01 / 21

Support Ecosystem Cycling
With Evidence

Learn to identify, trace, and support claims about nutrient and energy cycling using measurable evidence from real ecosystems.

High School Biology

What Is Ecosystem Cycling?

An ecosystem is a system of living organisms (biotic) and non-living components (abiotic) interacting through two fundamental processes: the flow of energy and the cycling of matter. Unlike energy, which flows in one direction, matter is continuously recycled.

Energy Flow
One-way: sunlight enters, heat exits. Follows the laws of thermodynamics.
Matter Cycling
Circular: atoms of C, N, P, H, and O are reused endlessly through biogeochemical cycles.

Key Terms in Biogeochemical Cycles

Reservoir
A place where a nutrient accumulates for a long time (e.g., ocean, atmosphere, rock).
Flux
The rate at which matter moves between reservoirs, often measured as mass per time.
Sink
A reservoir that absorbs more of a substance than it releases (net input > net output).

Why Does Evidence Matter?

Scientists cannot directly "see" atoms moving through an ecosystem. Instead, they rely on indirect evidence: gas measurements, water chemistry, soil samples, and isotopic tracers. Strong claims about cycling must be supported by multiple lines of evidence.

1
Quantitative data: concentrations of \( \text{CO}_2 \), \( \text{NO}_3^- \), or \( \text{PO}_4^{3-} \) in water or air.
2
Rate measurements: photosynthesis rate, decomposition rate, nitrogen fixation rate.
3
Isotope tracers: \( ^{13}\text{C} \) or \( ^{15}\text{N} \) track where atoms actually go.

The Carbon Cycle: Core Diagram

Atmosphere
\( \text{CO}_2 \) reservoir
Producers Consumers Decomposers Fossil Fuels Soil / Sediment Photosynthesis Respiration Feeding Death Decay Combustion

The Nitrogen Cycle: Key Processes

Atmosphere \( \text{N}_2 \)
N-Fixing Bacteria
\( \text{NH}_4^+ \) (Ammonium)
\( \text{NO}_3^- \) (Nitrate)
Plants Denitrifying Bacteria Fixation Nitrification Assimilation Denitrification

Energy Flow vs. Matter Cycling

Energy Flow Matter Cycling
Direction One-way (sunlight → heat) Circular (atoms are reused)
Conservation Decreases at each trophic level (~10% rule) Total mass is conserved
Source Sun Existing atoms in the biosphere
Key Evidence Biomass pyramids, calorimetry Isotope tracers, nutrient budgets
Equation \( E_{\text{out}} = E_{\text{in}} - E_{\text{lost as heat}} \) \( \text{Mass}_{\text{in}} = \text{Mass}_{\text{out}} \) (steady state)

What Counts as Evidence?

1
Direct measurements: \( \text{CO}_2 \) concentration in ppm, dissolved \( \text{O}_2 \) in water, soil nitrogen in mg/kg.
2
Rate data: Photosynthesis rate in \( \mu\text{mol}\ \text{CO}_2 / \text{m}^2 / \text{s} \), decomposition rates measured by mass loss over time.
3
Controlled experiments: Removing a species or adding a nutrient, then measuring how cycling changes.
4
Long-term monitoring: Keeling Curve (\( \text{CO}_2 \) at Mauna Loa), ice core data, sediment cores.
5
Isotope analysis: \( ^{13}\text{C}/^{12}\text{C} \) ratios reveal whether carbon came from biological or geological sources.

How to Build an Evidence-Based Argument

1
State the claim: Identify what process or pattern you are explaining (e.g., "Decomposers return carbon to the atmosphere").
2
Identify relevant data: Select measurable evidence that directly relates to the claim (e.g., \( \text{CO}_2 \) flux from soil).
3
Connect data to cycling process: Explain the mechanism: how does the data show matter moving from one reservoir to another?
4
Apply a scientific principle: Link to conservation of matter, energy transfer laws, or known biogeochemical pathways.
5
Evaluate limitations: Note any gaps, confounding variables, or alternative explanations for the data.

Example 1: Forest Carbon Budget

Scenario: A temperate forest absorbs 12 metric tons of \( \text{CO}_2 \) per hectare per year via photosynthesis. Respiration by plants and soil organisms releases 10 metric tons per hectare per year.

