01 / 20

Evaluate
Heat Device

Learn how to use test results to evaluate whether a heat device meets its design criteria and performs as intended.

Physical Science

What Is a Heat Device?

A heat device is any engineered tool or system designed to transfer, retain, or block thermal energy. Examples include insulated cups, solar ovens, hand warmers, and heat shields.

Retain Heat
Insulated mugs, thermoses, heated blankets
Transfer Heat
Solar ovens, radiators, heat exchangers
Block Heat
Oven mitts, heat shields, insulation panels

Design Criteria & Constraints

Before building a heat device, engineers define criteria (what the device must do) and constraints (limits on materials, cost, or size). Evaluation means checking whether the device satisfies both.

Criteria
The goals your device must achieve: "Keep water above \( 60^\circ \text{C} \) for 20 minutes."
Constraints
The limits you must work within: "Use only recycled materials; budget under $5."

Why Evaluation Matters

Testing alone is not enough. You must analyze results and compare them against your criteria to determine success. This is the difference between testing and evaluating.

Build Test Evaluate Redesign if needed

The Evaluation Rule

Design Criterion
Keep water \( > 60^\circ\text{C} \) for 20 min
Test Result
Water was \( 65^\circ\text{C} \) at 20 min
Compare ✓ Criterion Met

Met vs. Not Met

Target: \( 60^\circ\text{C} \)
°C 80 60 40 20 Time (minutes) 0 10 20 30 Device A Device B
✓ Device A
Stays above \( 60^\circ\text{C} \) for 30 minutes: criterion met.
✕ Device B
Drops below \( 60^\circ\text{C} \) before 20 minutes: criterion not met.

Testing vs. Evaluating

Students often confuse these two steps. Testing produces raw data. Evaluating interprets that data against criteria to form a judgment.

Testing Evaluating
Purpose Collect data Judge performance
Output Numbers, observations Pass / fail / redesign
Example "Water was \( 55^\circ\text{C} \)" "Below the \( 60^\circ\text{C} \) target"
Thinking What happened? Did it meet criteria?

How to Evaluate Step by Step

1
Restate your criteria. Write down every goal and constraint from your design brief.
2
Organize your test data. Put measurements in a table or graph so patterns are visible.
3
Compare each result to its criterion. Check: did this specific measurement meet the specific goal?
4
Write a conclusion. State which criteria were met, which were not, and why.
5
Propose improvements. For any unmet criterion, suggest a specific redesign change.

Example 1: Insulated Cup

Time (min) Temperature (°C) Above \( 50^\circ\text{C} \)?
085✓ Yes
572✓ Yes
1061✓ Yes
1553✓ Yes

Example 2: Solar Oven

Criterion Target Result Verdict
Max Temp \( \geq 80^\circ\text{C} \) \( 68^\circ\text{C} \) ✕ Not met
Cost \( < \$10 \) $7.50 ✓ Met

Example 3: Hand Warmer Design

✓ Criterion 1
Hit \( 42^\circ\text{C} \) in 1.5 minutes
✕ Criterion 2
Cooled to \( 30^\circ\text{C} \) after only 6 min
✓ Criterion 3
Mass: 150 g, well under 200 g limit

Reading a Cooling Curve

Cooling curves show how temperature drops over time. To evaluate, find the time when the curve crosses below your target temperature.

°C Time (min) 90 75 60 45 30 0 5 10 15 20 Target Crosses at ~12 min

Using Data Tables to Evaluate

Organize your test results in a table and add a verdict column that directly compares each result to the criterion.

1
Column 1: List each criterion or time point.
2
Column 2: Write the target value (from your design brief).
3
Column 3: Record your actual test result.
4
Column 4: Mark ✓ Met or ✕ Not Met for each row.

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Constraints
A device that works perfectly but costs too much or weighs too much still fails evaluation.
✕ Cherry-Picking Data
Using only your best trial while ignoring worse results gives a misleading evaluation.
✕ Vague Conclusions
Saying "it worked okay" without referencing specific criteria and numbers is not a real evaluation.

Summary of Key Concepts

Concept Definition Example
Design Criteria Goals the device must achieve Keep water \( > 60^\circ\text{C} \)
Constraints Limits on materials, cost, size Budget \( < \$5 \)
Testing Collecting data from trials Recording temperature every 5 min
Evaluating Judging data against criteria "Criterion met" or "not met"
Redesign Changing the device to fix failures Add more insulation layers

Question 1 of 5

A student's insulated cup must keep water above \( 50^\circ\text{C} \) for 10 minutes. After testing, the water is \( 48^\circ\text{C} \) at 10 minutes. What should the student conclude?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following is an example of evaluating a heat device rather than just testing it?

Question 3 of 5

A solar oven has two design criteria: (1) reach \( 80^\circ\text{C} \), (2) cost under $8. It reaches \( 90^\circ\text{C} \) but costs $12. How should this be evaluated?

Question 4 of 5

A cooling curve shows a device's temperature dropping below the \( 55^\circ\text{C} \) target at 8 minutes. The criterion requires staying above target for 15 minutes. What is the best redesign recommendation?

Question 5 of 5

A student runs three trials of their heat device and gets final temperatures of \( 62^\circ\text{C} \), \( 58^\circ\text{C} \), and \( 61^\circ\text{C} \). The criterion is to stay above \( 60^\circ\text{C} \). What is the most accurate evaluation?