01 / 20

Identify Arithmetic
Counterexamples

Learn to disprove a claim with a single example. One case where the statement fails is enough to make it false.

PRAXIS Core Math (5733)

What Is a Counterexample?

A counterexample is one specific case that shows a general claim is false. If a statement says "this is always true," you only need one example where it breaks to disprove it.

Why One Example Is Enough

Claim: "All of these fit the rule" one failure A single red case makes the whole claim FALSE No amount of green checks can save it.

Spotting Universal Claims

Counterexamples only work on universal claims — statements that use words like all, every, always, or any. These words mean "no exceptions allowed."

Universal words
all, every, always, any, no, none
Existence words
some, there exists, at least one

The Counterexample Rule

Universal claim:

\( \text{"For all } x, P(x)\text{"} \)

Find one x where

\( P(x) \text{ is false} \)

Result: the claim is disproven One counterexample = enough.

Key Distinction: Prove vs Disprove

To Prove True To Prove False
What you needA general argumentOne counterexample
How many casesCover all casesJust one failing case
Examples alone?Never enoughOne is enough

How to Find a Counterexample

1
Read the claim carefully. Identify the universal word (all, every, always).
2
State the property clearly. What must be true for every case?
3
Test the edge cases. Try \( 0 \), \( 1 \), negatives, fractions, and special values.
4
Confirm the failure. Show the case meets the setup but breaks the property.

Worked Example 1

Claim: "The product of two numbers is always greater than each number." Find a counterexample.

Worked Example 2

Claim: "If a number is divisible by 3 and by 2, it is divisible by 12." Find a counterexample.

Test the number 6

\( 6 \div 3 = 2 \) ✓

\( 6 \div 2 = 3 \) ✓

\( 6 \div 12 = 0.5 \) ✕

6 fits both conditions but is NOT divisible by 12

Worked Example 3

Claim: "The square of a number is always greater than the number itself." Find a counterexample.

Common Mistakes

✕ Using examples to prove
Showing several cases that work does NOT prove a universal claim is true.
✕ Wrong setup
A counterexample must satisfy the claim's conditions, then break the conclusion.
✕ Ignoring edge cases
Forgetting to test \( 0 \), \( 1 \), negatives, and fractions where claims often fail.

Quick Summary

Claim Type Can a counterexample disprove it?
"All / every / always"Yes — one is enough
"None / no number"Yes — find one that works
"Some / there exists"No — needs all cases

Let's Practice

Now you'll identify counterexamples on your own. For each claim, look for the one case that satisfies the setup but breaks the conclusion.

Question 1 of 5

Which value is a counterexample to: "The sum of two prime numbers is always even"?

Question 2 of 5

Which value disproves: "For any number \( x \), we have \( x^2 \geq x \)"?

Question 3 of 5

Claim: "Every multiple of 4 is a multiple of 8." Which is a counterexample?

Question 4 of 5

Which claim cannot be disproven by a single counterexample?

Question 5 of 5

Claim: "If \( a > b \), then \( a^2 > b^2 \)." Which pair is a counterexample?

Key Takeaways

1
One counterexample disproves any universal claim.
2
It must fit the setup but break the conclusion.
3
Test edge cases — \( 0 \), \( 1 \), negatives, and fractions.
4
Examples never prove a universal claim true.

You've Got It!

You can now identify counterexamples using arithmetic reasoning — disproving claims with a single, well-chosen case.