Authority Types - Bar Exam Uniform

  1. A client, the sole proprietor of a custom furniture business, authorized her lead carpenter to purchase a specific type of rare hardwood from a supplier. She instructed him, "Buy the lumber, but do not agree to any long-term supply contracts." The carpenter went to the supplier and purchased the wood. The supplier then offered a 10% discount on all future orders if the business would sign a one-year exclusive supply agreement. Believing it was a good deal, the carpenter signed the agreement on behalf of the business. The supplier was unaware of the owner's specific instructions.
    On what basis would the supplier have the strongest argument to enforce the one-year exclusive supply agreement? Select one.
    Answer: The carpenter had apparent authority to sign the supply agreement. The correct answer is B. The supplier's strongest argument is based on apparent authority. By sending the carpenter to transact business, the owner (principal) created a manifestation to the supplier (third party) that the carpenter had authority to conduct such business. It could be reasonable for the supplier to believe that a lead carpenter authorized to purchase materials also had authority to enter into a supply agreement, which is a common transaction in the industry. A is incorrect because the owner's express prohibition destroyed any implied actual authority. C is incorrect because ratification requires knowledge of all material facts of the unauthorized contract; accepting the initial lumber (which was authorized) does not ratify the separate, unauthorized supply agreement. D is incorrect as estoppel requires a detrimental reliance that is not clearly established here, and apparent authority is the more direct agency doctrine.
  2. You are advising a client who runs a small publishing house. The house's chief editor, whose job is to acquire manuscripts, attended a writers' conference. At the conference, she signed a contract with a famous author, promising a $500,000 advance. The editor's employment agreement, which the author has never seen, caps her authority to offer advances at $100,000. However, the publishing house's website and marketing materials describe the chief editor as having "full authority to acquire and contract for our next bestseller."
    What is the most likely reason the publishing house would be bound by the $500,000 contract? Select one.
    Answer: The editor had apparent authority based on the public representations made by the publishing house. The correct answer is B. The publishing house is likely bound on a theory of apparent authority. The house's public statements on its website that the editor had "full authority" constitute a manifestation to third parties, including the author, that the editor could enter into such contracts. The author could reasonably rely on these public representations. A is incorrect because the express $100,000 limit in her employment contract negates any implied actual authority for a larger amount. C is a true statement, but it is the reason why apparent authority exists, not the legal doctrine itself; B is the more precise legal answer. D is incorrect because "inherent agency power" is a less-common, more ambiguous doctrine, and apparent authority provides a clear and direct basis for liability.
  3. A chef owned a restaurant and employed a purchasing agent to buy fresh produce daily. The chef told the agent, "Only buy organic produce from Green Farms." For a year, the agent did so. One day, Green Farms had a fire and could not make its delivery. To ensure the restaurant could open for dinner, the agent purchased produce of similar quality and price from a different supplier, Quality Produce. The chef was angry about the purchase and refused to pay the invoice from Quality Produce.
    Is the chef liable to Quality Produce for the cost of the produce? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the agent had implied authority to take reasonable steps in an emergency to keep the business running. This question tests your understanding of agency law, specifically the different types of authority an agent can possess to bind a principal in contracts with third parties. When an agent acts outside their express authority, they may still have implied authority to bind the principal if their actions are reasonably necessary to accomplish the principal's objectives. Here, the chef's express instruction was to buy only from Green Farms, but the underlying purpose was to ensure the restaurant had fresh produce to operate. When Green Farms couldn't deliver due to the fire, the agent faced an emergency that threatened the restaurant's ability to open. Purchasing similar quality produce from Quality Produce was a reasonable step to fulfill the chef's broader business objective of keeping the restaurant running. Option A is wrong because disobeying express instructions doesn't automatically terminate actual authority—implied authority can still exist for emergency situations. Option B incorrectly focuses on the relationship between Quality Produce and the agent; apparent authority depends on what the principal communicates to third parties about the agent's authority, not prior dealings. Option C, while touching on apparent authority concepts, isn't the strongest legal theory here since it's more general and doesn't address the specific emergency circumstances. Option D correctly identifies that implied authority extends to reasonable emergency measures that serve the principal's interests, even when they technically violate express instructions. Remember: On agency questions, look for emergency situations where an agent's actions, though outside express authority, reasonably serve the principal's broader business purposes—this often creates implied authority.
