01 / 20

Differentiate
Derivative Securities

Compare options, futures, and warrants: how each derives value from an underlying asset, and the distinct costs and risks of each.

Series 65

What Is a Derivative?

A derivative is a contract whose value is derived from an underlying asset, such as a stock, index, commodity, or interest rate. You are not buying the asset itself, you are buying a contract that references it.

Four Common Instruments

Options
The right, not the obligation, to buy (call) or sell (put) at a set price.
Futures
A binding obligation to buy or sell an asset at a future date and price.
Warrants
A long-term right to buy new shares from the issuing company.

Why Value Derives From Price

Underlying Price (P) Option Value Strike Call

Options: Rights, Not Obligations

1
Call option gives the buyer the right to buy the underlying at the strike price \( K \).
2
Put option gives the buyer the right to sell the underlying at the strike price \( K \).
3
The buyer pays a premium upfront. Maximum loss for the buyer equals that premium.
4
If the option expires worthless, the buyer simply lets it lapse, no further obligation.

Futures: Binding Obligations

A futures contract obligates both parties: the buyer must purchase and the seller must deliver the asset at a fixed price on a set date. Unlike options, there is no choice to walk away.

Warrants: Issuer-Created Rights

1
Issued by the company itself, often attached to bonds or preferred stock as a "sweetener."
2
Grants the right to buy newly issued shares directly from the issuer, which dilutes existing shareholders.
3
Have long lifespans, often 5 to 15 years, much longer than typical listed options.

Warrants vs Call Options

Warrant Call Option
Issued byThe companyAnother investor
Share sourceNew shares (dilution)Existing shares
Typical term5 to 15 yearsDays to ~2 years
PurposeRaise capitalHedge or speculate

Costs and Risks at a Glance

Options Buyer
Cost: premium. Max loss: premium paid. Risk: time decay erodes value.
Futures
Cost: margin deposit. Max loss: potentially unlimited. Risk: leverage magnifies moves.
Warrants
Cost: purchase price. Max loss: amount paid. Risk: dilution and long-term uncertainty.

How to Identify the Instrument

1
Right or obligation? A right means option or warrant. An obligation for both sides means a future.
2
Who issued it? The company itself points to a warrant. Another investor points to an option.
3
What is the max loss? Limited to upfront cost (options, warrants) or potentially unlimited (futures).
4
How long is the term? Very long term (years) strongly suggests a warrant.

Example 1: Call Payoff

An investor buys a call with strike \( K = \$50 \) for a premium of \( \$3 \). At expiration the stock trades at \( P = \$58 \). What is the net profit per share?

Per-Share Cash Flow Intrinsic value
\( 58 - 50 = \$8 \)
Premium paid
\( -\$3 \)
Net profit
\( \$8 - \$3 = \$5 \)

Example 2: Futures Leverage

A trader posts \( \$5{,}000 \) margin to control a futures position worth \( \$100{,}000 \). The underlying rises \( 4\% \). What is the return on the margin?

Example 3: Warrant Dilution

A company has \( 1{,}000{,}000 \) shares outstanding. It issues warrants that, if all exercised, create \( 200{,}000 \) new shares. What fraction of the enlarged company do existing holders retain?

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing right and obligation
Options grant a right to one side; futures obligate both sides. Don't treat them the same.
✕ Forgetting dilution
Warrants create new shares from the issuer, unlike call options on existing shares.
✕ Underestimating futures loss
Margin is not the max loss. Futures losses can exceed the deposit posted.

Summary Comparison

Options Futures Warrants
NatureRightObligationRight
IssuerInvestorExchangeCompany
Upfront costPremiumMarginPrice
Max buyer lossPremiumUnlimitedPrice paid
TermShortShortLong

Question 1 of 5

Which derivative imposes a binding obligation on both the buyer and the seller?

Question 2 of 5

A security that grants the right to buy newly issued shares directly from the company for several years is best described as a:

Question 3 of 5

An investor buys a call with strike \( K = \$40 \) for a \( \$2 \) premium. At expiration the stock is \( \$45 \). What is the net profit per share?

Question 4 of 5

For the buyer of a call option, the maximum possible loss is:

Question 5 of 5

A trader posts \( \$10{,}000 \) margin to control a \( \$100{,}000 \) futures position. The position moves \( 12\% \) against them. This illustrates which key risk?