Proximate Cause - Bar Exam Uniform

  1. A manufacturer negligently designed a space heater so that its internal thermostat could fail, causing it to overheat. A consumer purchased one of these heaters. One night, the thermostat failed, and the heater became extremely hot, igniting a nearby curtain and starting a fire. The consumer's neighbor saw the fire, called 911, and then bravely entered the burning house to rescue the consumer's dog. The neighbor suffered severe smoke inhalation. The neighbor sued the heater manufacturer.
    Is the manufacturer liable for the neighbor's smoke inhalation injuries? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because a defective product creating a fire presents a foreseeable risk to rescuers, including those attempting to save life or property. The correct answer is C. The 'danger invites rescue' doctrine applies here. A tortfeasor who creates a peril is liable to those injured in a reasonable rescue attempt. Many courts have extended the doctrine to include the rescue of property, especially when the rescue does not involve an unreasonable risk. Creating a fire hazard makes a rescue attempt highly foreseeable. A is incorrect because many jurisdictions do apply the doctrine to the rescue of property. B is incorrect because whether the neighbor's conduct was an unreasonable assumption of risk is a question of fact, and attempting to save a pet is not generally considered unreasonable per se, thus not breaking the chain of causation. D is an overstatement; while strict product liability might apply, proximate cause is still a required element, and this answer does not correctly articulate the foreseeability component.
  2. A farmer negligently allowed his bull to escape its enclosure. The bull wandered onto a neighboring property where a circus was temporarily set up. The bull entered the main tent during a performance, causing panic. In the ensuing stampede of the audience toward the exits, a woman was trampled and seriously injured. The woman sued the farmer.
    Is the farmer liable for the woman's injuries? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because it is foreseeable that an escaped bull could frighten people and cause them to injure themselves in an attempt to flee. This question tests negligence law, specifically the concepts of proximate causation and foreseeability. When analyzing negligence claims, you must determine whether the defendant's breach of duty was a proximate cause of the plaintiff's harm, which requires that the harm be a foreseeable consequence of the negligent act. The farmer breached his duty of care by negligently allowing his bull to escape. The key question is whether the woman's injuries were a foreseeable result of this breach. Courts apply an objective standard: would a reasonable person anticipate that the type of harm that occurred could result from the negligent conduct? Here, it's entirely foreseeable that a loose bull entering a crowded circus tent would frighten people and cause them to flee in panic, potentially injuring themselves or others in the process. The specific manner of harm (trampling during stampede) falls within the general risk created by the farmer's negligence. Answer A incorrectly suggests the audience reaction was unforeseeable when it was actually a predictable response to a dangerous animal. Answer B mischaracterizes the scope of the farmer's duty - liability extends to foreseeable indirect consequences, not just direct physical contact by the animal. Answer C overstates the law by claiming absolute strict liability for "any and all harm," when livestock owners are typically subject to more limited forms of strict liability for specific types of harm. Remember that foreseeability doesn't require predicting the exact sequence of events - just that the general type of harm could reasonably be anticipated from the negligent act.
  3. A driver negligently ran a red light and struck a pedestrian, causing the pedestrian to suffer a complex fracture of her tibia. The pedestrian was rushed to a nearby hospital. The orthopedic surgeon who operated on the leg was fatigued from a long shift and negligently set the bone improperly. As a result, the pedestrian's leg healed with a permanent deformity, causing a noticeable limp and chronic pain. The pedestrian sued the driver for the full extent of her injuries, including the permanent limp.
    Is the driver liable for the damages related to the pedestrian's permanent limp? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because subsequent negligent medical treatment is considered a foreseeable intervening cause of the original tortfeasor's negligence. The correct answer is C. It is a well-established rule that subsequent medical malpractice is a foreseeable result of a defendant's negligence that causes bodily injury. The original tortfeasor is liable for the aggravation of the plaintiff's injuries caused by the negligence of a treating physician. A is incorrect because negligent rescue and subsequent medical negligence are classic examples of foreseeable intervening forces that are not superseding. B is incorrect because medical malpractice is a form of negligence, not an intentional tort. D is incorrect because it relies solely on but-for causation, which is insufficient; the key issue here is proximate cause and the foreseeability of the intervening negligence.
  4. A landlord of an apartment building in a high-crime neighborhood was repeatedly notified by tenants that the lock on the building's front door was broken. The landlord failed to repair the lock for over a month. One evening, an assailant, who was not a resident, entered the building through the unlocked door and assaulted a tenant in the hallway. The tenant sued the landlord for negligence.