  4. A farmer hired a ranch hand to manage his cattle operation. The employment contract expressly authorized the ranch hand to purchase feed and veterinary supplies. One day, a severe and unexpected blizzard struck. The cattle were in a remote pasture, and the ranch hand realized they would likely freeze without immediate shelter. Unable to contact the farmer, the ranch hand contracted with a local construction company to erect a temporary emergency shelter, costing $8,000. This action was not mentioned in his employment contract.
    Is the farmer liable for the $8,000 cost of the shelter? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the ranch hand had authority based on an emergency situation to protect the farmer's property. The correct answer is C. The ranch hand acted with authority derived from the emergency. This is a form of implied actual authority. When an emergency occurs and the agent cannot consult the principal, the agent has implied authority to take reasonable actions to protect the principal's interests, even if those actions were not originally authorized. A and B are incorrect because they fail to account for the expansion of an agent's authority in an emergency. D is incorrect because the basis of liability here is not apparent authority (what the third party believed), but rather the agent's actual authority implied by the unforeseen circumstances.
  5. A large technology corporation employs a Vice President of Procurement. The corporate bylaws, which are not public, state that any contract exceeding $1 million requires approval from the board of directors. The Vice President has, for years, signed contracts on behalf of the corporation, including a recent $950,000 contract that was publicly celebrated by the company. The Vice President then negotiates and signs a $1.2 million contract with a new supplier for essential components. The supplier was aware of the Vice President's title and the recently celebrated contract but was unaware of the internal bylaw limitation.
    Is the corporation likely bound by the $1.2 million contract? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the Vice President had apparent authority to enter into the contract. The correct answer is A. The corporation is likely bound because the Vice President had apparent authority. Apparent authority arises when a principal's manifestations cause a third party to reasonably believe that an agent has authority. Here, the corporation placed the Vice President in a position of high authority and celebrated a previous large contract, causing the supplier to reasonably believe the Vice President could bind the corporation to this new contract. The secret internal limitation does not defeat apparent authority. B is incorrect because implied actual authority is what the agent reasonably believes they have; the bylaw limitation negates this belief. C is incorrect because while the VP lacked actual authority, the corporation can still be bound by apparent authority. D is incorrect because a third party generally has no duty to inquire about an agent's authority unless the transaction is extraordinary or there are suspicious circumstances, which is not the case here.
  6. An investor owns a commercial building and has retained a property management company to handle leasing and maintenance. The written agreement states the property manager has the authority to sign leases up to three years in duration. A prospective tenant wanted a five-year lease. The property manager told the tenant, "I don't normally do five-year leases, but for a solid tenant like you, I can make an exception." The property manager then signed a five-year lease with the tenant on behalf of the investor. The tenant never communicated with the investor directly.
    Is the five-year lease binding on the investor? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the property manager lacked actual authority and the tenant had reason to doubt his authority. The correct answer is C. The property manager clearly lacked actual authority, which was limited to three-year leases. More importantly, apparent authority is based on the third party's reasonable belief. The manager's statement, "I don't normally do five-year leases," put the tenant on notice of a potential limitation on his authority. This gave the tenant a reason to inquire further. A third party's belief is not reasonable if they have notice that the agent's authority might be limited. A is incorrect because the tenant's belief was likely unreasonable under the circumstances. B is incorrect because an agent cannot create their own authority by their statements. D is a misstatement of the statute of frauds, which allows for an authorized agent to sign on behalf of the principal.
  7. Your client, an architect, was hired by a developer to design a commercial building. The developer orally told the architect to "handle all the necessary permits and hire a structural engineer." The architect hired a structural engineer and signed a contract with the engineer on the developer's behalf. Later, the developer claimed that she had intended for the architect to merely recommend an engineer, not to hire one directly. The developer now refuses to pay the engineer's invoice.
