01 / 20

Evidence in
Text

Master the skill of identifying and evaluating textual evidence to support claims, strengthen arguments, and ace PSAT reading questions.

PSAT Reading & Writing

What Is Textual Evidence?

Textual evidence is any specific information from a passage that directly supports a claim, conclusion, or answer choice. On the PSAT, you are asked not just what a passage says, but where in the passage the support comes from.

Three Types of Evidence

Direct Quotation
The exact words from the text, often enclosed in quotation marks. Strongest form of evidence.
Paraphrase
The author's idea restated in different words. Must preserve the original meaning without distortion.
Inference
A logical conclusion drawn from stated details. Must be strongly supported, not a guess or stretch.

Why Evidence Matters on the PSAT

Claim / Answer Supports Textual Evidence (from the passage)

On the PSAT, the evidence chain flows from text to claim to answer. You must always verify: does the passage actually say what this answer choice claims? The test rewards readers who ground every answer in the text, not in their own assumptions.

The Evidence Rule

1
Supported: The answer can be matched to a phrase, sentence, or set of details in the passage.
2
Relevant: The evidence directly addresses the question being asked, not a related but different idea.
3
Sufficient: The evidence is strong enough to justify the claim: not a minor detail stretched beyond its meaning.

Evidence Evaluation Flowchart

Read the question carefully Locate evidence in the passage Match evidence to an answer choice Eliminate unsupported choices Select the best-supported answer

Strong vs. Weak Evidence

Strong Evidence
Directly addresses the question. Comes from the specific part of the passage relevant to the claim. Uses the author's own words or a close paraphrase.
Weak Evidence
Vaguely related to the topic but does not address the specific claim. May come from a different part of the passage or require a logical leap.

Step-by-Step Strategy

1
Read the question stem first. Identify exactly what the question is asking: a main idea? A detail? The author's purpose?
2
Predict before you look. Form a rough answer in your own words based on the passage before examining choices.
3
Scan for evidence. Return to the passage and find the specific sentence or detail that supports your prediction.
4
Match and eliminate. Compare each answer choice against your evidence. Eliminate anything unsupported or only partially supported.
5
Confirm the fit. Re-read the winning choice alongside the evidence. Does it faithfully represent what the text says?

Worked Example: Finding the Evidence

Question: According to the passage, what causes coral bleaching?

✕ Pollution
Not mentioned in this excerpt. This is outside knowledge, not textual evidence.
✓ Rising ocean temperatures
Directly stated: "attributed this bleaching to rising ocean temperatures." This is strong, direct evidence.

Worked Example: Evaluating Choices

Question: Which choice best describes the committee's report?

A
"Innovative and groundbreaking" : the passage says "thoroughness and objectivity," not innovation. Unsupported.
B
"Thorough and unbiased" : matches "thoroughness," "objectivity," and "minimized bias." Directly supported.
C
"Popular and widely circulated" : the passage discusses quality, not popularity. Off-topic.
D
"Controversial but respected" : "initial skepticism" is not the same as controversy. Distortion.

Worked Example: Inference vs. Evidence

Question: What can be reasonably inferred from this passage?

✓ Supported Inference
"The war created economic opportunities for women." This is directly supported by the detail that women replaced men who left for war.
✕ Unsupported Inference
"Women earned equal pay to men." The passage says nothing about wages. This is a guess, not an evidence-based inference.

Common Mistakes

✕ Using Outside Knowledge
Choosing an answer that is factually true in real life but is not stated or implied in the passage.
✕ Choosing "Half-Right" Answers
Picking an option where part is supported but part goes beyond what the text says. The whole answer must be supported.
✕ Confusing Tone with Content
Selecting evidence that matches the passage's mood but doesn't address the specific claim in the question.

Evidence Comparison Table

Strong Evidence Weak Evidence
Source Directly from the relevant section From an unrelated section or outside text
Specificity Cites exact details or phrasing Vaguely gestures at the topic
Connection Clearly answers the question asked Related but tangential
Accuracy Faithfully represents the author's words Distorts, exaggerates, or narrows meaning
Sufficiency Strong enough to support the claim alone Requires additional assumptions

The Evidence Strength Spectrum

Guess No textual basis Weak Inference Requires major logical leaps Strong Inference Logically follows from stated facts Direct Quote Exact words from the text Weaker ← → Stronger

Evidence Checklist

✓
Can I underline the evidence? If I cannot point to a specific line or phrase, the answer may be unsupported.
✓
Does it answer THIS question? Good evidence for one question might be irrelevant to another. Stay focused on what is being asked.
✓
Is the match exact? Watch for answer choices that subtly shift the meaning with words like "always," "never," or "all."
✓
Am I adding my own knowledge? If supporting the answer requires facts not in the passage, eliminate it.

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is best supported by the passage?

Question 2 of 5

A student claims: "The author believes that traditional farming is superior to industrial agriculture." Which type of evidence would best support this claim?

Question 3 of 5

Based on the passage, which statement is most accurate?

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following is an example of a "half-right" trap answer?

Question 5 of 5

The passage best supports which of the following claims about the council?