    Will the tenant's claim against the landlord likely succeed? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the landlord's failure to repair the lock created a foreseeable risk of criminal intrusion and harm. This question tests landlord-tenant law and the duty of care landlords owe to tenants regarding criminal acts by third parties. When analyzing landlord liability for criminal acts, focus on whether the landlord's conduct created or enhanced a foreseeable risk of harm. Here, the landlord had actual notice of the broken lock from multiple tenant complaints but failed to repair it for over a month. This created a foreseeable risk that criminals could easily enter the building and harm tenants. Courts recognize that landlords have a duty to maintain reasonable security measures in common areas, especially when they know of specific security vulnerabilities. The landlord's negligence directly facilitated the assault by allowing the assailant easy access to the building. Answer A is wrong because criminal acts by third parties are not always superseding causes. If the defendant's negligence makes the criminal act foreseeable (as here), the criminal act doesn't break the chain of causation. Answer B incorrectly states the general rule too broadly. While landlords don't have a duty to protect against all criminal acts, they do have a duty when their own negligence creates or enhances the risk. Answer C is incorrect because landlords are not strictly liable for injuries in common areas—they're only liable when they breach their duty of reasonable care. The correct answer is D because the landlord's prolonged failure to repair a known security defect created a foreseeable risk of criminal intrusion and resulting harm. Remember: On negligence questions involving criminal acts, look for whether the defendant's conduct made the criminal act more likely or foreseeable, rather than applying blanket immunity rules.
  5. A defendant was driving a truck filled with industrial chemicals when he negligently ran a stop sign and collided with a car. There was no explosion or fire at the time of the crash. However, the collision damaged a valve on one of the chemical tanks. A firefighter responding to the scene was exposed to the leaking chemicals and developed a rare form of cancer two years later. Medical experts can establish that the specific chemical exposure caused the cancer. The firefighter sued the defendant driver.
    Assuming the 'firefighter's rule' does not apply, is the driver liable for the firefighter's cancer? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because rescuers are foreseeable plaintiffs, and the harm resulted directly from a risk created by the driver's negligence. The correct answer is C. Rescuers, including professional rescuers like firefighters, are generally considered foreseeable plaintiffs. The driver's negligence created the dangerous situation (a crash involving a damaged chemical truck) that invited the rescue. The harm (chemical exposure leading to cancer) was a direct result of the specific hazard created by the negligent act. Therefore, proximate cause is satisfied. The fact pattern explicitly asks to disregard the 'firefighter's rule,' which in some jurisdictions would bar recovery for risks inherent in the job. A is incorrect because the time lag does not defeat causation if the causal link is medically established. B is incorrect because rescuers are foreseeable plaintiffs. D is incorrect because the claim is based on negligence, not strict liability, as the simple transport of chemicals is not always deemed abnormally dangerous.
  6. A defendant's negligent driving caused a plaintiff to suffer a broken leg. The plaintiff's doctor properly set the leg in a cast. A week later, following all medical advice, the plaintiff developed a deep vein thrombosis (DVT), a type of blood clot, in the injured leg. The DVT dislodged, traveled to his lung, and caused a life-threatening pulmonary embolism. The plaintiff sued the defendant for the injuries related to the embolism.
    Is the defendant liable for the pulmonary embolism? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the embolism is a well-known and foreseeable risk associated with the type of immobility caused by the original injury. When you encounter tort questions involving chains of medical complications, focus on the concept of proximate causation and foreseeability. The key issue is whether subsequent injuries are a natural and probable consequence of the defendant's negligent act. The defendant is liable for the pulmonary embolism because it represents a foreseeable medical complication flowing directly from the original injury. Deep vein thrombosis is a well-documented risk associated with leg fractures and the resulting immobility, even when medical care is properly provided. Courts consistently hold that defendants take their victims as they find them and remain liable for medical complications that are reasonably foreseeable consequences of the initial injury. The chain of causation runs clearly from the negligent driving to the broken leg to the immobility to the DVT to the embolism. Answer B incorrectly suggests that biological complications automatically break causation. However, foreseeability, not the biological nature of the harm, determines liability. Answer C wrongly attempts to distinguish between accident-related and treatment-related complications, but properly administered medical care doesn't insulate defendants from liability for foreseeable complications of the injuries they caused. Answer D misapplies the eggshell plaintiff rule, which deals with unforeseeable severity of harm in vulnerable plaintiffs, not the foreseeability of the type of harm itself. Remember this principle: defendants remain liable for the natural and probable consequences of their negligent acts, including medical complications that commonly flow from the type of injury initially caused, regardless of intervening proper medical care.