    What is the architect's best argument that she acted with authority to hire the engineer? Select one.
    Answer: That she had express actual authority based on the developer's instruction to 'hire a structural engineer.' The correct answer is A. The developer's instruction to "hire a structural engineer" is a clear grant of express actual authority. Express authority is created by the principal's words to the agent. The developer's later-claimed subjective intent is irrelevant if her objective words were unambiguous. C describes implied authority, but the authority here was explicitly stated, making A a more direct and stronger argument. B describes apparent authority, which is an argument the engineer (the third party) would make, not the architect (the agent). D is a correct legal principle that supports A, but A is the best answer because it identifies the specific type of authority the architect possessed.
  8. A corporation's board of directors authorized the Vice President of Real Estate to purchase a specific downtown office building, "Building A," for a price not to exceed $5 million. The VP inspected Building A and found it unsuitable. She then discovered that an adjacent building, "Building B," was for sale. Believing it to be a much better investment for the corporation, she entered into a contract to purchase Building B for $4.8 million. The seller of Building B knew of the VP's title but nothing about her specific authorization.
    Which statement best describes the Vice President's authority to purchase Building B? Select one.
    Answer: She had neither actual nor apparent authority to purchase Building B. The correct answer is B. The VP lacked actual authority because her express authority was specifically limited to "Building A." There is no implied authority to purchase a completely different building, even if it seems like a better deal. The VP also lacked apparent authority. While her title might suggest some power, the authority to buy a specific, major asset like an office building is not something a third party can typically assume is a general power. A reasonable third party would understand that such a large, specific transaction likely requires specific board approval. A is incorrect because her mission was not general; it was specific to Building A. C is incorrect because apparent authority for such a large, non-ordinary transaction is unlikely to be created by title alone. D is incorrect because meeting the price limit does not cure the defect of buying the wrong subject matter.
  9. You are representing a client, a grain supplier. Your client was approached by a man who claimed to be the purchasing agent for a large farming cooperative. The man provided a business card with the co-op's logo and his title. He negotiated and signed a large purchase order on behalf of the co-op. In fact, the man had never been employed by the co-op; he had simply printed fake business cards. The co-op had no knowledge of the man or his actions until your client sent an invoice.
    Is the farming cooperative liable for the purchase order? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the man was an imposter who was never an agent of the cooperative. This question tests your understanding of agency law, specifically the requirements for establishing apparent authority. When someone claims to represent another party, you need to analyze whether a true agency relationship exists and what creates liability. The correct answer is D because apparent authority requires some manifestation or conduct by the principal (the cooperative) that would reasonably lead a third party to believe an agency relationship exists. Here, the cooperative never took any action that could have created the appearance of authority. The imposter acted entirely on his own by creating fake business cards and falsely representing himself. Since the cooperative had no knowledge of this person and never manifested any indication that he was their agent, no apparent authority was created. Answer A is wrong because simply having a professional-looking business card doesn't create apparent authority. The card must be traceable to some action or manifestation by the principal, not created unilaterally by the imposter. Answer B incorrectly focuses on the client's reasonableness rather than whether the principal created apparent authority. While the client's reliance might have been reasonable, that alone doesn't establish the cooperative's liability without the cooperative having done something to create the appearance of authority. Answer C is incorrect because there's generally no legal duty to verify an agent's credentials when dealing with someone who appears to have authority. Remember: For apparent authority questions, always ask what the alleged principal did to create the appearance of an agency relationship. If the "agent" acted entirely alone without any manifestation from the principal, no apparent authority exists regardless of how convincing the imposter was.
  10. A wealthy individual hired a financial advisor as her agent to manage an investment portfolio. The principal died on Monday morning. On Monday afternoon, the advisor, who was unaware of the principal's death, purchased 1,000 shares of a company's stock on the principal's behalf, as they had previously discussed. The stock's price increased significantly the next day. The principal's estate now wants to disavow the purchase.
    What is the legal status of the stock purchase? Select one.
