01 / 20

Compare Debt
Securities

Distinguish corporate, government, and agency debt — plus structured products — by issuer, risk, taxation, and yield.

Series 7

What Is a Debt Security?

A debt security is a loan made by an investor to an issuer. The issuer promises to pay periodic interest (the coupon) and to repay the principal (par value) at maturity. Unlike stockholders, bondholders are creditors, not owners.

Key Terms

Par Value
Face amount repaid at maturity, usually \( \$1{,}000 \) per bond.
Coupon
Stated annual interest rate paid to the bondholder.
Yield
Actual return based on price paid, not just the coupon.

Three Major Issuers

Corporate Issued by companies Higher risk Fully taxable Government U.S. Treasury securities Lowest risk No state tax Agency GNMA, FNMA, FHLMC Low risk Mostly taxable

The Risk & Yield Rule

Investors demand more return for taking on more risk. The relationship is direct: as credit risk increases, the required yield increases.

Credit Risk → Yield → Treasuries Agencies Corporates

The Taxation Rule

1
Corporate bonds: interest is taxed at the federal, state, and local levels — fully taxable.
2
Treasury securities: taxed federally but exempt from state and local tax.
3
Municipal bonds: interest is generally federally tax-exempt (and state-exempt if in-state).

Agency vs. Treasury

Treasury
Backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. Direct obligation. No state tax.
Agency
Issued by GSEs. GNMA is government-backed; FNMA/FHLMC are not directly guaranteed — slightly more risk.

Structured Products

Structured products bundle debt instruments together, often passing through cash flows from pools of loans. Common examples include CMOs (collateralized mortgage obligations) and asset-backed securities.

How to Compare Two Bonds

1
Identify the issuer. Corporate, government, agency, municipal, or structured?
2
Assess credit risk. Check ratings; Treasuries are risk-free, corporates vary widely.
3
Apply the tax treatment. Convert munis with \( \text{TEY} \) so yields are comparable.
4
Compare after-tax yield. The higher net return for equal risk wins.

Example 1: Current Yield

A corporate bond with a \( 6\% \) coupon (par \( \$1{,}000 \)) trades at \( \$950 \). What is its current yield?

Example 2: Taxable Equivalent

An investor in the \( 32\% \) tax bracket compares a municipal bond yielding \( 4\% \) with a corporate bond yielding \( 5.5\% \). Which is better after tax?

Example 3: Spread Analysis

A 10-year Treasury yields \( 4.0\% \). A 10-year agency bond yields \( 4.5\% \) and a 10-year corporate yields \( 5.8\% \). What spreads do investors require?

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Taxes
Comparing a muni's stated yield directly to a corporate yield. Always convert to taxable-equivalent first.
✕ Treasury = Agency
Assuming all agencies have the full faith and credit backing. Only GNMA is directly government-guaranteed.
✕ Coupon = Yield
Confusing the fixed coupon rate with the actual yield. Yield depends on the price paid.

Summary Comparison

Treasury Agency Corporate
IssuerU.S. GovtGSECompany
Credit RiskLowestLowHigher
Typical YieldLowestSlightly moreHighest
State TaxExemptTaxableTaxable
Federal TaxTaxableTaxableTaxable

Question 1 of 5

Which debt security is generally exempt from state and local income tax but taxable at the federal level?

Question 2 of 5

A bond with a \( 5\% \) coupon and \( \$1{,}000 \) par trades at \( \$1{,}250 \). What is the current yield?

Question 3 of 5

An investor in the \( 25\% \) bracket holds a municipal bond yielding \( 3\% \). What is its taxable-equivalent yield?

Question 4 of 5

Which agency security carries the full faith and credit of the U.S. government?

Question 5 of 5

A structured product such as a CMO primarily exposes investors to which risk when interest rates fall?

Key Takeaways

1
Issuer drives risk: Treasuries are safest, then agencies, then corporates.
2
More risk = more yield. Yields are quoted as spreads above the Treasury.
3
Taxes matter. Use \( \text{TEY} = \dfrac{\text{Muni Yield}}{1-\text{Tax Rate}} \) to compare fairly.
4
Structured products add prepayment and extension risk through pooled cash flows.