Compare Pooled
Investments
Understand how mutual funds, ETFs, UITs, REITs, and private funds pool capital — and what sets each apart.
What Is a Pooled Investment?
A pooled investment vehicle gathers money from many investors into a single fund. A professional manager then invests that combined capital across a portfolio of securities. Each investor owns a proportional share of the whole.
Why Structure Matters
All pooled vehicles share capital, but they differ dramatically in how they trade, who can invest, how they are taxed, and how they are regulated. As an adviser, recommending the right vehicle depends on understanding these differences.
The Five Core Vehicles
Net Asset Value: The Pricing Rule
A fund's per-share value is its Net Asset Value (NAV). It is the foundation of how open-end mutual funds are bought and redeemed:
Mutual funds are priced once per day after market close using forward pricing. An ETF, by contrast, trades all day at a market price that may differ slightly from its NAV.
How Each Vehicle Trades
Mutual Fund vs. ETF
| Mutual Fund | ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Trading | Once daily at NAV | Intraday on exchange |
| Pricing | Forward (next NAV) | Live market price |
| Minimums | Often required | One share |
| Tax efficiency | Lower | Generally higher |
| Cost to buy | Possible sales load | Commission / spread |
Understanding REITs
A REIT pools capital to own or finance income-producing real estate. To keep favorable tax treatment, a REIT must distribute at least 90% of its taxable income to shareholders:
Private Funds & Investor Access
Private funds — hedge funds and private equity — are exempt from registration under the Investment Company Act. In exchange, they limit participation to sophisticated investors and accept lower liquidity.
How to Match a Vehicle
Example 1: Calculating NAV
A mutual fund holds $50 million in assets and $2 million in liabilities. It has 4 million shares outstanding. What is the NAV per share?
An investor buying today pays the next calculated NAV of $12.00 per share (plus any sales charge), under forward pricing.
Example 2: Premium or Discount
An ETF's NAV is $50.00, but it trades on the exchange at a market price of $50.40. Is it trading at a premium or a discount, and by how much?
The ETF trades at a 0.8% premium to NAV. Authorized participants arbitrage such gaps, keeping market price close to NAV — a feature mutual funds lack since they always transact at NAV.
Example 3: REIT Distribution
A REIT reports $8 million of taxable income. What is the minimum it must distribute to maintain its REIT tax status, and why does this matter?
The REIT must pay out at least $7.2 million. Meeting the 90% test lets the REIT avoid corporate-level tax, so income is taxed mainly at the shareholder level — producing high but fully taxable dividend yields.
Common Mistakes
At-a-Glance Comparison
| Trades | Management | Access | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mutual Fund | Daily at NAV | Active/Passive | Retail |
| ETF | Intraday | Mostly passive | Retail |
| UIT | Redeem units | Fixed, none | Retail |
| REIT | Exchange/private | Active | Retail |
| Private Fund | Limited / lock-up | Active | Accredited |
Question 1 of 5
Which pooled vehicle trades on an exchange throughout the day at a market price?
Question 2 of 5
A fund holds $30M assets, $2M liabilities, and 4M shares. What is its NAV per share?
Question 3 of 5
To maintain favorable tax status, a REIT must distribute at least what percentage of its taxable income?
Question 4 of 5
Which vehicle holds a fixed, unmanaged portfolio and has a preset termination date?
Question 5 of 5
A client needs daily liquidity but is not accredited. Which vehicle is least appropriate?