    Answer: The purchase is not binding on the estate because the agent's actual authority terminated upon the principal's death. The correct answer is B. The general common law rule is that the death of the principal automatically terminates the agent's actual authority, regardless of whether the agent or the third party has notice of the death. Therefore, when the advisor made the purchase, she no longer had any actual authority to act for the principal. C is incorrect because apparent authority also terminates upon the principal's death. The principal can no longer make manifestations to third parties. A is incorrect because the agent's knowledge is irrelevant under the common law rule. D describes ratification, which is an option for the estate, but it doesn't describe the status of the purchase at the time it was made; at that time, it was not binding. B is the most accurate statement of the legal effect of the principal's death on the agent's authority.
  11. The president of a small, closely-held corporation, without consulting the other two shareholders/directors, signed a contract to sell the building that housed the company's entire operations. The corporate charter requires unanimous director approval for the sale of substantially all corporate assets. The buyer, a sophisticated real estate investor, knew the seller was a corporation and that the seller's business operated out of the building but did not inquire about the president's authority to make the sale.
    What is the strongest basis for the corporation to void the sale contract? Select one.
    Answer: The sale of substantially all assets is an extraordinary transaction outside a president's apparent authority. The correct answer is B. While a corporate president has broad apparent authority for transactions in the ordinary course of business, the sale of substantially all of the corporation's assets is an extraordinary event. A third party, particularly a sophisticated one, cannot reasonably believe that a president has the unilateral authority for such a fundamental corporate change. This lack of reasonable belief defeats any claim of apparent authority. A is correct that the president lacked actual authority, but B is a stronger argument for voiding the contract with the third party, as it directly addresses the third party's reliance. C misstates the law; there is no waiver, but the failure to inquire is relevant to the reasonableness of the buyer's belief. D is true but is an internal matter between the president and the corporation; it does not automatically make the contract voidable against a third party.
  12. A partner in a general partnership that operates an accounting firm signed a contract to purchase a high-performance sports car in the partnership's name. The partnership agreement requires a majority vote for any asset purchase over $25,000 that is not in the ordinary course of business. The car cost $150,000. The car dealership's owner knew the purchaser was a partner in the firm but did not inquire about the purpose of the car or the partner's specific authority.
    Is the partnership likely liable for the contract to purchase the sports car? Select one.
    Answer: No, because purchasing a sports car is not an act for apparently carrying on in the ordinary course the partnership's business. The correct answer is C. Under partnership law (like RUPA), a partner has apparent authority to bind the partnership for acts done in the ordinary course of the partnership's business. Purchasing a $150,000 sports car is not in the ordinary course of business for an accounting firm. Therefore, the partner lacked apparent authority for this act. A is incorrect because the partner lacked actual authority due to the partnership agreement's restriction. B is incorrect because a partner's apparent authority is not unlimited; it is confined to the scope of the partnership's business. D is incorrect because a third party generally has no duty to inspect a partnership agreement, but they cannot enforce a contract if they know or should know the partner lacks authority, which is the case when the act is clearly outside the ordinary course of business.
  13. Your client retained an attorney to represent her in a personal injury lawsuit. The client specifically instructed the attorney, "Do not accept any settlement offer under $50,000 without my final approval." During a pretrial conference with opposing counsel and the judge, the attorney received an offer of $45,000. Believing it was the best possible outcome, the attorney accepted the offer on the record, stating, "My client has authorized me to accept this amount." Opposing counsel had no knowledge of the specific limitation on the attorney's authority.
    Is your client likely bound by the $45,000 settlement? Select one.
    Answer: No, because an attorney's authority to settle a claim must be express, and the attorney exceeded his express authority. The correct answer is A. The authority to settle a lawsuit is a fundamental right that belongs to the client. An attorney has no implied or apparent authority to settle a claim without the client's express authorization. Unlike other decisions, a third party cannot reasonably assume an attorney has unilateral authority to settle. Therefore, the secret instruction is not the key issue; the key is that the authority to settle must be express and specific. The attorney acted outside that express authority. B is less precise; the core issue is lack of authority, not fraud. C is incorrect because courts consistently hold that attorneys lack apparent authority to bind clients to settlements. D is incorrect because settlement is a fundamental decision, not a tactical one like deciding which witness to call.
