SECTION 1
Historical Context & Motivation
For centuries, chemists could describe what formed in a chemical reaction, but they struggled to explain how bonds actually broke and reformed at the atomic level. The idea that reactions proceed through the directed movement of electron pairs was a breakthrough that transformed chemistry from a descriptive science into one that could predict and design new reactions. Understanding the history of this concept helps us appreciate why electron-pair sharing reactions are central to modern organic and inorganic chemistry.
1916 • Lewis's Electron-Pair Bond
1923 • Lewis Acids and Bases
1933 • Ingold's Nucleophile & Electrophile
1941 • Curly Arrow Notation
1960s • Frontier Molecular Orbital Theory
These milestones reveal a central question in chemistry: when two molecules collide, what determines which bonds break and which new bonds form? The answer lies in understanding where electron pairs are located, how they move, and what drives them from one atom to another. This lesson explores the principles behind electron-pair sharing reactions and equips you with the tools to predict and explain these processes.
SECTION 2
Core Principles & Definitions
Electron-pair sharing reactions revolve around the idea that bonds form and break because pairs of electrons move between atoms or molecules. To understand this fully, you need to master a handful of foundational concepts that serve as the vocabulary for reaction mechanisms in IB Chemistry.
Nucleophile
Electrophile
Curly Arrow (Curved Arrow)
Heterolytic Bond Breaking
Lewis Acid–Base Reaction
KEY TAKEAWAY
SECTION 3
Visual Explanation — Curly Arrow Mechanisms
The curly arrow is the single most important tool for communicating how electron pairs move during a reaction. A double-headed curly arrow always represents the movement of two electrons (one pair). The diagram below shows a generic nucleophilic attack on an electrophile, illustrating how a new bond forms and an old bond breaks simultaneously.
Notice how each curly arrow accounts for exactly one electron pair. The tail of the cyan arrow originates at the lone pair on Nu−, and the arrowhead lands between Nu and C — this is where the new bond forms. Simultaneously, the pink arrow shows the bonding pair in the C–L bond departing entirely with the leaving group L, which becomes L−. This coordinated movement of electron pairs is the essence of electron-pair sharing reactions.
SECTION 4
How Electron-Pair Sharing Works — Mechanism Deep Dive
Coordinate (Dative) Covalent Bond Formation
In a standard covalent bond, each atom contributes one electron to the shared pair. In a coordinate covalent bond (also called a dative bond), both electrons come from the same atom — the nucleophile. This is exactly what happens in every electron-pair sharing reaction. The nucleophile provides both electrons, and the electrophile simply accepts them into its empty or partially vacant orbital.
Identifying Nucleophilic and Electrophilic Sites
To predict where electron pairs will move, you need to locate the electron-rich and electron-poor regions in a molecule. Electronegativity differences within bonds create partial charges: the more electronegative atom pulls electron density toward itself (δ−), leaving the less electronegative atom electron-poor (δ+). For example, in a C–Cl bond, chlorine is more electronegative, so carbon bears a partial positive charge and acts as the electrophilic centre.
Frontier Molecular Orbital Theory — Extension Only (Beyond IB Scope)
Not Required for IB Assessment — Extension Reading
At a deeper level studied at university, electron-pair sharing can be understood using frontier molecular orbitals. The nucleophile's electron pair resides in its Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO), while the electrophile has a Lowest Unoccupied Molecular Orbital (LUMO) ready to accept electrons. A reaction occurs when the HOMO of the nucleophile overlaps effectively with the LUMO of the electrophile. The smaller the energy gap between HOMO and LUMO, the easier the reaction. This is a concept explored in university-level organic and physical chemistry courses.
IB Exam Tip
SECTION 5
Classifying Electron-Pair Sharing Reactions
Electron-pair sharing reactions can be classified by the type of species that initiates the reaction (nucleophile or electrophile) and the structural change that occurs. In IB Chemistry, you will encounter three major categories: nucleophilic substitution, electrophilic addition, and nucleophilic addition. The diagram below compares these three pathways.
| Feature | Nucleophilic Substitution | Electrophilic Addition | Nucleophilic Addition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Substrate | Haloalkane (sp³ C) | Alkene or alkyne (C=C) | Aldehyde or ketone (C=O) |
| Attacking species | Nucleophile (e.g., OH⁻, CN⁻) | Electrophile (e.g., H⁺, Br⁺) | Nucleophile (e.g., H⁻, CN⁻) |
| Bond changes | One made, one broken | π bond broken, two σ bonds made | π bond broken, one σ bond made |
| Leaving group? | Yes | No | No |
Summary of three electron-pair sharing reaction types
SECTION 6
Worked Example — S_N2 Reaction of Bromomethane with Hydroxide
Let's work through a complete electron-pair sharing reaction mechanism. We will examine the S_N2 nucleophilic substitution of bromomethane (CH3Br) with hydroxide ion (OH−).
