Evidence in
Text
Master the skill of identifying and evaluating textual evidence to support claims, strengthen arguments, and ace PSAT reading questions.
What Is Textual Evidence?
Textual evidence is any specific information from a passage that directly supports a claim, conclusion, or answer choice. On the PSAT, you are asked not just what a passage says, but where in the passage the support comes from.
Three Types of Evidence
Why Evidence Matters on the PSAT
On the PSAT, the evidence chain flows from text to claim to answer. You must always verify: does the passage actually say what this answer choice claims? The test rewards readers who ground every answer in the text, not in their own assumptions.
The Evidence Rule
Evidence Evaluation Flowchart
Strong vs. Weak Evidence
Step-by-Step Strategy
Worked Example: Finding the Evidence
Question: According to the passage, what causes coral bleaching?
Worked Example: Evaluating Choices
Question: Which choice best describes the committee's report?
Worked Example: Inference vs. Evidence
Question: What can be reasonably inferred from this passage?
Common Mistakes
Evidence Comparison Table
| Strong Evidence | Weak Evidence | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Directly from the relevant section | From an unrelated section or outside text |
| Specificity | Cites exact details or phrasing | Vaguely gestures at the topic |
| Connection | Clearly answers the question asked | Related but tangential |
| Accuracy | Faithfully represents the author's words | Distorts, exaggerates, or narrows meaning |
| Sufficiency | Strong enough to support the claim alone | Requires additional assumptions |
The Evidence Strength Spectrum
Evidence Checklist
Question 1 of 5
"The new urban park, stretching across 12 acres of formerly vacant lots, has become the neighborhood's most popular gathering spot. Residents credit the park's open green spaces and free weekend concerts for drawing families outdoors in numbers not seen in decades."
Which of the following is best supported by the passage?
Question 2 of 5
A student claims: "The author believes that traditional farming is superior to industrial agriculture." Which type of evidence would best support this claim?
Question 3 of 5
"Dr. Patel's research team observed that patients who received the experimental treatment showed a 40% improvement in mobility after six weeks. However, the team cautioned that the sample size was small and that further studies were needed before drawing definitive conclusions."
Based on the passage, which statement is most accurate?
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following is an example of a "half-right" trap answer?
Question 5 of 5
"Although the city council approved funding for the new library branch, several council members expressed concern that the project timeline was unrealistic. Councilwoman Reyes stated, 'We support the library, but completing construction in eight months ignores the realities of permitting and supply-chain delays.'"
The passage best supports which of the following claims about the council?