SHSAT ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTS • ELA: REVISING AND EDITING — PART A

Best Concluding Sentence — Choose the best concluding sentence that matches the passage's focus.

Learn to pick the ending that wraps up a paragraph's main idea clearly and completely.

Why Concluding Sentences Matter

Have you ever watched a movie that just… stopped? No ending, no wrap-up, nothing. It feels weird, right? That's exactly what happens when a paragraph is missing a good concluding sentence (the final sentence that ties together everything the paragraph talked about). Writers and teachers have spent centuries thinking about the best way to end a piece of writing.

~350 BCE
Aristotle's Three-Part Structure
The Greek philosopher Aristotle taught that every speech or essay needs a beginning, a middle, and an end. He argued that the ending must circle back to the main point.
1866
Alexander Bain and the Modern Paragraph
Scottish professor Alexander Bain wrote one of the first textbooks explaining that a paragraph should have a single topic and finish with a sentence that reinforces that topic.
1950s
Standardized Test Era Begins
Schools and testing companies started using multiple-choice questions to measure whether students could recognize well-organized writing, including strong concluding sentences.
Today
The SHSAT and Revising/Editing
The SHSAT tests your ability to choose the best concluding sentence for a passage. You must understand the paragraph's main idea and pick the ending that matches it.

So the big question is: how do you figure out which concluding sentence is the best match for a paragraph? That's exactly what this lesson will teach you, step by step.

Core Principles of a Strong Concluding Sentence

Before you can choose the best concluding sentence, you need to know what makes a concluding sentence strong in the first place. There are a few core rules to follow. Think of these as a checklist you can use every time.

1

Echoes the Main Idea

A strong concluding sentence connects back to the paragraph's topic sentence (the sentence that states the main idea, usually near the beginning). It restates the point using different words.
2

Stays on Topic

It does NOT introduce a brand-new idea. If the paragraph is about dolphins' intelligence, the last sentence should not suddenly switch to shark habitats.
3

Feels Like an Ending

Good concluding sentences use a tone that signals "we're wrapping up." They might summarize, offer a final thought, or leave the reader with something to think about.
4

Matches the Passage's Tone

If the passage is informational and serious, the concluding sentence should be too. If the passage is persuasive, the ending should reinforce the argument.
KEY TAKEAWAY
Think of a concluding sentence like the bow on a gift. The gift is the paragraph, and the bow pulls everything together into a neat finish. If you stick a random sticker on instead of a bow, it looks out of place. In the same way, the concluding sentence has to match the gift — the paragraph's main idea.

How a Paragraph Flows to Its Conclusion

The diagram below shows how the parts of a well-organized paragraph connect. Notice how the topic sentence at the top sets the main idea, the supporting details build on it, and the concluding sentence brings everything back to that original point.

The gold dashed arrow on the right shows that the concluding sentence must loop back to the topic sentence. The supporting details in purple build the path between them.

When you face a "best concluding sentence" question on the SHSAT, picture this diagram in your head. Read the passage, find the main idea, and then pick the answer choice that loops back to it — just like the gold dashed arrow.

The 4-Step Strategy: How to Choose the Best Concluding Sentence

On the SHSAT, you'll read a short passage and then see a question like: "Which sentence would best conclude this paragraph?" Here's a step-by-step method you can use every single time.

Step 1 — Find the Main Idea

Read the passage carefully. Ask yourself: "What is this paragraph mostly about?" Look at the topic sentence (usually the first sentence) for clues. You can underline or circle it.

Step 2 — Note the Supporting Details

What examples, facts, or reasons does the writer give? These details point you toward the focus of the passage. The concluding sentence should fit with all of them.

Step 3 — Eliminate Wrong Answers

Cross out any answer choice that introduces a new topic, contradicts the passage, or changes the tone (the feeling or attitude of the writing). These are common traps.

Step 4 — Pick the One That Wraps Up

The remaining choice should feel like a natural ending. It should echo the main idea, summarize the key point, or leave the reader with a final thought that matches the passage. That's your answer!

💡 SHSAT Tip
If two answer choices both seem related to the main idea, reread the passage one more time. The best concluding sentence will match the specific focus of the paragraph — not just the general topic.