S_N2 Reaction: CH₃Br + OH⁻ → CH₃OH + Br⁻
- 1
Step 1 — Identify the Nucleophile and Electrophile
The hydroxide ion (OH−) has three lone pairs on the oxygen atom and carries a negative charge, making it an excellent nucleophile. The carbon in CH3Br is bonded to the electronegative bromine atom, which pulls electron density away from it. This makes the carbon electrophilic (δ⁺). Bromine is the leaving group because it can stabilize the negative charge after departure.Nucleophile: OH⁻ | Electrophile: Cδ⁺ in CH₃Br | Leaving group: Br⁻ - 2
Step 2 — Draw the Curly Arrow from Nucleophile to Electrophile
Draw a curly arrow starting from a lone pair on the oxygen of OH− (the tail), pointing to the carbon atom in CH3Br (the head). This arrow represents the formation of the new O–C bond using the electron pair from oxygen.Arrow 1: lone pair on O → C atom (bond formation) - 3
Step 3 — Draw the Curly Arrow for Bond Breaking
Since carbon can only form four bonds, the C–Br bond must break as the new O–C bond forms. Draw a second curly arrow from the C–Br bond (the tail) to the bromine atom (the head). This represents the heterolytic fission of the C–Br bond — both bonding electrons go to bromine.Arrow 2: C–Br bond → Br atom (bond breaking) - 4
Step 4 — Write the Products
The nucleophile has replaced the leaving group. The organic product is methanol (CH3OH), and the inorganic product is bromide ion (Br−). In SN2, this happens in a single, concerted step — bond making and breaking occur simultaneously.CH₃Br + OH⁻ → CH₃OH + Br⁻ - 5
Step 5 — Verify Conservation
Check that atoms and charges are balanced. Reactant side: one C, three H, one Br, one O, one H, overall charge = −1. Product side: one C, three H, one O, one H, one Br, overall charge = −1. Everything balances, confirming that our curly arrows correctly tracked the electron-pair movement.Atoms balanced ✓ | Charges balanced ✓ | Mechanism complete ✓
SECTION 6B
Worked Example — Electrophilic Addition of HBr to Ethene
The IB specification requires you to draw complete curly-arrow mechanisms for electrophilic addition to alkenes. This is one of the most important reaction types you will meet in Reactivity 3.4. In electrophilic addition, the electron-rich π bond of an alkene acts as the nucleophile and donates a pair of electrons to an incoming electrophile (such as HBr or Br2). Let's work through the addition of HBr to ethene (CH2=CH2) step by step.
