native plants that need less water. The table provides specific data showing weekly water usage: Lawn watering (350 gallons), Showers (280 gallons), Dishwashing (70 gallons), Handwashing (105 gallons), and Cooking/drinking (35 gallons). To answer this question, students must identify the largest water use category from the table and connect it to water-saving strategies mentioned in the passage. Choice A is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows lawn watering uses the most water at 350 gallons per week, and the passage specifically mentions outdoor watering as an area where water can be saved. This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice B represents looking at a smaller usage category - dishwashing only uses 70 gallons compared to lawn watering's 350 gallons. Students who select this may have failed to compare all the numbers in the table or didn't identify the largest value. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (which change saves the MOST water), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (table has amounts, passage has strategies), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find largest number in table, find related strategy in passage), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create two-column chart with 'Water Use from Table' and 'Saving Strategies from Passage' then identify connections. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find data matching description), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks which change would save the MOST water. Let me check the table - lawn watering uses 350 gallons, that's the highest! The passage mentions outdoor watering can be reduced. So reducing lawn watering by 100 gallons would save the most.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) answer using only one source without checking the other, (b) don't compare all values in a table to find the maximum, (c) select based on personal experience rather than data. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'use information from both sources,' 'most likely'—these mean you need to look at more than one source and make comparisons.
Source A: Passage — “Why Some Animals Migrate”
Many animals migrate, which means they move from one place to another during the year. Animals migrate to find food, to have babies in safer places, or to avoid very cold weather. Some birds fly south in winter because insects and seeds are harder to find when snow covers the ground. Other animals, like whales, travel to warmer waters where newborns can stay warm. Migration can be risky because animals must use a lot of energy and avoid predators. Scientists often track migration to learn how animals use different habitats in different seasons.
Source B: Table — “Miles Traveled by Three Migrating Animals (One Way)”
Use information from Source A and Source B to choose the statement that is supported by both sources.
The monarch butterfly migrates because snow always covers the ground where it lives.
The Arctic tern likely migrates to find warmer water for its newborns.
Migration can require a lot of energy, and some animals travel thousands of miles.
All migrating animals travel the same distance each year.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides general information about why animals migrate (to find food, have babies in safer places, avoid cold weather) and mentions that migration can be risky because it requires a lot of energy. The table provides specific data showing that migrating animals travel different distances: Arctic tern (11,000 miles), Monarch butterfly (2,500 miles), and Gray whale (6,000 miles). To answer this question, students must combine the general concept from the text about energy requirements with the specific distance data from the table. Choice C is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the passage states that migration 'can be risky because animals must use a lot of energy' and the table shows animals traveling thousands of miles (2,500 to 11,000 miles). This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice D represents a misread of the data - the table clearly shows three different distances (11,000, 2,500, and 6,000 miles), not the same distance. Students who select this may have glanced at the table without carefully reading the numbers or made an incorrect generalization. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed, (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information, (3) Locate specific information in each source, (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create two-column chart with 'Information from Text' and 'Information from Table' then a row for 'Combined Answer.' Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find data matching description), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation), text + timeline (find details about dates). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks about statements supported by both sources. The passage tells me migration requires a lot of energy. Now I need to check the table to see the distances - wow, thousands of miles! When I combine these, answer C matches both sources.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) answer using only one source without checking the other, (b) misread visual data (wrong column, wrong number), (c) don't recognize when synthesis is required. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'use information from Source A and Source B,' 'supported by both sources'—these mean you need to look at more than one source.
Source A: Passage — “Erosion and Plant Roots”
Erosion happens when wind or water carries soil away. Heavy rain can wash soil downhill, especially where the ground is bare. Plant roots help prevent erosion because they hold soil in place like a net. Leaves and grass also slow down rainwater so it does not hit the ground as hard. People can reduce erosion by planting grass on slopes, leaving some leaves on the ground, and building paths where many people walk.
Source B: Table — “Soil Collected After One Rainstorm”
Based on Source A and Source B, which conclusion is best supported?
Plant roots make erosion worse because they loosen the soil.
Concrete absorbs rainwater, so it causes the most erosion.
Wind causes more erosion than rain in all locations.
Bare soil loses more soil during rain, and plants can help hold soil in place.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about erosion and how plants prevent it, explaining that 'Plant roots help prevent erosion because they hold soil in place like a net' and that erosion is worse 'especially where the ground is bare.' The table provides specific data showing soil collected after rain: Bare soil area (8 pounds), Grassy area (2 pounds), Area with bushes (1 pound), and Concrete path (0 pounds). To answer this question, students must connect the passage's explanation about plant roots preventing erosion with the data showing different amounts of soil loss. Choice A is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows bare soil lost the most soil (8 pounds) while areas with plants lost much less (2 pounds for grass, 1 pound for bushes), and the passage explains that plant roots 'hold soil in place.' This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice D represents the opposite of what both sources show - the passage states roots help prevent erosion, and the data confirms areas with plants lost less soil. Students who select this may have misunderstood the relationship between plants and erosion or misread the data. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (conclusion about erosion), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (passage explains how erosion works, table shows actual measurements), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find explanation of plant roots in passage, compare soil amounts in table), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create two-column chart with 'What Passage Says About Plants/Erosion' and 'What Data Shows' then draw conclusions. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find data supporting explanation), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The passage says plant roots hold soil in place. Let me check the table - bare soil lost 8 pounds, but grassy area only lost 2 pounds and bushes only 1 pound. This data proves what the passage says - plants do help prevent erosion!' Common difficulties: Students often (a) answer using only one source without checking the other, (b) misinterpret inverse relationships (more plants = less erosion), (c) don't recognize when data confirms or contradicts text explanations. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'based on Source A and Source B,' 'which conclusion is best supported'—these mean you need to look at both sources and see how they work together.
