01 / 20

Supporting
Evidence

Learn to identify and select evidence from a passage that directly supports a given conclusion: the essential skill for ISEE Reading Comprehension.

ISEE Upper Level Reading Comprehension

What Is Supporting Evidence?

Supporting evidence is a specific detail, fact, example, or quotation drawn directly from a passage that proves or strengthens a conclusion. On the ISEE, you will be asked to find the answer choice that best backs up a stated claim.

Evidence vs. Conclusion

EVIDENCE Specific facts, details, quotations from the passage SUPPORTS CONCLUSION A claim, judgment, or main idea the author makes
"Temperatures rose \(2^\circ\text{F}\)
over the last decade."
"The climate is getting warmer."

Why It Matters on the ISEE

High Frequency
Supporting evidence questions appear in nearly every ISEE reading passage, making this skill essential for a strong score.
Text-Based Answers
The correct answer is always provable from the passage: no guessing, no outside knowledge needed.
Transferable Skill
This reasoning carries over to main idea, inference, and tone questions: all require evidence awareness.

The Core Rule of Evidence

Strong Evidence Specific Not vague From the Passage Relevant On topic Logically Linked

The Evidence Strength Spectrum

Weak Moderate Strong Vague paraphrase Off-topic detail Outside knowledge Related but indirect Partial support True but tangential Direct quote/fact Specific data point Logical cause-effect

Evidence vs. Inference

Evidence Inference
Definition A fact or detail stated in the passage A conclusion drawn from evidence
Location Directly in the text Beyond the text (reader's reasoning)
Role on ISEE The answer to "Which supports..." The question stem or conclusion itself
Example "Sales rose 40% in Q3." "Business was improving."

The 4-Step Method

1
Read the conclusion first. Identify the exact claim or idea you need to support before looking at choices.
2
Return to the passage. Scan for specific details, facts, or quotations related to the conclusion. Underline or note key lines.
3
Match, don't invent. Compare each answer choice against the passage text. The best evidence is a near-direct match, not a creative interpretation.
4
Eliminate distractors. Remove choices that are off-topic, too vague, or true-but-irrelevant. The last choice standing is your answer.

Worked Example: Easy

Conclusion: The recycling program was successful.

✕ Weak
"Teachers taught science classes." (True but does not show success.)
✓ Strong
"Collected 2,000 lbs of paper, a 35% increase." (Specific data proving growth.)

Worked Example: Medium

Conclusion: The expedition was extremely difficult.

~ Moderate
"Many believed it would fail." (Shows doubt, but not hardship itself.)
✓ Strong
"They endured minus 40° temps, rationed food, lost sleds, and only 3 of 7 remained." (Multiple concrete hardships.)

Worked Example: Hard

Conclusion: Dr. Patel's findings are reliable.

✕ Trap
"Participants scored 23% lower on memory tests." (Supports her claim about sleep, but not that her findings are reliable.)
✓ Best
"A follow-up study with 1,200 subjects confirmed similar results." (Replication with a larger sample proves reliability.)

Anatomy of an ISEE Question

QUESTION STEM "Which detail best supports the idea that...?" EMBEDDED CONCLUSION (A) Off-topic detail From passage but irrelevant (B) True-but-vague Restates idea without evidence (C) Direct evidence ✓ Specific fact supporting conclusion (D) Opposite evidence Contradicts or weakens claim

Types of Distractors

Off-Topic
A true detail from the passage that has nothing to do with the conclusion in question.
Too Vague
Restates the conclusion in different words instead of providing new, specific evidence.
Opposite
A detail that actually weakens or contradicts the conclusion, trapping students who read too quickly.

Common Mistakes

✕ Choosing Outside Knowledge
Picking an answer because it is true in real life, even though it is not stated in the passage.
✕ Picking the First True Detail
Selecting a detail just because it appears in the passage, without checking if it logically connects to the conclusion.
✕ Confusing Evidence with Conclusion
Choosing a restatement of the claim itself, which is a circular answer, not supporting evidence.

Evidence Quick Reference

Check Good Evidence Bad Evidence
Source Directly from the passage Outside knowledge
Specificity Concrete facts, numbers, quotes Vague generalizations
Relevance Directly addresses the conclusion True but about a different point
Logical Link Clearly proves or supports Restates or contradicts
ISEE Signal Words "best supports," "according to" "the reader can infer" (different Q-type)

Question 1 of 5

Which detail from the passage best supports the conclusion that the bike-sharing program benefited public health?

Question 2 of 5

Which detail best supports the idea that the novelist was innovative?

Question 3 of 5

The passage suggests that losing honeybees would hurt the economy. Which detail best supports this conclusion?

Question 4 of 5

Which detail best supports the conclusion that the longer school day had negative effects?

Question 5 of 5

Which detail provides the strongest evidence that octopuses are intelligent?