  14. The owner of a retail boutique hired a manager and gave her explicit oral instructions to handle all store operations, including inventory purchases, but to never spend more than $5,000 on a single purchase order without the owner's prior approval. For two years, the manager regularly placed orders with a particular clothing distributor, never exceeding the limit. One month, the distributor offered a significant discount on a popular line of dresses, but the minimum order was $7,000. The manager, unable to reach the owner, placed the $7,000 order. The distributor had never been informed of the manager's spending limit.
    Which of the following statements most accurately describes the legal situation regarding the $7,000 order? Select one.
    Answer: The owner is bound because the manager had apparent authority based on her position and prior dealings. The correct answer is B. The owner is bound because the manager had apparent authority. The owner placed the manager in a position where it was reasonable for the distributor to believe she had the authority to place orders. The prior course of dealing established this authority in the eyes of the distributor, who was unaware of the secret limitation. A is incorrect because while the manager lacked actual authority due to the express limit, the owner can still be bound through apparent authority. C is incorrect because a violation of a duty of loyalty might give the owner a claim against the manager, but it doesn't automatically void the contract with the third party. D is incorrect because the manager's implied authority was limited by the owner's explicit instructions; she could not reasonably believe she had authority to violate a direct order.
  15. The board of directors of a manufacturing company passed a resolution authorizing its CEO to "negotiate and execute all contracts necessary for the acquisition of a new warehouse facility in the city." The CEO located a suitable warehouse and signed a purchase contract. As part of the deal, to secure favorable terms, the CEO also signed a separate five-year agreement with the seller's logistics company to handle all shipping from that new facility. The board was unaware of this secondary agreement.
    Is the manufacturing company likely bound by the five-year logistics agreement? Select one.
    Answer: Yes, because the CEO had implied actual authority to take actions reasonably necessary to complete the authorized acquisition. The correct answer is C. The CEO had implied actual authority. Actual authority includes not only what is expressly stated but also what is implied to carry out the principal's objectives. The authority to "negotiate and execute all contracts necessary" for the acquisition can reasonably be interpreted by the agent (the CEO) to include ancillary agreements that facilitate the main transaction, especially if they secure favorable terms. A is incorrect because authority need not be expressly stated if it is necessary to accomplish the express goal. B is incorrect because a third party would likely see this as part of the CEO's apparent authority to manage the business and close deals. D uses the term "inherent authority," which is a less favored concept, and states the power too broadly; a CEO's authority is not unlimited.
  16. A woman gave her friend a specific power of attorney, properly executed and in writing, authorizing him to sell her vintage car for a price "no less than $50,000." The friend, while negotiating with a potential buyer, was offered $48,000 in cash. The friend accepted, believing the certainty of the cash sale was better for the woman than holding out for a higher, uncertain price. He signed the bill of sale as "[Friend's Name], as agent for [Woman's Name]." The buyer was not shown the power of attorney document but knew the friend was acting as an agent.
    Is the woman bound by the contract to sell the car for $48,000? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the friend violated the express limitation on his actual authority. The correct answer is C. The agent's authority was explicitly limited by the written power of attorney. By selling for less than the specified minimum price, he exceeded his actual authority. The agent's good faith belief is irrelevant when he violates a clear, express instruction. A is incorrect because there is no basis for apparent authority beyond the scope of the actual authority in this context; the principal did nothing to suggest the agent could violate the price term. B is incorrect because there is no implied authority to violate an express and specific instruction. D is a strong supporting argument but C is the most direct answer: the agent lacked authority. The fact that an agent is acting under a power of attorney often heightens a third party's duty to ascertain the scope of that authority.
  17. The owner of an art gallery told her assistant to sell a specific painting, instructing him, "Don't sell it for less than $10,000." Later that day, the owner discovered the painting was a rare work by a famous artist and was worth at least $100,000. She immediately called the assistant's cell phone and left a voicemail, "Do not sell the painting! I've learned it's very valuable. Pull it from the floor immediately." The assistant's phone was off, and he did not receive the message. An hour later, he sold the painting to a collector for $11,000.
