01 / 20

Set Design
Requirements

Learn how to define criteria and constraints for engineering a device that controls thermal energy transfer.

Physical Science

What Is Thermal Energy?

Thermal energy is the total kinetic energy of all the particles in a substance. The faster the particles move, the more thermal energy the substance has. Temperature measures the average kinetic energy per particle.

Cold Object Hot Object Heat flows Energy transfers from hot to cold until equilibrium

Three Methods of Thermal Transfer

Conduction
Direct contact between particles: energy passes from faster-moving particles to slower ones through a material.
Convection
Movement of heated fluid (liquid or gas): warm fluid rises, cool fluid sinks, creating a circular current.
Radiation
Energy travels as electromagnetic waves: no medium required. This is how the Sun's heat reaches Earth.

Why Design Requirements Matter

Engineers don't just build: they plan. Before creating any device, they define exactly what the device must do and what limits they must work within. These are called criteria and constraints.

Problem Criteria What must the device DO? Constraints What are the LIMITS? Design Solution Meets criteria within constraints

Criteria vs. Constraints

Criteria Constraints
Definition Goals the design must achieve Limitations the design must respect
Question "What should it do?" "What can't we exceed?"
Example Keep soup above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \) for 2 hours Budget under $5, must weigh < 500 g
Type Performance-based Resource / safety-based

The Core Design Rule

Insulator Slows heat transfer Keeps hot things hot or cold things cold Conductor Speeds heat transfer Transfers heat quickly to or from food vs.

Rate of Conduction

The rate at which heat conducts through a material depends on several factors. Engineers use this relationship when choosing insulation materials:

Conductors vs. Insulators

Conductor Insulator
\( k \) value High Low
Examples Metals (copper, aluminum) Foam, wool, air, plastic
Use case Cooking pans, heat sinks Thermoses, oven mitts
Design goal Maximize heat flow Minimize heat flow

How to Define Design Requirements

1
Identify the problem. What thermal issue needs solving? (e.g., "Keep a drink cold for 4 hours.")
2
List criteria. What must the device achieve? Use measurable targets (temperatures, time, performance).
3
List constraints. What limits exist? Consider budget, materials, size, weight, and safety.
4
Choose materials. Match material properties (conductors vs. insulators) to your criteria.
5
Test and iterate. Build a prototype, measure results, and revise the design based on data.

Example 1: Designing a Thermos

Problem: Design a container that keeps soup above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \) for at least 3 hours.

Criteria
Maintain temperature above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \) for 3 hours. Must hold at least 500 mL of liquid. Must be leak-proof.
Constraints
Budget: under $10 in materials. Must weigh less than 600 g. Must be food-safe. Maximum height: 25 cm.

Thermos Cross-Section

Outer wall Air/vacuum gap Reflective inner wall Hot Soup Sealed lid Conduction ✕ Radiation ✕ Convection blocked by lid ✕

Example 2: Laptop Cooling Pad

Problem: Design a pad that lowers a laptop's bottom temperature by at least \( 10^\circ \text{C} \) during heavy use.

Criteria
Reduce temperature by at least \( 10^\circ \text{C} \). Support laptops up to 17 inches. Must operate silently (< 30 dB).
Constraints
Budget: under $15. Must be portable (under 800 g). Only uses USB power (5V). No liquids allowed.

Example 3: Building a Solar Oven

Problem: Design a solar oven that can heat food to at least \( 80^\circ \text{C} \) using only sunlight.

Criteria
Reach \( 80^\circ \text{C} \) within 45 minutes in direct sunlight. Large enough to hold a small pot.
Constraints
Only use recycled materials (cardboard, foil, plastic wrap). No electricity. Must fold flat for storage.

Navigating Trade-Offs

Real engineering requires trade-offs: improving one aspect of a design often means sacrificing another. You must prioritize criteria based on the problem's needs.

Performance Cost Weight Optimal Balance Better insulation Lighter materials Cheaper materials

Common Mistakes

✕ Vague Criteria
Writing "keep it warm" instead of "maintain above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \) for 3 hours." Criteria must be measurable.
✕ Ignoring Constraints
Designing a perfect insulator that costs $50 when the budget is $5. Always check feasibility first.
✕ One Transfer Method
Only blocking conduction but forgetting convection and radiation. Heat escapes through all three paths.

Summary of Key Concepts

Concept Definition Example
Thermal energy Total kinetic energy of particles Hot coffee has more than iced tea
Criteria What the device must achieve Keep food above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \)
Constraints Limits on the design Budget under $10
Conductor Material with high \( k \) Copper, aluminum
Insulator Material with low \( k \) Foam, wool, air
Trade-off Gaining one quality by losing another Thicker walls = heavier device

Question 1 of 5

A student wants to design a cup that keeps a cold drink below \( 10^\circ \text{C} \) for 2 hours. Which of the following is a criterion for this design?

Question 2 of 5

A thermos uses a vacuum between its walls. Which method of thermal energy transfer does the vacuum primarily reduce?

Question 3 of 5

According to the formula \( Q = \frac{k \cdot A \cdot \Delta T}{d} \), which change would most reduce the rate of heat transfer through a wall?

Question 4 of 5

A team is designing a solar oven from recycled materials. They want it to reach \( 80^\circ \text{C} \) but it only reaches \( 55^\circ \text{C} \). Which design change would most likely help?

Question 5 of 5

A student writes: "The ice pack must be cheap." Why is this a poor design requirement?