State Action Requirement - Next Generation Bar Exam
- Under Shelley v. Kraemer, what made enforcement of a racially restrictive covenant state action?
- Judicial enforcement of the covenant by state courts. Private parties may agree to such covenants, but courts may not enforce them.
- Under Brentwood Academy v. TSSAA, what made a private athletic association a state actor?
- Pervasive entwinement of public school officials in its management. Public schools made up most of the membership and their officials controlled the association.
- A privately owned shopping mall bans leafleting on its premises. On what ground does the First Amendment not protect the leafleters?
- The mall's owner is not a state actor. Hudgens v. NLRB held that a private shopping center is not the functional equivalent of a company town.
- Under Blum v. Yaretsky, when does a private party's decision become state action?
- When the state has coerced it or provided such significant encouragement that the choice is the state's. Mere approval or acquiescence by the state is not enough.
- Under the public function doctrine, when is a private entity a state actor?
- When it performs a function traditionally and exclusively reserved to the state. Examples include running a company town or administering elections.
- Whom do most constitutional rights provisions restrain?
- Government actors, not private persons. The Thirteenth Amendment is the principal exception.
- Under Rendell-Baker v. Kohn, what is the effect of substantial government funding on whether a private entity is a state actor?
- Funding alone does not make the entity a state actor. A private school's dismissal of employees was not state action despite heavy public funding.
- Under Manhattan Community Access Corp. v. Halleck, what is the status of a private operator of public-access cable channels?
- It is not a state actor, because operating such channels is not a traditional, exclusive public function. Providing a forum for speech is not an exclusively governmental function.
- Under Lindke v. Freed, when is a public official's social-media activity state action?
- When the official had actual authority to speak for the state and purported to exercise it. Posts made in a purely personal capacity are not state action.
- Under Burton v. Wilmington Parking Authority, what made a private restaurant's discrimination state action?
- A symbiotic relationship with the state, which leased it space in a public parking garage and shared in its benefits. Later cases treat Burton narrowly.
- What is the effect of state licensing or extensive regulation alone on whether a private entity is a state actor?
- It does not make the entity a state actor. Moose Lodge v. Irvis and Jackson v. Metropolitan Edison so held.