Common Wrong-Answer Traps

The SHSAT is tricky. The test writers design wrong answers that look reasonable but actually don't belong. Let's study the most common trap types so you can spot them right away.

Four common wrong-answer types branch off the main idea. The correct concluding sentence (green box) restates the main idea — "dogs are loyal companions" — using slightly different words, without introducing new topics, shifting tone, being too narrow, or contradicting the passage.
Four wrong-answer trap types and how to identify them
Trap TypeWhat It Looks LikeHow to Spot It
New TopicSuddenly brings up something the passage never discussed.Ask: "Was this mentioned anywhere in the passage?" If no, eliminate it.
Too NarrowFocuses on one small detail instead of the big picture.Ask: "Does this cover the whole paragraph or just one part?" A conclusion should be broad.
Wrong ToneUses a very different voice — overly casual, emotional, or harsh when the passage is calm.Ask: "Does this sound like it belongs with the rest of the writing?"
ContradictsSays the opposite of what the paragraph argues or explains.Ask: "Does this agree with the passage or fight against it?"

Worked Example: Choosing the Best Concluding Sentence

Let's walk through a full example, the same way you would on the SHSAT. Read the passage below, then follow each step of our strategy.

📖 Sample Passage
(1) Community gardens have become a valuable resource in many cities. (2) They provide residents with access to fresh vegetables and fruits that might otherwise be expensive or hard to find. (3) In addition, these gardens bring neighbors together, creating a sense of teamwork and shared purpose. (4) Studies have even shown that neighborhoods with community gardens experience lower crime rates. (5) ____________________

Question: Which sentence would best follow sentence 4 to conclude this paragraph?

  • A. Some people prefer to grow flowers instead of vegetables in their gardens.
  • B. For all of these reasons, community gardens offer important benefits to the people and neighborhoods they serve.
  • C. The city should also build more public swimming pools.
  • D. However, some residents complain that community gardens are too noisy.
Step-by-Step Solution
1
Step 1 — Find the Main IdeaSentence 1 is the topic sentence: "Community gardens have become a valuable resource in many cities." The main idea is that community gardens are valuable to cities.
2
Step 2 — Note the Supporting DetailsThe paragraph gives three benefits: access to fresh food (sentence 2), bringing neighbors together (sentence 3), and lower crime rates (sentence 4). All details support the idea that community gardens are beneficial.
3
Step 3 — Eliminate Wrong AnswersChoice A talks about flowers vs. vegetables — that's a new, unrelated detail (Trap: New Topic). Choice C brings up swimming pools — completely off topic (Trap: New Topic). Choice D contradicts the positive tone by introducing a complaint (Trap: Contradicts/Wrong Tone). All three can be crossed out.
4
Step 4 — Pick the One That Wraps UpChoice B says, "For all of these reasons, community gardens offer important benefits…" This sentence ties back to the main idea of community gardens being valuable. It summarizes the supporting details with the phrase "for all of these reasons" and matches the informational, positive tone.
Answer: B

Comparing Strong and Weak Concluding Sentences

Sometimes both a strong and weak concluding sentence can seem related to the topic. The table below shows you key differences.

Comparing features of strong versus weak concluding sentences
FeatureStrong Concluding Sentence ✓Weak Concluding Sentence ✗
Connection to main ideaDirectly echoes or restates the main idea using different words.Loosely related to the topic but doesn't clearly tie back to the main idea.
ScopeCovers the whole paragraph — broad enough to wrap everything up.Too narrow (only one detail) or too broad (makes a claim the passage never supported).
ToneMatches the passage's voice — formal stays formal, informational stays informational.Shifts suddenly — goes from calm to emotional, or from formal to slang.
New informationDoes not introduce brand-new facts, topics, or arguments.Brings in something the passage never mentioned.
Feeling of closureGives the reader a sense that the paragraph is complete.Leaves the reader confused or expecting more.
KEY TAKEAWAY
Imagine you're watching a basketball game. At the end, the announcer says, "What a great game — both teams played their hearts out!" That feels right. But if the announcer suddenly said, "And now, let's talk about yesterday's soccer match," you'd be confused. A concluding sentence should finish the game that was being played, not start a new one.