  7. A defendant negligently caused a multi-car pileup on a highway during a blizzard, completely blocking all lanes of traffic. An ambulance responding to an unrelated emergency on the other side of town was caught in the resulting traffic jam for over an hour. Because of the delay, the ambulance arrived too late to save a heart attack victim, who died. The victim's estate brought a wrongful death action against the defendant driver who caused the pileup.
    Will the estate's claim against the defendant driver likely succeed? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because it is foreseeable that blocking a major highway could impede emergency vehicles and lead to harm. The correct answer is B. This question tests the outer limits of foreseeability. While the specific plaintiff was unknown to the defendant, the general type of plaintiff (a person relying on emergency services) and the type of harm (death or injury from delayed response) are foreseeable consequences of completely blocking a major highway. Courts have found liability in similar situations, holding that the scope of the risk created by obstructing a highway includes the risk to those who depend on that highway for emergency access. A is incorrect because it relies only on but-for causation. C frames the issue as duty to a specific person, but the better analysis is foreseeability of the type of harm to a class of persons. D is incorrect because while the heart attack was independent, the defendant's negligence caused the delay in treatment that led to the death, providing the causal link.
  8. A construction worker for a large company was working on the 30th floor of a new skyscraper. He negligently dropped a heavy wrench, which fell towards the street below. The wrench struck a large metal beam that was staged on the ground floor, creating an extremely loud clang. The sound startled a delivery driver who was waiting at a red light a full city block away. The driver panicked and accelerated into the intersection, striking a classic car. The owner of the classic car sued the construction company for the damage.
    In the car owner's negligence suit against the construction company, what is the likely outcome? Select one.
    Answer: The car owner will not prevail, because he was not a foreseeable plaintiff within the zone of danger created by the falling wrench. The correct answer is D. This fact pattern mirrors the famous Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co. case. Proximate cause requires that the harm result from the risks that made the defendant's conduct negligent. The duty of care is owed only to foreseeable plaintiffs within the zone of danger. Here, the risk created by the falling wrench was injury to people or property directly below. A driver a block away, who was harmed only by the sound, is generally considered an unforeseeable plaintiff. A is incorrect because but-for causation (actual cause) is necessary but not sufficient for liability; proximate cause must also be established. B is incorrect because it states the risk too broadly; while property damage is foreseeable, the specific plaintiff and the manner of harm were not. C is incorrect because the driver's reaction, while an intervening cause, is not the primary reason for denying liability; the unforeseeability of the plaintiff is the dispositive issue.
  9. A tavern served alcohol to a visibly intoxicated patron, in violation of a state dram shop act. The patron then drove his car. A few miles from the tavern, a child suddenly darted into the road chasing a ball. The patron, due to his intoxication, had a delayed reaction time and was unable to swerve or brake effectively, striking and killing the child. The child's parents brought a wrongful death action against the tavern.
    Is the tavern likely to be held liable for the child's death? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the tavern's negligence created the foreseeable risk that the patron would be unable to respond appropriately to common road hazards. The correct answer is C. The purpose of a dram shop act is to prevent accidents caused by intoxicated drivers. The risk created by over-serving a patron includes not just unprovoked swerving, but also an impaired ability to react to foreseeable road hazards, such as a pedestrian entering the street. The child's action, while perhaps a contributing factor, is the type of hazard an unimpaired driver might have avoided. It is a foreseeable intervening event, not a superseding cause that would absolve the tavern. A is incorrect because the child's action (or negligence, depending on age) is a foreseeable event that does not break the causal chain. B is incorrect as it misstates the scope of liability. D is incorrect because while violating the statute may be negligence per se, the plaintiff must still prove that the violation was the actual and proximate cause of the injury.
  10. A homeowner, in a rush to leave for vacation, negligently left a garden hose running, causing a large, deep puddle to form on the public sidewalk in front of his house. A pedestrian, to avoid the puddle, stepped into the street. At that moment, a small private airplane suffered a catastrophic engine failure and fell from the sky, crashing into the street and injuring the pedestrian with flying debris. The pedestrian has sued the homeowner for negligence.