Electrophilic Addition: CH₂=CH₂ + HBr → CH₃CH₂Br
- 1
Step 1 — Identify the Roles of Each Species
In HBr, the H–Br bond is polar. The hydrogen end is electron-poor (δ+) and acts as the electrophile. The π bond of ethene has electron density above and below the C=C bond, making the alkene the nucleophile in this reaction. There is no leaving group — instead, both atoms of HBr add across the double bond.Nucleophile: π bond of C=C | Electrophile: Hδ⁺ in HBr | No leaving group - 2
Step 2 — Draw the Curly Arrows for Step 1 (π attack on H⁺)
Draw the first curly arrow starting from the C=C π bond (the tail) and pointing to the H atom of HBr (the head). This arrow shows the π electrons attacking the electrophilic hydrogen. At the same time, draw a second curly arrow from the H–Br bond to the bromine atom, showing heterolytic fission of the H–Br bond. Both electrons of the H–Br bond go to Br, which leaves as Br−.Arrow 1: C=C π bond → H of HBr (new C–H bond forms) | Arrow 2: H–Br bond → Br (H–Br breaks, Br⁻ departs) - 3
Step 3 — Identify the Carbocation Intermediate
After step 1, one carbon of the original double bond has formed a new C–H bond and now has four bonds. The other carbon has lost its share of the π electrons and is left with only three bonds — it carries a positive charge. This species is called a carbocation (CH3–CH+₂). The carbocation intermediate is the electrophilic species in the second step.Intermediate: CH₃–CH⁺ (ethyl carbocation) + Br⁻ - 4
Step 4 — Draw the Curly Arrow for Step 2 (Br⁻ attacks carbocation)
In the second step, the bromide ion (Br−) generated in step 1 now acts as a nucleophile. Draw a curly arrow from a lone pair on Br− (the tail) to the positively charged carbon of the carbocation (the head). This forms the new C–Br bond and gives the final product.Arrow 3: lone pair on Br⁻ → C⁺ of carbocation (new C–Br bond forms) - 5
Step 5 — Write the Overall Equation and Verify
The product is bromoethane (CH3CH2Br). Both H and Br have added across the original double bond. Check: reactants have 2C, 4H, 1Br; product has 2C, 5H, 1Br — wait, the H from HBr adds too, giving 2C, 5H, 1Br overall. Charges: reactants neutral (HBr and CH₂=CH₂), product neutral (CH₃CH₂Br). ✓CH₂=CH₂ + HBr → CH₃CH₂Br
IB Exam Tip — Electrophilic Addition
SECTION 6C
Worked Example — Nucleophilic Addition to a Carbonyl Compound
The IB specification also requires curly-arrow mechanisms for nucleophilic addition to carbonyl compounds (aldehydes and ketones). In this reaction type, a nucleophile attacks the electron-poor carbon of a polar C=O bond. A classic IB example is the addition of cyanide ion (CN−) to ethanal (CH3CHO).
Nucleophilic Addition: CH₃CHO + HCN → CH₃CH(OH)CN
- 1
Step 1 — Identify the Nucleophile and Electrophilic Centre
In ethanal, the C=O bond is strongly polarised because oxygen is much more electronegative than carbon. This makes the carbonyl carbon electron-poor (Cδ+) and therefore the electrophilic site. The cyanide ion (CN−) has a lone pair on the carbon atom, making it the nucleophile. Unlike substitution, there is no leaving group — the π bond simply breaks and both electrons go to oxygen.Nucleophile: CN⁻ (lone pair on C of CN⁻) | Electrophile: Cδ⁺ of C=O | No leaving group - 2
Step 2 — Draw the Two Curly Arrows
Draw the first curly arrow from the lone pair on the carbon of CN− (the tail) to the carbonyl carbon of ethanal (the head). This shows the formation of the new C–CN bond. Simultaneously, draw a second curly arrow from the C=O π bond (the tail) to the oxygen atom (the head). This shows the π bond electrons moving entirely onto oxygen as the double bond breaks down to a single bond, giving oxygen a negative charge (O−).Arrow 1: lone pair on C of CN⁻ → carbonyl C (new C–C bond) | Arrow 2: C=O π bond → O (O gains lone pair, becomes O⁻) - 3
Step 3 — Identify the Tetrahedral Intermediate
After the nucleophilic attack, the carbonyl carbon has changed from trigonal planar (sp² hybridisation, three groups) to tetrahedral (sp³ hybridisation, four groups). The intermediate is an alkoxide ion — a species with a negatively charged oxygen (–O−). The formula of the intermediate is CH3CH(CN)O−.Intermediate: CH₃CH(CN)O⁻ (alkoxide ion, tetrahedral carbon) - 4
Step 4 — Protonation to Give the Final Product
In aqueous solution (or with a proton source such as dilute acid), the alkoxide ion is quickly protonated. A water molecule (or H+) donates a proton to the O−. This gives the final product: a hydroxynitrile (also called a cyanohydrin). The overall equation is CH3CHO + HCN → CH3CH(OH)CN.CH₃CHO + HCN → CH₃CH(OH)CN (2-hydroxypropanenitrile) - 5
Step 5 — Verify Conservation and Note Key Feature
Verify atom and charge balance. Reactants: CH3CHO + HCN gives 3C, 4H, 1O, 1N, neutral overall. Product: CH3CH(OH)CN gives 3C, 4H, 1O, 1N, neutral overall. ✓ The carbonyl carbon has become tetrahedral in the product — a key feature of nucleophilic addition.Atoms balanced ✓ | Charges balanced ✓ | C=O (trigonal planar) → C–OH (tetrahedral) ✓
IB Exam Tip — Nucleophilic Addition
SECTION 7
Heterolytic vs. Homolytic — Comparing Bond-Breaking Mechanisms
Not all bond-breaking processes involve electron-pair sharing. It's important to distinguish heterolytic fission (where one atom takes both electrons) from homolytic fission (where each atom takes one electron). The type of fission determines whether the reaction proceeds via electron pairs or free radicals.
