01 / 20

Set Heat Device
Requirements

Learn to define criteria and constraints for designing a device that controls thermal energy transfer: conduction, convection, and radiation.

Physical Science

What Is Thermal Energy?

Thermal energy is the total kinetic energy of all the particles moving inside a substance. The faster the particles move, the more thermal energy the substance has.

Cold Object Slow-moving particles Hot Object Fast-moving particles Heat flows

Three Methods of Heat Transfer

Conduction
Transfer through direct contact between particles. Example: a metal spoon in hot soup gets warm.
Convection
Transfer through moving fluids (liquids or gases). Example: warm air rises from a heater.
Radiation
Transfer through electromagnetic waves: no matter needed. Example: sunlight warming your face.

Why Design Heat Devices?

In the real world we need to speed up, slow down, or redirect thermal energy transfer. Every device that does this must begin with a clear set of requirements.

Keep Things Cool
Coolers, refrigerators, insulated water bottles: slow down heat entering.
Keep Things Warm
Thermoses, oven mitts, building insulation: slow down heat escaping.
Move Heat On Purpose
Radiators, heat sinks, solar ovens: speed up heat transfer to where it is needed.

Criteria vs. Constraints

Criteria "What success looks like" • Keep ice frozen 4+ hrs
• Reduce temp by \( 10\,^\circ\text{C} \)
• Maintain heat \( > 60\,^\circ\text{C} \)
• Transfer heat in \( < 5\,\text{min} \)
• Must be measurable Constraints "What limits your design"
• Budget \( < \$10 \)
• Max size: 30 cm each side • Only classroom materials • Build time: 45 min • Must be safe to handle

The Core Design Rule

Heat Device Requirement Specific Names the transfer method + direction Measurable Uses numbers, units, or testable outcomes Method-Linked Conduction, convection, or radiation Example Criterion:
"Reduce conduction so ice stays below \( 5\,^\circ\text{C} \) for 2 hours."

Insulators vs. Conductors

Insulator Conductor
Purpose Slows heat transfer Speeds up heat transfer
Examples Foam, wool, air pockets Copper, aluminum, steel
Particle motion Particles transfer energy slowly Particles transfer energy quickly
Design use Coolers, oven mitts, walls Heat sinks, cooking pans, radiators

How to Write Requirements

1
Identify the problem. What thermal issue needs solving? (Too hot? Too cold? Wrong direction?)
2
Name the transfer method. Is the main heat path conduction, convection, or radiation?
3
State measurable criteria. Use numbers and units: temperatures, time, or distances.
4
List your constraints. Budget, materials, size, time, and safety limits.
5
Check for testability. Can you measure whether each criterion was met after building?

Example 1: The Ice Keeper

Problem: Design a container that keeps an ice cube frozen as long as possible at room temperature (\( \approx 22\,^\circ\text{C} \)).

Insulated Container Insulation layer (foam/cotton) ICE Heat Heat ✕ ✕

Example 2: The Solar Oven

Problem: Design a device that uses sunlight to heat a marshmallow to at least \( 50\,^\circ\text{C} \) in 30 minutes.

Sun Solar Oven Box Reflective Flap (foil) Dark-colored absorber Food Clear wrap (trap heat)

Example 3: Laptop Cooler

Problem: Design a pad that prevents a laptop bottom from exceeding \( 40\,^\circ\text{C} \) during a 1-hour video call.

Laptop (heat source) Heat (conduction) Metal + Fan Cooling Pad Fan Fan Fan Convection (forced airflow)

Measuring Insulation: R-Value

Engineers use a number called the R-value to rate how well a material resists heat flow. A higher R-value means better insulation.

Low R-Value
Metal, glass: heat passes through easily. Good for conductors.
High R-Value
Foam, fiberglass, wool: heat barely passes. Good for insulators.

Requirement Template

Use this sentence frame when writing each criterion or constraint. It forces you to include all three key elements.

✓
Good: "The device must slow conduction so that ice stays below \( 0\,^\circ\text{C} \) for 90 minutes."
✕
Vague: "The device should keep things cold." (No method, no measurement, no time.)

Common Mistakes

✕ No Numbers
Writing "keep it cold" instead of "keep below \( 5\,^\circ\text{C} \) for 2 hours." Without numbers you cannot test success.
✕ Wrong Method
Using foil to block conduction when the real problem is convection (moving air). Match the material to the transfer method.
✕ Ignoring Constraints
Planning a $50 design when the budget is $10. Always check constraints before finalizing your design.

Summary: Methods and Materials

Transfer Method To Slow It To Speed It Up
Conduction Foam, wood, plastic (insulators) Metal surfaces (copper, aluminum)
Convection Sealed containers, still-air gaps Fans, vents, open channels
Radiation Reflective surfaces (foil, white paint) Dark/rough surfaces (black paint)

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is a criterion (not a constraint) for a heat-control device?

Question 2 of 5

A student wraps a cup in aluminum foil to keep a drink cold. Which heat transfer method is the foil primarily reducing?

Question 3 of 5

Which requirement is specific and measurable enough to test?

Question 4 of 5

A solar oven uses a black-painted bottom to absorb sunlight. This design choice targets which heat transfer method?

Question 5 of 5

A team designs a laptop cooling pad. Their criterion is: "Laptop stays below \( 40\,^\circ\text{C} \)." A classmate says this criterion is incomplete. What is missing?