Evaluate
Collision Design
Learn to judge how well a collision-related design meets criteria and constraints using the physics of momentum and energy transfer.
What Is a Collision?
A collision occurs when two or more objects come into contact and exert forces on each other over a brief period. During every collision, momentum and energy are transferred between the objects.
Momentum: The Physics of Motion
Momentum measures how hard it is to stop a moving object. It depends on both mass and velocity:
A massive, slow object can carry far more momentum than a fast, light one. Collision designs must account for both factors.
Energy Transfer in Collisions
Moving objects carry kinetic energy. During a collision, kinetic energy can be transferred, transformed, or absorbed:
The Conservation of Momentum
Elastic vs. Inelastic Collisions
| Elastic | Inelastic | |
|---|---|---|
| Momentum | Conserved | Conserved |
| Kinetic Energy | Conserved | NOT conserved |
| Objects After | Bounce apart | May stick together |
| Real-World Example | Billiard balls | Car crash |
| Energy Lost To | None | Heat, sound, deformation |
Criteria vs. Constraints
When evaluating a collision design, you must understand two key engineering terms:
How to Evaluate a Collision Design
Example 1: Bumper Design
Example 2: Helmet Evaluation
Example 3: Egg Drop Challenge
Two student teams design containers to protect an egg dropped from 3 meters. Which design better meets the criteria?
Cost: $2.50
Egg survived: Yes
Stopping distance: 4 cm
Cost: $3.00
Egg survived: Yes
Stopping distance: 8 cm
The Impulse-Momentum Connection
The key physics principle behind collision safety design is the impulse-momentum theorem:
Both curves enclose the same area (same impulse = same momentum change), but the green curve has a much lower peak force. That is the entire goal of safety padding.
Why Stopping Distance Matters
The work-energy theorem tells us that energy absorbed equals force times distance:
Comparing Safety Designs
| Design Feature | What It Does | Physics Principle |
|---|---|---|
| Crumple Zone | Deforms on impact | Increases \( d \) → lowers \( F \) |
| Airbag | Cushions passenger | Increases \( \Delta t \) → lowers \( F \) |
| Seatbelt | Distributes force across body | Spreads force, prevents ejection |
| Helmet Foam | Compresses and absorbs energy | Converts \( KE \) to deformation |
| Bumper | First point of contact | Absorbs initial \( KE \), protects frame |
Common Mistakes in Evaluation
Question 1 of 5
A car's crumple zone is designed to increase the stopping distance during a crash. According to \( F = \frac{KE}{d} \), what happens to the force on passengers when stopping distance doubles?
Question 2 of 5
A student designs an egg-drop container. The egg survives the fall, the container weighs 90 g (under the 150 g limit), but it costs $7 when the budget limit is $5. How should you evaluate this design?
Question 3 of 5
Two identical balls collide. Ball A (\( m = 2 \) kg, \( v = 4 \) m/s) hits stationary Ball B (\( m = 2 \) kg). After the collision, Ball A stops. What is Ball B's velocity?
Question 4 of 5
A helmet's foam liner works by compressing during impact. Which physics principle best explains why this reduces injury?
Question 5 of 5
A car traveling at 20 m/s has kinetic energy \( KE_1 \). If the same car travels at 40 m/s, how does the new kinetic energy \( KE_2 \) compare?