    Will the pedestrian likely succeed in his claim against the homeowner? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the risk that made the homeowner's conduct negligent was a slip-and-fall, not injury from a plane crash. The correct answer is C. This question tests the 'type of harm' or 'scope of risk' aspect of proximate cause. The foreseeable risks associated with leaving a puddle on a sidewalk are that someone might slip and fall in the puddle or be struck by a car when forced to walk in the street. An airplane falling from the sky is a completely different type of risk and is not foreseeable. Therefore, the harm suffered is outside the scope of the risk created by the defendant's negligence. A is incorrect because it conflates actual cause with proximate cause. B is too general; while the risk of harm from traffic is foreseeable, the risk from a plane crash is not. D is incorrect because while the plane crash is the immediate cause, the most precise legal reason for the homeowner's non-liability is that the harm was not the type of harm that was foreseeable from his specific negligent act.
  11. A gas station attendant negligently overfilled a customer's fuel tank, causing several gallons of gasoline to spill onto the pavement. The customer drove away, and the attendant began cleaning the spill. Five minutes later, before the attendant had finished, a completely unrelated person carelessly tossed a lit cigarette out of a passing car. The cigarette landed in the gasoline, which ignited and created a large fireball that severely burned a pedestrian on the sidewalk. The pedestrian sued the gas station.
    Will the gas station likely be held liable for the pedestrian's burns? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the risk of ignition from a careless source is precisely what makes spilling gasoline a negligent act. This question tests your understanding of proximate cause and foreseeability in negligence law. When analyzing whether a defendant's negligent act caused a plaintiff's harm, you must consider whether the type of harm that occurred was a foreseeable consequence of the defendant's negligence. Answer A correctly identifies that the gas station will likely be liable because the risk of ignition from careless sources is exactly what makes spilling gasoline negligent in the first place. The attendant's negligence created a dangerous condition (spilled gasoline), and fire/explosion from ignition sources is the precise type of harm that makes such spills unreasonably risky. The fact that the ignition came from a third party's cigarette doesn't break the causal chain because this type of careless behavior is foreseeable. Answer B incorrectly suggests the cigarette tosser's act breaks causation. While the cigarette was the direct cause, this doesn't automatically make it a superseding cause that relieves the gas station of liability. Intervening acts only break causation if they're unforeseeable. Answer C wrongly focuses on the littering aspect being criminal. Criminal acts don't automatically constitute superseding causes—the key is foreseeability, not the legal characterization of the intervening act. Answer D incorrectly applies strict liability theory. While gasoline is dangerous, routine dispensing at gas stations is generally not considered an "abnormally dangerous activity" under strict liability doctrine, as it's a common, regulated commercial activity. Remember: In negligence cases involving dangerous substances, focus on whether the harm that occurred was the type of risk that made the defendant's conduct negligent—not just whether an intervening cause was present.
  12. A factory negligently released a plume of noxious but non-toxic gas that had a foul odor. The gas drifted over a nearby highway, but it was thin and did not obscure visibility. A truck driver on the highway, disgusted by the smell, began to gag violently. The gagging reflex was so severe that he momentarily lost consciousness, and his truck swerved across the median, colliding with a car and injuring its driver. The injured car driver sued the factory.
    Is the factory liable for the car driver's injuries? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because it is foreseeable that a foul-smelling gas could distract a driver or cause some physical reaction leading to an accident. The correct answer is C. The central issue is the foreseeability of the mechanism of harm. While the specific mechanism (gagging leading to unconsciousness) might be unusual, it is foreseeable that a noxious odor could cause some form of physical distress or distraction to a driver, leading to an accident. The result—a car crash—is a foreseeable consequence of releasing a distracting substance over a highway. Therefore, the unusual mechanism does not break the chain of proximate cause. A is incorrect because the gas created an unreasonable risk of harm (distraction/illness leading to accidents) even if it wasn't toxic or sight-obscuring. B is incorrect because while the reaction was extreme, it is not so bizarre as to be legally unforeseeable when the general type of harm (an accident caused by driver impairment) is foreseeable. D is incorrect because emitting fumes is not typically classified as an abnormally dangerous activity unless the fumes are highly toxic or explosive.
  13. A driver negligently left his car unlocked with the keys in the ignition in a public parking lot. A teenager stole the car. The next day, the teenager was driving the stolen car recklessly at high speed and collided with a motorcyclist, severely injuring him. The motorcyclist sued the driver who owned the car for negligence.
    In most jurisdictions, what is the likely outcome of the motorcyclist's suit against the car's owner? Select one.