| Feature | Heterolytic Fission | Homolytic Fission |
|---|---|---|
| Electron distribution | Both electrons go to one atom | One electron to each atom |
| Products | Ions (cation + anion) | Free radicals |
| Arrow notation | Double-headed curly arrow (two electrons) | Single-headed fish-hook arrow (one electron) |
| Favoured conditions | Polar solvents, polar bonds | UV light, high temperature, non-polar bonds |
| Example | CH₃Br → CH₃⁺ + Br⁻ | Cl₂ → Cl• + Cl• |
Comparison of heterolytic and homolytic bond fission
KEY TAKEAWAY
SECTION 8
Connection to Advanced Theory — Reaction Kinetics & Stereochemistry
Understanding electron-pair sharing reactions at the mechanism level opens the door to predicting reaction rates and stereochemical outcomes. For instance, an SN2 reaction always produces inversion of configuration (the nucleophile attacks from the opposite side of the leaving group). The SN1 mechanism — in which a carbocation intermediate forms before the nucleophile attacks — is not required for IB Reactivity 3.4 and is included in the comparison table below for extension purposes only. You will not be assessed on SN1 in your IB exams.
Extension Only — SN1 is Beyond IB Scope
| Feature | S_N2 (IB Level) | S_N1 (Extension — Beyond IB Scope) |
|---|---|---|
| Number of steps | One (concerted) | Two (via carbocation) |
| Rate law | Rate = k[Nu⁻][substrate] | Rate = k[substrate] |
| Stereochemistry | Inversion (Walden inversion) | Racemization (mixture) |
| Preferred substrate | Primary haloalkane (less steric hindrance) | Tertiary haloalkane (stable carbocation) |
| Solvent effect | Favoured in aprotic polar solvents | Favoured in protic polar solvents |
Comparing SN2 (IB level) and SN1 (extension only) reaction pathways
As you progress beyond IB, you will see how the concepts of steric effects and solvent polarity interweave to give you a complete picture of reactivity. The curly-arrow mechanisms you learn now form the essential foundation for university-level organic chemistry, biochemistry, and even drug design. Every pharmaceutical synthesis involves dozens of carefully planned electron-pair sharing reactions.
SECTION 9
Practice Problems
Question 1: CONCEPTUAL
Show answer
Question 2: BASIC CALCULATION
Show answer
Question 3: INTERMEDIATE
Show answer
Question 4: APPLIED
Show answer
Question 5: CRITICAL THINKING
Show answer
SUMMARY
Lesson Summary
Summary
Electron-pair sharing reactions are the foundation of organic reaction mechanisms. Every such reaction involves a nucleophile (electron-pair donor) and an electrophile (electron-pair acceptor). The movement of electron pairs is tracked using curly arrows, which always start at the electron source (tail) and end at the electron sink (head). When a bond breaks and both electrons go to one atom, this is heterolytic fission. The new bond formed when both electrons come from one atom is a coordinate (dative) covalent bond.
The three major IB reaction types are nucleophilic substitution (SN2) (a nucleophile replaces a leaving group on an sp³ carbon in a concerted single step), electrophilic addition (an electrophile attacks a π bond in an alkene, proceeding via a carbocation intermediate), and nucleophilic addition (a nucleophile attacks a polar C=O bond, giving a tetrahedral product). These three reaction types — and their curly-arrow mechanisms — are the core of IB Reactivity 3.4. Frontier molecular orbital theory (HOMO–LUMO) and the SN1 mechanism go beyond the IB specification and are extension material only. Comparing heterolytic vs. homolytic fission clarifies why electron-pair sharing reactions differ fundamentally from free-radical processes. Mastering curly-arrow notation is essential for success in IB Chemistry and beyond.