01 / 20

Drawing Text-Based
Conclusions

Master the skill of forming logical conclusions backed by textual evidence: the cornerstone of ISEE reading comprehension.

ISEE Upper Level Reading Comprehension

What Is a Conclusion?

A conclusion is a judgment or decision you reach by reasoning from evidence in the text. Unlike a summary, which restates facts, a conclusion goes one step further: it tells you what the facts add up to.

Why This Skill Matters

ISEE Frequency
Conclusion questions appear on nearly every reading passage. They are among the most common question types.
Higher-Order Thinking
These questions test whether you can reason beyond the surface. They separate strong readers from average ones.
Cross-Subject Value
Drawing conclusions from evidence is essential in science, history, and persuasive writing: not just reading tests.

The Evidence-to-Conclusion Bridge

Textual Evidence Your Reasoning (logical inference) Conclusion (supported claim) What the text says What you figure out What it all means

The Core Rule of Conclusions

A valid conclusion must be: Supported by the text + Logically reasonable + Not contradicted by any detail

Every answer choice on the ISEE will test whether you can distinguish a conclusion that is actually supported by the passage from one that sounds reasonable but has no evidence.

Conclusions vs. Inferences vs. Opinions

Conclusion Inference Opinion
Definition Final judgment from evidence A single "reading between the lines" step Personal belief or preference
Evidence Required? Yes: must be in text Yes: implied by text No: subjective
Scope Big picture, overall Specific detail or moment Varies wildly
ISEE Tested? ★ Very often ★ Often Rarely directly

The 4-Step Method

1
Read the question first. Know whether it asks for a conclusion about the whole passage or a specific paragraph.
2
Locate relevant evidence. Scan for key details, facts, descriptions, or the author's tone that relate to the question.
3
Form your own conclusion before looking at the choices. This prevents trap answers from swaying you.
4
Match and eliminate. Pick the choice closest to your conclusion. Eliminate any choice that is unsupported, too extreme, or contradicted by the text.

Worked Example: The Coral Reef

Question: Based on the passage, what can the reader conclude?

Analyzing the Evidence

Evidence 1: 40% decline in coral coverage Evidence 2: Rising temps + acidification Evidence 3: Shrinking fish catches Conclusion: Coral reef degradation is harming both ecosystems and local economies. Too Extreme: "All coral reefs will vanish"

Worked Example: The Inventor

What can the reader conclude about Margaret Knight?

✓ Supported
Knight was a determined and resourceful inventor who overcame gender-based obstacles.
✕ Unsupported
Knight was the greatest inventor of her generation. (The passage does not compare her to others.)

Harder Example: Tone as Evidence

Question: What conclusion is best supported by the passage?

A
The report satisfied all parties. (Contradicted: critics objected.)
B
The report was deliberately non-committal. (Supported: "vague," "evasion," "avoided.")
C
The committee lacked expertise. (No evidence of their qualifications.)

Spotting Signal Words

Certain words and phrases in a passage signal that evidence is building toward a conclusion. Train yourself to notice them:

Cause/Effect
therefore, consequently, as a result, because, since, due to
Contrast
however, although, despite, nevertheless, on the other hand, yet
Emphasis
importantly, significantly, notably, in particular, especially, above all

Choosing the Right Strength

Cautious "suggests" "likely" Moderate "indicates" "shows that" Extreme "proves" "always" ✓ ISEE correct answers usually live here

Common Mistakes

✕ Using Outside Knowledge
Choosing an answer because you know it is true in real life, even though the passage does not mention it.
✕ Overgeneralizing
Jumping from "some evidence" to "always" or "never." Watch for absolute language in answer choices.
✕ Confusing Stated with Concluded
Picking an answer that simply restates a fact from the passage instead of drawing a new conclusion from it.
✕ Emotional Appeal
Selecting an answer that "feels right" or is emotionally satisfying, even though no evidence supports it.

Quick Reference Summary

Principle Do This Avoid This
Evidence Point to specific lines Rely on general memory
Scope Match the passage's scope Go broader or narrower
Strength Use cautious language Use absolutes
Reasoning Follow the author's logic Insert your own opinion
Distractors Eliminate with evidence Pick what "sounds right"

Question 1 of 5

Which conclusion is best supported by the passage?

Question 2 of 5

Based on the passage, what can the reader conclude about the town's situation?

Question 3 of 5

What conclusion does the passage best support?

Question 4 of 5

From the passage, the reader can conclude that:

Question 5 of 5

Which conclusion about the astronaut's experience is best supported?