01 / 20

Differentiate
Insurance Products

Compare fixed, variable, and indexed annuities and life insurance — and know who carries the investment risk.

Series 65

What Is an Annuity?

An annuity is a contract between an investor and an insurance company. The investor pays in money (a lump sum or periodic premiums), and in return the insurer promises a stream of payments — often for life.

The Key Question: Who Bears the Risk?

FIXED Insurer bears the risk Guaranteed return INDEXED Shared risk
\( \text{Floor} + \text{Cap} \)
on returns VARIABLE Investor bears the risk Subaccounts, no guarantee Less Risk to Investor ←→ More Risk to Investor

Fixed Annuities

A fixed annuity guarantees a minimum rate of return and a fixed payout. The insurer invests premiums in its general account and bears all market risk.

1
Guaranteed return: the insurer promises a set interest rate.
2
Insurance product: regulated by the state, not a security.
3
Purchasing power risk: fixed payments may lose value to inflation.

Variable Annuities

A variable annuity lets the investor allocate premiums among separate-account subaccounts (mutual-fund-like portfolios). Returns rise and fall with the market — the investor bears the risk.

1
It is a security: requires a prospectus and SEC/FINRA oversight, plus state insurance licensing.
2
No guaranteed value: the account can lose money.
3
Inflation hedge: growth potential can outpace inflation.

Indexed Annuities

An equity-indexed annuity (EIA) credits interest based on a market index (like the S&P 500) but with a guaranteed minimum. Returns are limited by a cap and protected by a floor.

Core Rule: Security vs. Insurance

The regulatory line is sharp: if the investor bears market risk through a separate account, the product is a security.

Insurance ProductSecurity
Fixed annuity✓—
Indexed annuity✓ (typically)—
Variable annuity—✓
Variable life—✓

Life Insurance: Three Flavors

Whole Life
Fixed premium, guaranteed cash value and death benefit. Insurer bears the risk.
Universal Life
Flexible premiums and death benefit. Cash value earns a credited rate with a minimum.
Variable Life
Cash value invested in subaccounts. A security — investor bears the risk.

Key Distinction: Cash Value Growth

Time Cash Value Whole Universal Variable

How to Classify Any Product

1
Find the risk-bearer. Insurer guarantees value? Fixed. Investor's market exposure? Variable.
2
Check the account type. General account = insurance. Separate account = security.
3
Look for cap and floor. Both present? It is an indexed product.
4
Confirm licensing. Securities need a prospectus and FINRA registration.

Example 1: Identify the Product

A client buys a contract where premiums go into the insurer's general account, earn a guaranteed \( 3\% \), and pay a fixed monthly amount for life. What product is this?

Example 2: Indexed Math

An indexed annuity has a \( 0\% \) floor, an \( 8\% \) cap, and \( 90\% \) participation. The index returns \( 12\% \). What is credited?

Example 3: Security or Not?

A client wants a life policy where cash value is invested in stock subaccounts they choose, with no guaranteed minimum. Which product, and what licensing is required?

Common Mistakes

✕ "All annuities are securities"
Only variable annuities are securities. Fixed and indexed are insurance products.
✕ Ignoring the cap
Indexed credits are limited by the cap and participation rate — not the full index gain.
✕ Forgetting inflation
Fixed products carry purchasing-power risk; variable products help hedge inflation.

Summary Comparison

FixedIndexedVariable
Risk borne byInsurerSharedInvestor
ReturnGuaranteedCap + floorMarket-based
AccountGeneralGeneralSeparate
Security?NoUsually noYes
Inflation hedgeWeakModerateStrong

Question 1 of 5

In which product does the investor bear all of the investment risk?

Question 2 of 5

An indexed annuity has an \( 8\% \) cap, a \( 0\% \) floor, and \( 100\% \) participation. If the index returns \( 6\% \), what is credited?

Question 3 of 5

Which products are considered securities requiring a prospectus?

Question 4 of 5

A retiree's main concern is a guaranteed income they cannot outlive, with no market exposure. Which product fits best?

Question 5 of 5

Which life insurance product offers flexible premiums and a death benefit but credits cash value at a rate set by the insurer (with a guaranteed minimum)?