Supporting
Evidence
Learn to identify and select evidence from a passage that directly supports a given conclusion: the essential skill for ISEE Reading Comprehension.
What Is Supporting Evidence?
Supporting evidence is a specific detail, fact, example, or quotation drawn directly from a passage that proves or strengthens a conclusion. On the ISEE, you will be asked to find the answer choice that best backs up a stated claim.
Evidence vs. Conclusion
Why It Matters on the ISEE
The Core Rule of Evidence
The Evidence Strength Spectrum
Evidence vs. Inference
| Evidence | Inference | |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | A fact or detail stated in the passage | A conclusion drawn from evidence |
| Location | Directly in the text | Beyond the text (reader's reasoning) |
| Role on ISEE | The answer to "Which supports..." | The question stem or conclusion itself |
| Example | "Sales rose 40% in Q3." | "Business was improving." |
The 4-Step Method
Worked Example: Easy
Conclusion: The recycling program was successful.
Worked Example: Medium
Conclusion: The expedition was extremely difficult.
Worked Example: Hard
Conclusion: Dr. Patel's findings are reliable.
Anatomy of an ISEE Question
Types of Distractors
Common Mistakes
Evidence Quick Reference
| Check | Good Evidence | Bad Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Directly from the passage | Outside knowledge |
| Specificity | Concrete facts, numbers, quotes | Vague generalizations |
| Relevance | Directly addresses the conclusion | True but about a different point |
| Logical Link | Clearly proves or supports | Restates or contradicts |
| ISEE Signal Words | "best supports," "according to" | "the reader can infer" (different Q-type) |
Question 1 of 5
"The city's new bike-sharing program has been a remarkable success. In its first six months, ridership exceeded projections by 60%. Local businesses near bike stations reported a 15% rise in foot traffic, and hospital data showed a decline in pollution-related respiratory visits."
Which detail from the passage best supports the conclusion that the bike-sharing program benefited public health?
Question 2 of 5
"Although the novelist was little known during her lifetime, her works have since been recognized as groundbreaking. Her 1923 novel introduced stream-of-consciousness narration to American fiction, and contemporary critics now rank her among the most innovative writers of the twentieth century."
Which detail best supports the idea that the novelist was innovative?
Question 3 of 5
"Honeybees are essential to agriculture. They pollinate approximately 80% of all flowering plants, including many crops that humans depend on for food. Without bees, farmers would need to rely on expensive and less effective methods of pollination, which could raise food prices dramatically."
The passage suggests that losing honeybees would hurt the economy. Which detail best supports this conclusion?
Question 4 of 5
"The school board voted to extend the school day by 45 minutes. Supporters argued that additional instructional time would improve test scores. However, students reported feeling more fatigued, participation in after-school clubs dropped by 30%, and teachers noted that attention spans declined sharply in the final period."
Which detail best supports the conclusion that the longer school day had negative effects?
Question 5 of 5
"Marine biologists have long debated whether octopuses display intelligence. Recent experiments show that octopuses can solve multi-step puzzles, unscrew jars from the inside, and navigate mazes after a single trial. One researcher observed an octopus using a coconut shell as a portable shelter: the first documented case of tool use in an invertebrate."
Which detail provides the strongest evidence that octopuses are intelligent?