01 / 20

Evaluate
Collision Design

Learn to judge how well a collision-related design meets criteria and constraints using the physics of momentum and energy transfer.

Physical Science

What Is a Collision?

A collision occurs when two or more objects come into contact and exert forces on each other over a brief period. During every collision, momentum and energy are transferred between the objects.

A
\( v_1 \)
⚡ B
\( v_2 \)
Forces act during contact

Momentum: The Physics of Motion

Momentum measures how hard it is to stop a moving object. It depends on both mass and velocity:

Heavy truck at low speed
\( m = 5{,}000\;\text{kg},\; v = 2\;\text{m/s} \) → \( p = 10{,}000\;\text{kg·m/s} \)
Light ball at high speed
\( m = 0.5\;\text{kg},\; v = 40\;\text{m/s} \) → \( p = 20\;\text{kg·m/s} \)

A massive, slow object can carry far more momentum than a fast, light one. Collision designs must account for both factors.

Energy Transfer in Collisions

Moving objects carry kinetic energy. During a collision, kinetic energy can be transferred, transformed, or absorbed:

Absorbed
Crumple zones in cars convert kinetic energy into deformation
Transformed
Energy becomes heat, sound, or light during impact
Transferred
One object slows down while the other speeds up

The Conservation of Momentum

BEFORE 2 kg 3 m/s 1 kg at rest AFTER 2 kg 1 m/s 1 kg 4 m/s
\( p = 6 \)
\( p = 6 \)

Elastic vs. Inelastic Collisions

Elastic Inelastic
Momentum Conserved Conserved
Kinetic Energy Conserved NOT conserved
Objects After Bounce apart May stick together
Real-World Example Billiard balls Car crash
Energy Lost To None Heat, sound, deformation

Criteria vs. Constraints

When evaluating a collision design, you must understand two key engineering terms:

Criteria
What the design must accomplish. These are the goals: reduce force on passengers, absorb energy, redirect objects safely.
Constraints
The limits and restrictions on the design: budget, materials available, size, weight, manufacturing difficulty.

How to Evaluate a Collision Design

1
Identify the criteria. What must the design achieve? (e.g., reduce peak force below a safe threshold)
2
Identify the constraints. What are the limits? (e.g., total mass < 50 kg, cost < $100)
3
Analyze the physics. Use \( p = mv \) and \( KE = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 \) to calculate momentum and energy before and after the collision.
4
Check criteria against data. Does the design reduce force, absorb energy, or redirect motion as required?
5
Check constraints. Does the design stay within budget, weight, size, and material limits?

Example 1: Bumper Design

1,000 kg Bumper Wall 5 m/s Crumples 0.3 m

Example 2: Helmet Evaluation

Head Hard Shell Foam Liner Impact Two layers work together Shell spreads force, foam absorbs energy

Example 3: Egg Drop Challenge

Two student teams design containers to protect an egg dropped from 3 meters. Which design better meets the criteria?

Design A: Foam Box
Mass: 120 g
Cost: $2.50
Egg survived: Yes
Stopping distance: 4 cm
Design B: Parachute + Bubble Wrap
Mass: 85 g
Cost: $3.00
Egg survived: Yes
Stopping distance: 8 cm

The Impulse-Momentum Connection

The key physics principle behind collision safety design is the impulse-momentum theorem:

Time (s) Force (N) No padding With padding Same area Same area

Both curves enclose the same area (same impulse = same momentum change), but the green curve has a much lower peak force. That is the entire goal of safety padding.

Why Stopping Distance Matters

The work-energy theorem tells us that energy absorbed equals force times distance:

1
Crumple zones in cars increase \( d \) by letting the frame collapse gradually.
2
Airbags increase \( d \) for the passenger's head and chest, extending the deceleration path.
3
Foam padding in helmets compresses on impact, adding several centimeters of stopping distance.

Comparing Safety Designs

Design Feature What It Does Physics Principle
Crumple Zone Deforms on impact Increases \( d \) → lowers \( F \)
Airbag Cushions passenger Increases \( \Delta t \) → lowers \( F \)
Seatbelt Distributes force across body Spreads force, prevents ejection
Helmet Foam Compresses and absorbs energy Converts \( KE \) to deformation
Bumper First point of contact Absorbs initial \( KE \), protects frame

Common Mistakes in Evaluation

✕ Ignoring Constraints
A design might protect perfectly but exceed the weight or cost limit: it still fails the evaluation.
✕ Confusing Energy and Momentum
Momentum is always conserved in collisions; kinetic energy usually is not. Mixing these up leads to wrong conclusions.
✕ Forgetting \( v^2 \)
Kinetic energy depends on velocity squared. A small speed increase causes a large energy increase: doubling speed means 4x the energy.

Question 1 of 5

A car's crumple zone is designed to increase the stopping distance during a crash. According to \( F = \frac{KE}{d} \), what happens to the force on passengers when stopping distance doubles?

Question 2 of 5

A student designs an egg-drop container. The egg survives the fall, the container weighs 90 g (under the 150 g limit), but it costs $7 when the budget limit is $5. How should you evaluate this design?

Question 3 of 5

Two identical balls collide. Ball A (\( m = 2 \) kg, \( v = 4 \) m/s) hits stationary Ball B (\( m = 2 \) kg). After the collision, Ball A stops. What is Ball B's velocity?

Question 4 of 5

A helmet's foam liner works by compressing during impact. Which physics principle best explains why this reduces injury?

Question 5 of 5

A car traveling at 20 m/s has kinetic energy \( KE_1 \). If the same car travels at 40 m/s, how does the new kinetic energy \( KE_2 \) compare?