01 / 20

Interpret Portfolio
Performance

Calculate and interpret portfolio return measures and compare them against performance benchmarks.

Series 65

Why Measure Performance?

An investment adviser must do more than report that an account "made money." Clients need to know how much a portfolio earned, relative to what, and whether the return justified the risk taken.

Core Terms

Holding Period Return
Total return over the time an asset is held, including income and price change.
Benchmark
A reference index (e.g., S&P 500) used to judge relative performance.
Risk-Adjusted Return
Return measured per unit of risk taken to earn it.

Holding Period Return

The most basic measure combines income received and the change in price over the holding period:

Two Sources of Return

Total Return (HPR) Income Dividends / Interest Capital Gain Price Change
\( D + (P_1 - P_0) \)

Annualizing a Return

To compare returns earned over different time spans, convert them to an annual basis. For a period shorter than a year:

Time-Weighted vs Dollar-Weighted

Time-Weighted (TWR)
Removes the effect of cash flows. Measures the manager's skill regardless of when money was added.
Dollar-Weighted (DWR)
An IRR that reflects the timing and size of investor cash flows. Measures the investor's actual experience.

Risk-Adjusted: Sharpe Ratio

The Sharpe ratio measures excess return per unit of total risk (standard deviation). Higher is better.

Comparing to a Benchmark

Value Time Portfolio Benchmark

How to Evaluate a Portfolio

1
Compute the raw return. Use HPR including all income and price change.
2
Annualize if comparing periods of different lengths.
3
Choose a fair benchmark with similar asset class and risk.
4
Adjust for risk using Sharpe (total risk) or another measure.

Example 1: Holding Period Return

A stock is bought at \( P_0 = \$50 \), pays \( D = \$2 \) in dividends, and is sold at \( P_1 = \$56 \). Find the HPR.

Example 2: Annualizing

A portfolio earned a 16% HPR over 6 months \( (n = 0.5) \). What is the annualized return?

Example 3: Sharpe Ratio

A portfolio returned \( R_p = 12\% \), the risk-free rate is \( R_f = 3\% \), and the standard deviation is \( \sigma_p = 15\% \). Find the Sharpe ratio.

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Income
Forgetting dividends or interest understates the true total return.
✕ Doubling, Not Compounding
Multiplying a 6-month return by 2 ignores compounding and understates the annual figure.
✕ Wrong Benchmark
Comparing a bond portfolio to a stock index gives a misleading picture.
✕ Ignoring Risk
A high raw return may simply reflect excessive risk, not skill.

Measures at a Glance

What It Measures Best Used For
HPR Total return over a period Single-period results
Annualized Return on a yearly basis Comparing periods
TWR Manager skill Evaluating advisers
DWR Investor experience Cash-flow timing
Sharpe Return per unit of risk Risk adjustment

Question 1 of 5

A stock bought at \( \$40 \) pays \( \$3 \) in dividends and is sold at \( \$44 \). What is the HPR?

Question 2 of 5

Which measure best isolates a manager's skill by removing the effect of client cash flows?

Question 3 of 5

A portfolio returns \( 10\% \), the risk-free rate is \( 2\% \), and \( \sigma_p = 16\% \). What is the Sharpe ratio?

Question 4 of 5

A fund earns \( 9\% \) over 6 months. Using compounding, the annualized return is closest to:

Question 5 of 5

An adviser shows a portfolio beat the S&P 500. To fairly judge this result, what must also be considered?