01 / 20

Molecules vs
Crystal Structures

Learn to tell the difference between small, countable molecules and extended crystal lattices that repeat in every direction.

Middle School Physical Science

What Is a Molecule?

A molecule is a small group of atoms bonded together in a fixed ratio. You can count exactly how many atoms are in one molecule, and every copy of that molecule is identical.

O H H
Water: \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\)
O C O
Carbon Dioxide: \(\text{CO}_2\)

What Is a Crystal Structure?

A crystal (or extended structure) is a repeating 3-D pattern of atoms, ions, or formula units that goes on and on. There are no individual "molecules": you can only write a ratio, not a count.

\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
\(\text{Cl}^-\)
\(\text{Na}^+\)
... pattern repeats in all directions

Why Does This Distinction Matter?

Whether a substance is made of discrete molecules or an extended crystal controls its properties: melting point, hardness, conductivity, and more.

Molecules
Often gases or liquids at room temperature. Lower melting points. Soft when solid.
Crystals
Usually solids at room temperature. Higher melting points. Hard and brittle.

The Core Rule

Molecular Substance
Made of discrete particles (molecules). Each particle has a fixed number of atoms with a specific chemical formula.
Extended Structure
A continuous 3-D network of bonded atoms or ions. The formula only shows the simplest ratio, not a single particle.
O H H O H H Separate particles ... Continuous network

Bonding Drives Structure

The type of chemical bond determines whether atoms form small molecules or extended crystals.

Covalent Molecules
Nonmetals share electrons in small groups: \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\), \(\text{CO}_2\), \(\text{O}_2\).
Ionic Crystals
Metals give electrons to nonmetals, forming a lattice of ions: \(\text{NaCl}\), \(\text{CaCO}_3\).
Covalent Networks
Nonmetals bond in a continuous 3-D web: diamond (C), quartz (\(\text{SiO}_2\)).

Molecules vs Crystals: Side by Side

Molecular Crystal / Extended
Basic unit Discrete molecule Repeating formula unit
Formula meaning Exact atom count Simplest ratio
Typical bonds Covalent (shared \(\text{e}^-\)) Ionic or covalent network
Melting point Low High
State at \(25^\circ\text{C}\) Gas, liquid, or soft solid Solid
Examples \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\), \(\text{CO}_2\), sugar \(\text{NaCl}\), diamond, quartz

How to Identify the Structure

1
Look at the formula. Does it describe a small, fixed group of atoms (like \(\text{CH}_4\))? Likely a molecule.
2
Check the elements. Metal + nonmetal usually means ionic crystal. Only nonmetals could be molecular or a covalent network.
3
Test the properties. High melting point, hard, brittle? Extended structure. Low melting point, soft or gas? Molecular.
4
Look at the model. If you can circle one complete unit and pick it up, it is a molecule. If the pattern keeps repeating, it is a crystal.

Example 1: Water (\(\text{H}_2\text{O}\))

O H H One complete molecule

Example 2: Table Salt (\(\text{NaCl}\))

✕ Can't isolate
one molecule!
Every ion is bonded to its neighbors in all directions

Example 3: Diamond vs Sugar

Diamond (C)
Every carbon atom bonds to 4 neighbors in a continuous 3-D network. No separate molecules. Extremely hard, melts at \(3550^\circ\text{C}\).
Sugar (\(\text{C}_{12}\text{H}_{22}\text{O}_{11}\))
Each sugar grain contains trillions of individual molecules. Soft, dissolves in water, melts at \(186^\circ\text{C}\).

Metals: Another Extended Structure

Metals like iron (Fe) and copper (Cu) are also extended structures. Metal atoms pack in ordered rows and share a "sea" of delocalized electrons.

\(\text{e}^-\)
\(\text{e}^-\)
\(\text{e}^-\)
\(\text{e}^-\)
\(\text{e}^-\)
...

The Formula Tells the Story

Chemical formulas look similar, but they mean different things depending on the structure.

\(\text{H}_2\text{O}\) (Molecular)
Each molecule has exactly 2 H and 1 O. The formula is a literal count.
\(\text{NaCl}\) (Ionic)
The formula shows a 1:1 ratio. A grain of salt has billions of \(\text{Na}^+\) and \(\text{Cl}^-\) ions arranged in a lattice.
\(\text{SiO}_2\) (Network)
The formula shows a 1:2 ratio. In quartz, every Si bonds to 4 O atoms in an infinite network.

Properties Reveal the Structure

Property Molecular Ionic Crystal Covalent Network
Melting point Low High Very high
Hardness Soft Hard, brittle Extremely hard
Conducts electricity? No When dissolved or melted Usually no
Dissolves in water? Many do Many do Usually no

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ "\(\text{NaCl}\) is a molecule"
\(\text{NaCl}\) is an ionic compound. Its formula shows a ratio, not a single molecule. Salt exists as a crystal lattice.
✕ "All solids are crystals"
Many molecular substances form soft solids (like sugar or ice) made of individual molecules packed together, not a continuous network.
✕ "Diamond and sugar are the same because both have carbon"
Diamond is a covalent network crystal (extended). Sugar is molecular. Same element, totally different structure.

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is an extended crystal structure rather than a molecule?

Question 2 of 5

A substance has a very high melting point and is extremely hard. What type of structure does it most likely have?

Question 3 of 5

What does the formula "\(\text{NaCl}\)" tell you about table salt?

Question 4 of 5

Diamond and sugar both contain carbon. Why are their physical properties so different?

Question 5 of 5

A student looks at a ball-and-stick model and can draw a circle around a small group of atoms that represents one complete unit. The pattern does not continue repeating. What kind of substance is it?