01 / 20

Identify
Prohibited Practices

Spotting conflicts of interest and unlawful conduct — from insider trading to selling away — that every adviser must avoid.

Series 65

What Is a Prohibited Practice?

A prohibited practice is any act by an investment adviser or representative that violates securities law, regulations, or the duty owed to a client. These rules exist to protect investors and preserve market fairness.

Rooted in Fiduciary Duty

Adviser (Fiduciary) Client (Beneficiary) Loyalty + Care Trust + Assets Client's interest must always come first

Conflicts of Interest

A conflict of interest exists when an adviser's personal or business interest could compromise the advice given to a client. Conflicts are not automatically illegal — but they must be disclosed.

Compensation
Commissions or fees that reward one product over a better one.
Affiliation
Recommending an affiliated firm's products or services.
Personal Trading
Trading ahead of clients or in the same securities.

The Core Antifraud Rule

The probability that conduct is prohibited rises with the size of the hidden conflict. A simple way to think about adviser risk:

\( \text{Risk} = \text{Conflict} \times \text{Nondisclosure} \)

Major Prohibited Practices

1
Insider Trading. Trading on material, nonpublic information.
2
Selling Away. Selling securities outside the firm's supervision.
3
Churning. Excessive trading to generate commissions.
4
Front Running. Trading ahead of a client's large order.
5
Commingling. Mixing client funds with the firm's own funds.

Insider Trading: MNPI

Insider trading means buying or selling on material, nonpublic information (MNPI). It applies to insiders and to anyone who receives the tip ("tippees").

Insider has MNPI Tippee receives tip Trade illegal Both insider and tippee are liable

Selling Away & Private Securities

Selling away occurs when a representative offers securities transactions not recorded on the books of the employing firm and without prior written approval.

Disclosed vs. Hidden Conflict

Disclosed Conflict
Adviser tells the client in writing, client consents, and advice remains in the client's best interest. Permitted.
Hidden Conflict
Adviser conceals the benefit or steers the client toward a worse product for personal gain. Prohibited.

How to Spot a Violation

1
Whose interest is served? If the adviser benefits at the client's expense, scrutinize closely.
2
Was it disclosed? Check for written disclosure and client consent.
3
Is the firm aware? Off-the-books transactions signal selling away.
4
Is the info public? Trading on MNPI is insider trading.

Example 1: Commission Steering

Analysis: This is an undisclosed conflict of interest. The adviser placed personal compensation above the client's best interest. Verdict: Prohibited.

Example 2: The Hot Tip

Analysis: The acquisition is material, nonpublic information. The adviser is a tippee trading on MNPI. Verdict: Insider trading — prohibited.

Example 3: The Side Deal

Analysis: Selling securities off the firm's books without written approval is the textbook definition of selling away. Verdict: Prohibited.

Common Mistakes

✕ "Conflict = Crime"
Conflicts are allowed if disclosed and consented to. Only hidden conflicts are prohibited.
✕ Ignoring Tippees
Insider trading liability extends to anyone who trades on the tip, not just the original insider.
✕ "Good Deal" Excuse
A legitimate investment can still be selling away if done outside firm supervision.

Practice Comparison

Violation Key Cure
Insider TradingTrade on MNPIWait for public info
Selling AwayOff-book salesWritten firm approval
ChurningExcess tradingSuitable activity level
Hidden ConflictConcealed benefitDisclose & consent
ComminglingMix client fundsSegregate accounts

Question 1 of 5

An adviser recommends a fund that pays a higher commission, but discloses it in writing and the client consents. The fund still suits the client. This is:

Question 2 of 5

A representative arranges client investments in a private partnership without reporting them to the firm. This is best described as:

Question 3 of 5

A friend at a public company tells an adviser about an upcoming, unannounced merger. The adviser buys shares. The adviser:

Question 4 of 5

An adviser places frequent, excessive trades in a client's account mainly to generate commissions. This prohibited practice is called:

Question 5 of 5

Which factor most reliably separates a permitted conflict from a prohibited one?