Preliminary injunctions and temporary restraining orders - Next Generation Bar Exam
- What notice is required before a court may issue a preliminary injunction?
- Notice to the adverse party. Only a temporary restraining order may issue without notice.
- Under Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, what must a party show to obtain a preliminary injunction?
- Likely success on the merits, likely irreparable harm, a balance of equities in its favor, and that relief serves the public interest. A preliminary injunction is an extraordinary remedy never awarded as of right.
- Under Rule 65(d)(2), who is bound by an injunction?
- The parties, their officers, agents, employees, and attorneys, and others in active concert who receive actual notice. Nonparties are bound only if they act in concert with a party and have actual notice.
- Under Rule 65(d), what must every injunction or restraining order state?
- The reasons it issued, its terms specifically, and the acts restrained in reasonable detail, without reference to other documents. The specificity requirement ensures that those bound know what is prohibited.
- Under Winter, how likely must irreparable harm be?
- Likely, not merely possible. A mere possibility of irreparable harm is too lenient a standard.
- How long may a temporary restraining order issued without notice remain in effect?
- Up to 14 days, unless extended once for good cause or by the adverse party's consent. An extension for good cause may be for a like period.
- Under Rule 65(b)(1), what must a movant show to obtain a temporary restraining order without notice?
- Facts showing immediate irreparable injury before a hearing, plus counsel's certified notice efforts and reasons to excuse notice. The facts must appear in an affidavit or a verified complaint.
- On how much notice may a party restrained by an ex parte temporary restraining order move to dissolve or modify it?
- Two days' notice, or shorter notice set by the court. The court must hear and decide the motion as promptly as justice requires.
- A court issues an ex parte temporary restraining order on March 1 and does not extend it. When does the order expire?
- At the end of March 15. An ex parte order may last no more than 14 days absent extension or consent.
- What may a court do with the trial on the merits when it holds a preliminary injunction hearing?
- Advance the trial and consolidate it with the hearing. Evidence received at the hearing becomes part of the trial record even without consolidation.
- Under Rule 65(c), what must a movant do before a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order issues?
- Give security in an amount the court considers proper to pay costs and damages if the party was wrongfully restrained. The security caps the enjoined party's recovery for a wrongful injunction.
- What is the traditional purpose of a preliminary injunction?
- To preserve the relative positions of the parties until a trial on the merits. Injunctions altering the status quo are often subjected to closer scrutiny.