    Answer: The owner is liable, because the theft and subsequent negligent driving were foreseeable consequences of leaving the keys in the car. The correct answer is A. This is a common 'key in ignition' scenario. Many jurisdictions hold that leaving keys in a car in a public place creates a foreseeable risk that the car will be stolen and that the thief will drive negligently, causing an accident. In such jurisdictions, the thief's actions are a foreseeable intervening cause, not a superseding one. B is incorrect because vicarious liability does not apply; the thief is not the owner's agent or employee. C is the minority view; while plausible, the modern trend is to view the subsequent negligent driving as a foreseeable outcome of the owner's negligence. D is incorrect because drivers generally owe a duty of care to other people on the road, and this can include a duty to reasonably secure one's vehicle to prevent it from becoming a hazard in the hands of an unauthorized user.
  14. You are representing a client who was injured in a car accident caused by a defendant's negligence. Your client suffered a broken arm and a concussion. Two weeks after the accident, while your client was recovering at home and still suffering from post-concussion headaches, he slipped on a rug in his own home and fell, breaking his leg. He claims the fall happened because a sudden, severe headache from the concussion made him dizzy. You are considering whether to claim damages from the defendant for the broken leg.
    What is the strongest argument that the defendant is liable for the client's broken leg? Select one.
    Answer: The fall was a direct and foreseeable result of the concussion symptoms caused by the defendant's negligence. The correct answer is B. A defendant is liable for subsequent injuries suffered by the plaintiff if they are a foreseeable consequence of the original injury. If the plaintiff's original injuries (the concussion) made him more susceptible to a subsequent accident (falling due to dizziness), the second injury is generally considered a foreseeable result of the original negligence. A is incorrect because it relies only on but-for causation, which is not enough. C is incorrect as it applies the wrong legal standard; the defendant is liable based on negligence and foreseeability, not strict liability. D states the defendant's best counterargument, not the plaintiff's strongest argument, and it is likely to fail if the fall was caused by symptoms of the original injury.
  15. A chemical company negligently allowed a toxic chemical to leak into a river. The chemical was known to be harmful to aquatic life but was not considered a direct threat to humans at that concentration. The chemical killed a large number of fish downstream. A restaurant owner who operated a popular riverside fish restaurant 10 miles downstream lost significant business because he could no longer source local fish, his main attraction. The restaurant owner sued the chemical company for his purely economic losses.
    Will the restaurant owner likely recover for his lost profits? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the economic loss rule generally bars recovery for purely economic losses in the absence of physical injury to person or property. This question tests your understanding of the economic loss rule, a fundamental limitation in tort law that restricts recovery for purely financial harm. The economic loss rule generally prohibits plaintiffs from recovering purely economic damages in negligence cases unless they also suffered physical injury to their person or property. Here, the restaurant owner suffered only financial losses - he couldn't source local fish and lost profits, but his own property wasn't physically damaged. The chemical company's negligence directly harmed the fish (which weren't the restaurant owner's property), creating an indirect economic impact on his business. Under traditional tort principles, this purely economic harm without accompanying physical damage to the plaintiff's person or property is not recoverable. Answer choice (A) confuses foreseeability with legal duty. While it may have been foreseeable that businesses relying on local fish would be harmed, foreseeability alone doesn't overcome the economic loss rule's bar on recovery. Choice (B) incorrectly suggests strict liability applies. The facts indicate negligence, and even if strict liability applied, it wouldn't automatically allow recovery for purely economic losses. Choice (C) misapplies the "zone of danger" concept, which typically relates to emotional distress claims or physical injury cases, not economic loss situations. Study tip: When you see tort questions involving business losses without physical property damage, immediately consider the economic loss rule. This doctrine frequently appears on bar exams because it represents a key limitation on negligence liability that many students overlook.
  16. A driver negligently lost control of his car and crashed into a ditch on the side of a rural highway, causing him to be trapped inside the vehicle. A passing motorist saw the crash, pulled over, and ran to help. As the motorist attempted to pry open the driver's door, he strained a muscle in his back, resulting in a permanent injury. The motorist sued the driver whose negligence caused the original crash.
