01 / 20

Resolve Trade Errors
and Complaints

Learn the procedures for handling trade errors, processing customer complaints, and resolving disputes through arbitration and mediation.

Series 7

What Is a Trade Error?

A trade error occurs when an order is executed differently than the customer intended: wrong security, wrong quantity, wrong account, wrong price, or wrong direction (buy vs. sell).

Key Terms

Error Account
Firm account where trade mistakes are corrected so the customer is unaffected.
Complaint
Any written grievance from a customer about the handling of an account.
Arbitration
Binding dispute resolution by a neutral panel; no appeal.

Why It Matters

Unresolved errors and mishandled complaints damage customer trust and expose the firm to regulatory sanctions. FINRA requires firms to keep records of all written complaints for at least 4 years.

The Complaint Flow

Written Complaint Log & Investigate Resolve Internally Escalate to Arbitration

Handling a Trade Error

1
Identify the error. Confirm what the customer intended vs. what was executed.
2
Notify a principal. A supervisor must approve any correction.
3
Move the trade to the error account. Correct the customer's account so they are made whole.
4
Document everything. The firm absorbs any loss; gains do not benefit the rep.

Core Rule: Make the Customer Whole

When a firm corrects a trade error, the customer's position must reflect what they originally intended. The firm's loss equals the difference between the erroneous and correct outcomes:

$$\text{Firm Loss} = \text{Erroneous Cost} - \text{Intended Cost}$$

Dispute Resolution

When complaints cannot be resolved internally, FINRA provides two formal paths through its Dispute Resolution Services:

Arbitration
Binding. A neutral panel issues a final decision. No appeal. Mandatory for member-to-member disputes.
Mediation
Voluntary & non-binding. A mediator helps parties reach their own settlement. Either side may walk away.

Key Distinction

ARBITRATION Binding decision Neutral panel No appeal Mandatory (members) MEDIATION Non-binding Neutral facilitator Either may exit Voluntary

How to Apply It

1
Acknowledge promptly. Confirm receipt of the complaint or error in writing.
2
Escalate to a principal. Never attempt to settle a complaint on your own.
3
Document and retain. Keep written complaints on file for at least 4 years.
4
Resolve or refer. Settle internally, or refer to mediation/arbitration.

Example 1: Wrong Quantity

A customer orders 100 shares of a stock at \$50, but the rep enters 1,000 shares. The price is now \$52. How is this resolved?

Example 2: Computing Firm Loss

A rep accidentally buys 200 shares at \$30 when the customer wanted to sell. To correct, the firm reverses the position. The price drops to \$27 before reversal.

$$\text{Loss} = (30 - 27)\times 200 = \$600$$

Example 3: A Written Complaint

A customer emails alleging unauthorized trading. The rep wants to call and "smooth it over." What is the correct procedure?

1
Forward immediately to a designated principal: this is a written complaint.
2
Do not settle alone. The rep cannot resolve it unilaterally.
3
Retain the record for at least 4 years per FINRA rules.

Common Mistakes

✕ Rep Settles Alone
Reps cannot resolve a written complaint without principal approval.
✕ Charging the Customer
The customer never pays for the firm's trade error.
✕ Confusing Arb & Mediation
Arbitration is binding; mediation is voluntary and non-binding.
✕ Ignoring Recordkeeping
Written complaints must be kept on file for at least 4 years.

Summary Comparison

Arbitration Mediation
OutcomeBindingNon-binding
Decision makerNeutral panelFacilitator only
AppealNoneN/A
Member disputesMandatoryVoluntary
Either may exitNoYes

Question 1 of 5

When a firm corrects a trade error, the trade is moved to the firm's error account. Who bears any resulting loss?

Question 2 of 5

Under FINRA rules, a customer complaint becomes formally subject to recordkeeping when it is:

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about FINRA arbitration is correct?

Question 4 of 5

A rep mistakenly buys 300 shares at \$40 when the customer intended a sale. To correct, the firm reverses the position at \$37. What is the firm's loss?

Question 5 of 5

A registered rep receives a written complaint by email alleging unauthorized trading. What is the correct first step?