01 / 20

Synthesizing
Multiple Sources

Master the skill of combining information from different passages to draw conclusions, identify relationships, and build a unified understanding.

ISEE Upper Level Reading Comprehension

What Is Synthesis?

Synthesis means combining ideas from two or more sources to create a new, deeper understanding. It goes beyond simply summarizing each passage on its own: you must find the connections, contrasts, and patterns that emerge when you read them together.

Why the ISEE Tests Synthesis

Higher-Order Thinking
Synthesis proves you can analyze, not just recall facts from a single passage.
Real-World Readiness
College and career work requires integrating multiple perspectives constantly.
Distinguishing Top Scores
Synthesis questions separate strong readers from merely competent ones.

Single-Source vs. Multi-Source Reading

SINGLE SOURCE Passage A Summary of A vs. MULTI-SOURCE Pass. A Pass. B + New Insight

The Three Pillars of Synthesis

1 Identify Connections Find shared themes, topics, or facts across passages. 2 Analyze Differences Note contrasting viewpoints, tones, or evidence. 3 Draw New Conclusions Combine evidence to form insights neither passage states alone.

The Synthesis Rule

On the ISEE, the correct answer will always be traceable back to specific details in each passage. If an answer choice only references one passage, it is not a synthesis: it is a summary.

Synthesis vs. Summary vs. Comparison

Skill What It Does Example
Summary Restates one passage's main idea "Passage A argues that bees face habitat loss."
Comparison Lists similarities or differences "Passage A blames habitat loss; Passage B blames pesticides."
Synthesis Creates a new conclusion from both "Together, both passages suggest bees face multiple, compounding threats."

The Five-Step Strategy

1
Read each passage independently. Note the main idea, tone, and key evidence for each.
2
Identify the shared topic. What subject or question do both passages address?
3
Map agreements and disagreements. Where do the authors align, and where do they diverge?
4
Form a combined conclusion. Ask: "What new understanding emerges from reading both?"
5
Verify with both passages. Check that your conclusion is supported by specific evidence from each source.

Worked Example: Coral Reefs

Passage A: Marine Biologist
"Rising ocean temperatures cause coral bleaching. Without intervention, 70% of reefs could die by 2050."
Passage B: Economist
"Coral reefs generate $36 billion annually in tourism. Coastal communities depend on reefs for their livelihoods."

Building the Synthesis

Passage A Reefs dying by 2050 Passage B $36B economy at stake SYNTHE- SIZE Reef loss threatens both ecosystems AND economies

Harder Example: Space Exploration

Passage A: Historian
"The Apollo program succeeded because of Cold War competition. National pride, not scientific curiosity, drove the moon landing."
Passage B: Scientist
"Modern space exploration focuses on Mars colonization and asteroid mining. Today's goals are driven by resource scarcity and survival."

When Sources Conflict

Passage A
"Social media helps teens build communities, develop identities, and access support networks."
Passage B
"Social media increases anxiety, promotes comparison, and disrupts sleep patterns among adolescents."

Recognizing Synthesis Questions

ISEE synthesis questions use specific signal phrases in the question stem. Learn to spot them instantly:

✓
"Both authors would most likely agree that..."
✓
"Based on both passages, the reader can conclude..."
✓
"How do the two passages differ in their treatment of..."
✓
"Which statement is supported by information in both passages?"
✓
"The authors of Passage 1 and Passage 2 would disagree about..."

Types of Relationships Between Passages

Complementary
Passages support the same idea from different angles. Together they strengthen the claim.
Contradictory
Passages present opposing views. The synthesis identifies the point of disagreement and what it reveals.
Cause and Effect
One passage describes a phenomenon, the other explains its consequence. Linking them creates a causal chain.
General to Specific
One passage offers a broad principle; the other provides a concrete example. Together they illustrate and validate.

Common Mistakes

✕ One-Passage Trap
Choosing an answer supported by only one passage. A synthesis answer must draw from both.
✕ Over-Generalizing
Making a sweeping claim that goes beyond what either passage actually states. Stick to what the text supports.
✕ Confusing Summary with Synthesis
Restating what each passage says individually instead of combining them into a new insight.
✕ Injecting Outside Knowledge
Using facts you know but that neither passage mentions. The ISEE tests reading, not prior knowledge.

Synthesis Cheat Sheet

Step Action Check
1 Read each passage and note main ideas Can I state each main idea in one sentence?
2 Identify the shared topic Do both passages address the same subject?
3 Map agreements and disagreements Are they complementary, contradictory, or cause-effect?
4 Form a combined conclusion Does my conclusion require BOTH passages?
5 Verify with textual evidence Can I point to specific lines in each?

Question 1 of 5

Based on both passages, which conclusion is best supported?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement represents a valid synthesis of both passages?

Question 3 of 5

Both authors would most likely agree that:

Question 4 of 5

What type of relationship exists between these two passages?

Question 5 of 5

A student writes: "Passage A says electric cars are good for the environment. Passage B says electric cars are expensive." Which of the following best describes why this is not a synthesis?