Forest Ecosystem 12 t/ha/yr Photosynthesis 10 t/ha/yr Respiration
Net: +2 t \( \text{CO}_2 \)/ha/yr (carbon sink)

Example 2: Aquatic Phosphorus Loading

Scenario: A lake receives agricultural runoff containing phosphate (\( \text{PO}_4^{3-} \)). Researchers measure phosphorus concentration upstream and downstream over 6 months.

[P] (mg/L) Months 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 1 2 3 4 5 Upstream Downstream

Example 3: Isotope Tracing in a Food Web

Scenario: Scientists feed algae labeled with \( ^{15}\text{N} \) to zooplankton in a controlled pond, then measure \( ^{15}\text{N} \) in fish tissue over 30 days.

Algae
\( ^{15}\text{N} \) labeled
Zooplankton
\( ^{15}\text{N} \) detected Day 5
Fish
\( ^{15}\text{N} \) detected Day 15
Days 0-5 Days 5-15 Days 15-30

The Water Cycle Drives Nutrient Transport

Water is the universal solvent that physically carries dissolved nutrients (\( \text{NO}_3^- \), \( \text{PO}_4^{3-} \), \( \text{Ca}^{2+} \)) between reservoirs. Without the water cycle, biogeochemical cycles would stall.

Precipitation
Delivers water and dissolved atmospheric gases (\( \text{CO}_2 \), \( \text{N}_2\text{O} \)) to soil and water bodies.
Runoff
Transports eroded nutrients from land to streams, rivers, and oceans.
Evapotranspiration
Moves water (but not solutes) back to the atmosphere, concentrating nutrients in soil.

Case Study: Hubbard Brook Experiment

In the 1960s, researchers at Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest clear-cut one watershed while leaving an adjacent one intact, then measured stream water chemistry for years.

Control Watershed
Nutrient concentrations in stream water stayed low and stable. Vegetation absorbed nutrients before they reached the stream.
Deforested Watershed
\( \text{NO}_3^- \) in stream water increased by 60x. Without plant uptake, nutrients washed directly into waterways.

Common Mistakes in Evidence-Based Reasoning

✕ Confusing Correlation with Mechanism
Saying "\( \text{CO}_2 \) rises because temperature rises" without explaining the biological or chemical process connecting them.
✕ Ignoring Scale
Applying data from a single tree to an entire ecosystem without acknowledging the scale difference or sampling limitations.
✕ Forgetting Abiotic Factors
Explaining nutrient cycling only through organisms and ignoring weathering, volcanic activity, or ocean chemistry.

Comparing the Major Cycles

Carbon Nitrogen Phosphorus Water
Main Reservoir Atmosphere, oceans Atmosphere (\( \text{N}_2 \)) Rock, sediment Oceans
Key Process Photosynthesis / Respiration Fixation / Denitrification Weathering / Uptake Evaporation / Precipitation
Gaseous Phase? Yes (\( \text{CO}_2 \)) Yes (\( \text{N}_2 \)) No Yes (\( \text{H}_2\text{O} \))
Human Impact Fossil fuel combustion Fertilizer use Mining, agriculture Damming, irrigation
Best Evidence Keeling Curve data \( ^{15}\text{N} \) tracers Stream \( \text{PO}_4^{3-} \) data Satellite imagery

Question 1 of 5

A forest ecosystem absorbs 15 metric tons of \( \text{CO}_2 \) per hectare per year and releases 15 metric tons through respiration. What is this forest with respect to carbon?

Question 2 of 5

In the Hubbard Brook experiment, \( \text{NO}_3^- \) levels in stream water increased 60 times after deforestation. Which statement best explains this evidence?

Question 3 of 5

A scientist measures \( ^{15}\text{N} \) in fish tissue 15 days after feeding labeled algae to zooplankton. What does this evidence most directly support?

Question 4 of 5

Unlike carbon and nitrogen, the phosphorus cycle lacks a significant gaseous phase. What is the primary evidence for this claim?

Question 5 of 5

A student claims: "Decomposers are not important for ecosystem cycling because they just break things down." Which evidence best refutes this claim?