    Is the driver who crashed liable for the motorist's back injury? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the 'danger invites rescue' doctrine makes the creator of the peril liable for injuries sustained by a rescuer. The correct answer is C. The 'danger invites rescue' doctrine holds that a person who negligently creates a dangerous situation is liable for the injuries of those who attempt to rescue the person in peril. The rescuer is considered a foreseeable plaintiff. A is incorrect because assumption of the risk is generally not a defense against a rescuer unless the rescuer's conduct was reckless or wanton. B is incorrect because the driver's negligence is the proximate cause of the injury, as it created the necessity for the rescue. D is incorrect because it misstates the law; while some jurisdictions have statutes encouraging or requiring aid, the basis for civil liability here is the common law doctrine that a negligent party is responsible for the foreseeable consequences of their actions, which includes injuries to rescuers.
  17. A city parks department employee negligently failed to secure a heavy metal lid on a utility access point in a public park. The next day, a group of teenagers, as a prank, lifted the unsecured lid and left the deep hole exposed. An hour later, a jogger running through the park did not see the open hole and fell in, sustaining serious injuries. The jogger sued the city.
    Is the city likely to be held liable for the jogger's injuries? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the city's negligence created the opportunity for the teenagers' misconduct, which was a foreseeable intervening act. This question tests proximate causation and intervening acts in negligence law. When analyzing liability chains with multiple actors, you need to determine whether an intervening act breaks the causal connection between the original negligent act and the ultimate harm. The city employee's negligence in failing to secure the utility lid created a dangerous condition that made the teenagers' misconduct both possible and reasonably foreseeable. Courts generally hold that if an intervening act is a foreseeable consequence of the defendant's negligence, it doesn't cut off liability. Here, teenagers engaging in pranks or mischief in a public park is exactly the type of foreseeable intervening conduct that property owners must anticipate. Looking at the wrong answers: Choice B is incorrect because having a cause of action against one party doesn't eliminate liability for another party whose negligence contributed to the harm - multiple parties can be liable. Choice C misapplies superseding cause doctrine. While intentional criminal acts can sometimes break the causal chain, they only do so when they're unforeseeable. Teenage pranks in a public park are reasonably foreseeable, especially when the original negligence creates the very opportunity for such misconduct. Choice D incorrectly states that landowners face strict liability - municipalities typically face ordinary negligence standards, not strict liability, for maintaining public property. The correct answer is A because the city's negligence created the dangerous condition that foreseeably led to the teenagers' intervention and the jogger's injury. Study tip: In intervening cause questions, focus on foreseeability. If the intervening act is a foreseeable result of the defendant's negligence, liability typically continues down the chain.
  18. A defendant's negligence caused a plaintiff to suffer disfiguring facial scars. The plaintiff became severely depressed and withdrawn as a result of the disfigurement. One year after the accident, the plaintiff committed suicide. The plaintiff's estate brought a wrongful death action against the defendant, arguing that the suicide was a result of the depression caused by the defendant's negligence.
    What is the most likely outcome of the estate's claim? Select one.
    Answer: The claim will succeed, but only if the estate can prove the disfigurement created an irresistible impulse to commit suicide. The correct answer is B. The general rule is that suicide is a superseding cause that breaks the chain of causation. However, there is a significant exception: if the defendant's tortious act causes a mental illness or condition (like severe depression) that results in an 'irresistible impulse' to commit suicide, the act is not considered truly voluntary and does not break the chain of causation. The plaintiff would have to show that the depression was so severe that it destroyed the deceased's ability to resist the suicidal impulse. A is incorrect because but-for causation is not sufficient. C states the general rule but ignores the critical exception. D is incorrect because damages for emotional distress are recoverable, especially when they stem from a physical injury, and the question is whether the ultimate consequence of that distress is attributable to the defendant.
  19. A power company negligently failed to maintain a utility pole, which fell during a mild windstorm, causing a blackout in a residential neighborhood. Due to the blackout, the traffic signals at a busy intersection failed. Two drivers, both approaching the intersection from different directions, failed to treat it as a four-way stop. They collided, and one of the drivers was injured. The injured driver sued the power company.
    Will the injured driver's suit against the power company likely succeed? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because it is foreseeable that a power failure will cause traffic signals to malfunction and that driver negligence may lead to an accident. The correct answer is C. The power company's negligence created the dangerous condition—an intersection without functioning traffic lights. It is foreseeable that in such a situation, drivers may become confused or act negligently, resulting in a collision. The drivers' negligence is therefore a foreseeable intervening cause that combines with the power company's negligence to cause the harm; it is not a superseding cause. A is incorrect for this reason. B defines the scope of duty too narrowly; the duty to maintain equipment includes preventing foreseeable harms from its failure, such as traffic accidents. D is incorrect because the standard for power companies is negligence, not strict liability.

Start this quiz