    At the moment the assistant sold the painting, what was the status of his authority? Select one.
    Answer: He had no actual authority, but the gallery is bound by the sale based on apparent authority. The correct answer is D. The assistant's actual authority terminated when the owner revoked it, regardless of whether he received the message. An agent's actual authority is based on their reasonable belief, and that belief is no longer reasonable once the principal communicates a revocation. However, the gallery (principal) is still bound by the sale because of apparent authority. The gallery placed the assistant in a position where the collector (third party) would reasonably believe he had the authority to sell the painting. Since the collector was unaware of the revocation, the apparent authority persists. A is incorrect because actual authority terminates upon revocation by the principal, not upon receipt by the agent. B is an incomplete answer because it doesn't address the lack of actual authority. C is incorrect because apparent authority still existed.
  18. A manager of a member-managed LLC, which operates a chain of coffee shops, signed a contract to purchase a vacant lot of land. The LLC's operating agreement, which was not filed publicly, requires a unanimous vote of all members for any real estate purchase. The seller knew the person was a manager of the LLC but did not know about the voting requirement and assumed a manager had the power to make such a purchase.
    If the other members of the LLC challenge the contract, what is the seller's strongest argument for enforcement? Select one.
    Answer: In a member-managed LLC, each member has apparent authority for acts in the ordinary course of business. The correct answer is B. In a member-managed LLC, each member has apparent authority to bind the LLC for acts in the ordinary course of business, similar to partners in a partnership under RUPA. The fact that this person is called a 'manager' is less important than the LLC's member-managed structure. Purchasing real estate for expansion could arguably be within the ordinary course of business for a growing chain. A is incorrect because the operating agreement negated actual authority by requiring unanimous consent. C states a general principle but B is more specific to LLC law. D overstates the law; operating agreements can limit actual authority and can defeat apparent authority with proper notice to third parties.
  19. A real estate developer hired an agent to acquire several parcels of land for a new project. The agency agreement was in writing and specified that the agent was authorized to offer up to $200,000 per acre. The agent approached a landowner and, during negotiations, falsely stated, "The developer has authorized me to go as high as $250,000 per acre, so my offer of $230,000 is a great deal for you." The landowner, relying on this statement, accepted the $230,000 offer. The developer had made no representations of any kind directly to the landowner.
    Is the developer legally obligated to purchase the land for $230,000 per acre? Select one.
    Answer: No, because the agent's authority cannot be created by the agent's own statements to the third party. The correct answer is C. The developer is not bound because the agent lacked both actual and apparent authority for the $230,000 price. The agent's actual authority was expressly limited to $200,000. Apparent authority arises from the principal's manifestations to the third party, not the agent's. Since the developer made no representations to the landowner, the agent's own false statements cannot create apparent authority. A is incorrect because the agent's status does not change the source of authority. B is incorrect because it misstates the source of apparent authority. D is incorrect because while the agent's actions may be fraudulent, the primary reason the developer is not bound is the lack of authority, which is a more direct answer to the enforceability of the contract against the principal.
  20. You represent a client who owns a construction company. The company fired a project manager for poor performance. The company immediately deactivated the manager's email and building access but failed to collect his company-branded truck and business cards. A week later, the former manager, using the truck and cards, went to a long-time lumber supplier. He placed a large order for materials on the company's credit account, stating it was for a new project. The supplier, who had dealt with the manager for years and was unaware of his termination, filled the order.
    What is your client's strongest argument for not being liable for the lumber order? Select one.
    Answer: The project manager had no actual authority because his employment had been terminated. The correct answer is A. While this argument will likely fail, it is the client's strongest available argument. Termination does extinguish actual authority, which is a necessary starting point for the defense. However, the company will probably still be bound due to lingering apparent authority created by allowing the manager to retain company property (truck and cards) and failing to notify known third parties of the termination. B is incorrect because suppliers generally have no duty to verify authority absent suspicious circumstances. C is incorrect because the agent's unauthorized acts do not automatically protect the principal when apparent authority exists. D is incorrect because internal actions do not constitute notice to external parties.

Start this quiz