Reading Comprehension Quiz
20 questions · no time limit
0:00
LOGIC & REASONING
Question 1 of 20
No time limit
Current
Answered
Flagged
Not seen
PASSAGE
Risk assessment tools that estimate a defendant's likelihood of pretrial misconduct have been criticized for perpetuating bias, particularly racial disparities. Proponents respond that, when designed properly, such tools can reduce arbitrary human decision-making: they exclude protected-class variables, undergo external validation, and present calibrated risk categories to judges. Because these systems are transparent about which factors they use—prior failures to appear, current charge severity, age at first arrest, and the like—they can be audited and improved in a way that idiosyncratic human judgment cannot. Moreover, in jurisdictions where human judges have historically detained many defendants who would have succeeded on release, replacing discretion with structured guidance may lower detention rates overall. Critics note that historical data reflect policing patterns that overexpose some communities to arrest and surveillance, threatening to encode past practices into the future. But proponents argue that validation can detect and correct miscalibration: if a category labeled 'moderate risk' has equal failure rates across groups, then classifications are fair in the relevant sense. Despite the unresolved philosophical debates, the practical question for policymakers is whether deploying a validated tool will worsen racial disparities in detention compared with status quo judging. Given that the tools omit protected-class variables, are validated for accuracy and calibration, and provide consistent inputs to judges, there is little reason to fear that, when properly validated, their deployment will exacerbate racial disparities in pretrial detention; indeed, they may modestly reduce those disparities by disciplining human discretion.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the claim made in the passage that properly validated risk assessment tools are unlikely to exacerbate racial disparities in pretrial detention?
YOUR PROGRESS
20
QUESTIONS
Ready when you are
Answer in any order. Your progress shows here as you go.
QUESTIONS
KEYBOARD
Pick an answer ABCDE
Next question ↵→
Previous ←
Flag for review F
Answers save as you go · flagged questions come back at the end