Research Ethics - NAPLEX

1. What ethical principle requires maximizing benefits and minimizing harms in research?

   Beneficence. This Belmont Report principle mandates researchers to do no harm and maximize potential benefits while minimizing risks to participants.

2. What is plagiarism in the context of research misconduct?

   Using others' ideas or words without proper attribution. It undermines intellectual honesty by appropriating others' work, violating ethical norms of originality and proper credit in scholarship.

3. Which option best describes minimal risk in human-subject research?

   Harm not greater than daily life or routine exams. Federal regulations define it as risks comparable to everyday activities or standard medical exams, guiding IRB approvals for low-risk studies.

4. What is the key distinction between confidentiality and anonymity in research data?

   Confidential: identifiable but protected; anonymous: not identifiable. Confidentiality maintains privacy by protecting identifiable data, while anonymity prevents any linkage to individuals, enhancing ethical safeguards.

5. What is a conflict of interest (COI) in research?

   Secondary interest that could bias professional judgment. COIs arise when external influences, like financial ties, could compromise the integrity and objectivity of research decisions.

6. What is fabrication in the context of research misconduct?

   Making up data or results and recording/reporting them. It violates research integrity by inventing false information, which can mislead scientific progress and erode public trust in findings.

7. What is parental permission in pediatric research?

   Consent provided by a parent or legal guardian. It serves as a substitute for the child's informed consent, ensuring legal and ethical protection when the child cannot fully consent.

8. Which element of consent requires freedom from coercion or undue influence?

   Voluntariness. This element protects autonomy by ensuring decisions are made freely, without pressure or incentives that could unduly influence participation.

9. What is the primary ethical principle requiring voluntary participation in research?

   Respect for persons (autonomy). This principle from the Belmont Report emphasizes autonomy by ensuring participants can make informed, voluntary choices without coercion.

10. What is the main purpose of an Institutional Review Board (IRB)?

    Protect human subjects by reviewing research ethics. IRBs are mandated by federal regulations to evaluate study protocols, ensuring ethical compliance and safeguarding participant rights and welfare.

11. What document is the classic source of the principles: respect, beneficence, and justice?

    The Belmont Report. Published in 1979 by the National Commission, it established the foundational ethical principles for protecting human subjects in research.

12. What is the ethical obligation when a serious, unexpected adverse event is discovered?

    Promptly report to the IRB/sponsor per protocol. Reporting ensures participant safety and regulatory compliance, allowing oversight bodies to assess and mitigate ongoing study risks.

13. What is assent in pediatric research?

    Affirmative agreement of a child to participate. In pediatric research, assent respects the child's developing autonomy by requiring their agreement in addition to parental permission.

14. Identify the unethical practice: excluding a qualifying contributor from the author list.

    Ghost authorship. Excluding contributors denies proper recognition and breaches ethical standards like those from ICMJE, compromising transparency in research.

15. What is the ethical requirement regarding subject payment to avoid undue influence?

    Compensation must not be so large that it is coercive. Ethical guidelines require payments to reimburse without coercion, preserving voluntariness and preventing undue influence on participation.

16. Which practice is considered unethical: omitting outliers solely to achieve significance?

    Falsification (selective data reporting). Selective omission manipulates data to misrepresent outcomes, constituting falsification under research misconduct definitions.

17. Identify the unethical practice: listing an author who made no meaningful contribution.

    Gift (honorary) authorship. This practice violates authorship guidelines, such as ICMJE criteria, which require substantial contributions for legitimate authorship credit.

18. Which element of consent ensures the participant can understand study information?

    Comprehension (understanding). This element requires that information be presented in a way that matches the participant's capacity to understand risks, benefits, and procedures.

19. What is the most appropriate management step when a researcher has a financial COI?

    Disclose the COI and follow the management plan. Disclosure promotes transparency, and a management plan mitigates bias, ensuring research integrity and compliance with ethical standards.

20. What is informed consent in human-subject research?

    Voluntary, informed agreement to participate. It upholds respect for persons by providing participants with sufficient information to make an autonomous decision about involvement.

21. What ethical principle requires fair subject selection and equitable distribution of burdens?

    Justice. This Belmont Report principle ensures fairness in selecting subjects and distributing research burdens and benefits equitably across populations.

22. What is clinical equipoise as an ethical requirement for randomized clinical trials?

    Genuine uncertainty about which intervention is superior. Equipoise justifies randomization ethically by ensuring no known superior treatment exists, balancing beneficence and scientific validity.

23. What is scientific misconduct defined as by U.S. research policy?

    Fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism (FFP). U.S. policy, including from the Office of Research Integrity, defines misconduct strictly as these intentional acts that undermine scientific validity.

24. What is falsification in the context of research misconduct?

    Manipulating methods or data so results are misrepresented. This misconduct distorts scientific truth by altering processes or results, leading to inaccurate representations in research reporting.

25. What is the appropriate action if a participant withdraws consent during a study?

    Stop study procedures; honor withdrawal per consent terms. Respecting autonomy requires immediate cessation of interventions and adherence to withdrawal protocols to protect participant rights.

Study these flashcards