Connecting to the Bigger Picture: Writing & Reading Comprehension

The skill of choosing a strong concluding sentence doesn't just show up in Revising and Editing questions. It connects to many other parts of the SHSAT and your schoolwork.

How concluding-sentence skills connect to other SHSAT and school tasks
This Lesson's SkillWhere Else You'll Use It
Finding the main idea to match a concluding sentenceReading Comprehension — central idea questions ask you to identify the main point of a full passage.
Eliminating off-topic answersAny multiple-choice test — the process of elimination works the same way across all subjects.
Matching tone and styleYour own essays — when you write a concluding paragraph, you need to maintain a consistent voice.
Understanding paragraph structurePart B Revising/Editing — questions about sentence order, transitions, and organization all rely on understanding structure.

As you continue your SHSAT prep, you'll notice that understanding paragraph structure is one of the most important skills across the entire test. Mastering concluding sentences is a great first step toward mastering all the revising and editing questions.

Practice Problems

PROBLEM 1CONCEPTUAL
What is the main purpose of a concluding sentence in a paragraph?
PROBLEM 2BASIC
Read the following paragraph: "Recycling helps protect the environment in many ways. It reduces the amount of waste in landfills. It also saves energy because making products from recycled materials uses less power. Furthermore, recycling conserves natural resources like trees and water." Which concluding sentence best fits this paragraph? A. Paper is one of the most commonly recycled materials. B. Overall, recycling is an important practice that benefits both the planet and its resources. C. Some people find recycling confusing because of the different bins. D. Pollution from factories is another serious environmental problem.
PROBLEM 3INTERMEDIATE
Read the following paragraph: "The invention of the printing press in the 1400s transformed European society. Before the press, books had to be copied by hand, a process that was slow and expensive. With the printing press, books could be produced quickly and cheaply, making them available to many more people. As literacy rates rose, new ideas spread faster than ever before." Which concluding sentence best fits? A. Johannes Gutenberg is often credited with inventing the printing press around 1440. B. Today, most people read digital books instead of printed ones. C. By making knowledge widely accessible, the printing press played a key role in reshaping European culture. D. Handwritten manuscripts are now considered valuable antiques.
PROBLEM 4APPLIED
Read the following paragraph: "School uniforms have been a topic of debate for years. Supporters argue that uniforms reduce distractions and help students focus on learning. They also point out that uniforms can reduce bullying related to clothing choices. Opponents, however, believe that uniforms limit students' ability to express themselves and can be an extra expense for families." Which concluding sentence best fits? A. Many private schools have required uniforms for decades. B. Whether one supports or opposes them, it is clear that the debate over school uniforms involves important concerns on both sides. C. Students should always be allowed to wear whatever they want. D. In conclusion, school bullying is a serious issue that must be addressed.
PROBLEM 5CRITICAL THINKING
Read the following paragraph: "Many scientists believe that getting enough sleep is just as important for students as eating well and exercising. Research shows that teens who sleep at least eight hours a night perform better on tests and are less likely to feel anxious. Sleep also helps the brain store new information learned during the day. Despite this evidence, many middle and high school students report sleeping fewer than seven hours on school nights." Two possible concluding sentences are below. Explain which one is better and why. Option 1: "Given the strong link between sleep and academic success, schools and families should work together to help students get the rest they need." Option 2: "Scientists are also studying how diet affects student performance in school."

Lesson Summary

A concluding sentence is the last sentence in a paragraph, and its job is to restate or reflect the main idea without introducing anything new. On the SHSAT, you choose the best concluding sentence by first identifying the topic sentence and supporting details, then eliminating answers that are off-topic, too narrow, wrong in tone, or contradictory.

Remember the four-step strategy: find the main idea, note the supporting details, eliminate traps, and pick the choice that wraps up the paragraph. The correct answer will always echo the main idea, match the passage's tone, and leave the reader feeling that the paragraph is complete.

Varsity Tutors • SHSAT English Language Arts • Best Concluding Sentence