Source A: Passage — “School Recycling Choices”
A school can recycle different materials, but each material needs its own bin. Paper is often the easiest to recycle at school because it is used in many classrooms. Plastic bottles can also be recycled, but students must empty them first. Aluminum cans are valuable because they can be recycled into new cans. To improve recycling, students can place bins where people use the materials most, such as near the cafeteria and copy room.
Source B: Table — “Items Collected During One Week”
Use information from Source A and Source B to choose the best place to add a new paper recycling bin.
Near the gym, because it collected the most cans.
Near the copy room, because paper is used often and many sheets were collected.
Near the main office, because it collected the most plastic bottles.
Near the playground, because students spend the most time there.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about recycling strategies, specifically stating that 'Paper is often the easiest to recycle at school because it is used in many classrooms' and suggesting placing bins 'where people use the materials most, such as near the cafeteria and copy room.' The table provides specific data showing items collected at different locations: Near copy room collected 450 sheets of paper (the highest paper amount), Near cafeteria collected 85 aluminum cans, Near gym collected 120 plastic bottles, and Near main office collected 75 sheets of paper. To answer this question, students must identify where paper is used most based on the collection data and connect this to the passage's strategy about bin placement. Choice B is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows the copy room area collected the most paper (450 sheets), and the passage specifically mentions the copy room as a place where materials are used most. This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice A represents focusing on the wrong material - the question asks specifically about paper recycling bins, not cans. Students who select this may have looked for the highest number overall without paying attention to which material the question specified. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (best place for PAPER recycling bin), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (table has collection amounts by location, passage has placement strategy), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find paper amounts in table, find placement advice in passage), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create a chart highlighting only paper collection data from the table, then match to placement strategies from the passage. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (find data matching description), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The question asks about a PAPER recycling bin. Let me check the table for paper amounts only - copy room has 450 sheets, main office has 75. The passage says to place bins where materials are used most. Since copy room collected the most paper, that's the best place.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) answer based on the highest number without checking if it's the right material, (b) miss key words in questions (like 'paper' being underlined), (c) don't distinguish between different materials in mixed data. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'use information from Source A and Source B,' underlined words—these indicate specific focus areas requiring careful attention to both sources.
Source A: Passage — “Planning a Class Garden”
A class garden grows best when plants get enough sunlight and water. Some plants, like tomatoes, need lots of sun. Others, like lettuce, can grow with less sun. Gardeners also think about how much space each plant needs. If plants are too close together, they may not get enough nutrients. Measuring and planning before planting helps a garden stay healthy.
Source B: Table — “Sunlight and Space Needs for Three Plants”
Using information from both sources, which plant is the best choice for a small garden bed that gets only about 4 hours of sunlight each day?
Lettuce, because it needs less sunlight and less space than tomatoes.
Tomatoes, because they grow best with less sun.
Tomatoes, because they need the most space.
Carrots, because they need 8 hours of sunlight.
Explanation
This question assesses CCSS.RI.5.7: drawing on information from multiple print or digital sources, demonstrating the ability to locate an answer to a question quickly or to solve a problem efficiently. The passage provides information about garden planning, explaining that 'Some plants, like tomatoes, need lots of sun. Others, like lettuce, can grow with less sun' and emphasizing the importance of considering both sunlight and space requirements. The table provides specific data showing: Tomatoes need 6-8 hours sunlight and 18 inches space, Lettuce needs 3-4 hours sunlight and 6 inches space, and Carrots need 6-8 hours sunlight and 3 inches space. To answer this question, students must identify which plant can grow in only 4 hours of sunlight (eliminating those needing 6-8 hours) AND requires less space for a small garden bed. Choice C is correct because it accurately integrates information from both sources: the table shows lettuce only needs 3-4 hours of sunlight (matching the 4-hour constraint) and requires just 6 inches of space, while the passage confirms lettuce 'can grow with less sun.' This demonstrates the student successfully navigated between different formats and synthesized the information. Choice A represents focusing on only one constraint - while the passage mentions space considerations, tomatoes need 6-8 hours of sun according to the table, which exceeds the garden's 4-hour availability. Students who select this may have only considered space without checking the sunlight requirement. To help students use multiple sources: Teach a systematic approach: (1) Read the question and identify what information is needed (plant for 4 hours sun AND small space), (2) Determine which source(s) contain relevant information (passage provides context, table has specific requirements), (3) Locate specific information in each source (find sunlight hours and space for each plant), (4) Combine or synthesize information from both sources to form answer, (5) Check answer against all sources. Use graphic organizers: create a chart with columns for 'Sunlight Needed,' 'Space Needed,' and 'Fits 4-hour Garden?' to systematically evaluate each option. Practice different text-visual pairings: text + table (match multiple criteria from data), text + graph (identify trend explained in text), text + diagram (connect labels to explanation). Model think-aloud: 'The garden gets only 4 hours of sun and is small. Let me check each plant: Tomatoes need 6-8 hours - that's too much sun! Carrots also need 6-8 hours - too much! Lettuce needs only 3-4 hours - perfect! And it only needs 6 inches of space.' Common difficulties: Students often (a) focus on only one criterion when multiple are specified, (b) misread ranges (thinking 6-8 hours includes 4 hours), (c) select based on prior knowledge rather than the data provided. Teach signal phrases in questions: 'using information from both sources,' multiple criteria with 'AND'—these require checking all conditions against data from multiple sources.