01 / 21

Variation &
Selection Pressure

Explore how genetic variation within populations interacts with environmental pressures to drive the process of natural selection.

AP Biology

What Is Genetic Variation?

Genetic variation refers to the differences in DNA sequences among individuals in a population. These differences arise through mutations, sexual reproduction (crossing over and independent assortment), and gene flow between populations.

Beetle Population with Variation Green variant Purple variant Yellow variant Different alleles produce different body colors

Sources of Variation

Mutation
Random changes in DNA sequence that create new alleles. The ultimate source of all genetic variation.
Sexual Reproduction
Crossing over and independent assortment during meiosis shuffle existing alleles into new combinations.
Gene Flow
Migration of individuals between populations introduces new alleles into a gene pool.

What Is Selection Pressure?

A selection pressure is any environmental factor that affects an organism's ability to survive and reproduce. Selection pressures determine which traits are advantageous, neutral, or harmful in a given environment.

Predation
Organisms that avoid predators survive longer and leave more offspring.
Resource Scarcity
Limited food, water, or territory favors traits that improve resource acquisition.
Disease
Pathogens select for immune system variants that confer resistance.
Climate Change
Shifts in temperature or rainfall favor traits suited to the new conditions.

The Core Principle of Natural Selection

Genetic Variation Selection Pressure Differential Survival Allele Frequency Shifts Over Time = Evolution by Natural Selection +

Fitness and Allele Frequency

In evolutionary biology, fitness is the relative ability of an organism to survive and pass on its genes. If a trait increases fitness under a given selection pressure, the allele(s) encoding that trait become more common over generations.

Generations Allele Frequency 0 0.5 1.0
Allele \(A\) (advantageous)
Allele \(a\) (disadvantageous)

Types of Selection

Directional
One extreme phenotype is favored. The population's trait distribution shifts toward that extreme.
Stabilizing
Intermediate phenotypes are favored. Extremes are selected against, narrowing the distribution.
Disruptive
Both extremes are favored over intermediates. The distribution splits into two peaks.
Directional Stabilizing Disruptive

Why Variation Matters for Selection

1
No variation = no selection. If every individual is genetically identical, a selection pressure cannot favor one over another.
2
More variation = more potential. A wider range of alleles means a population is more likely to contain traits suited to new pressures.
3
Selection pressure acts as a filter. It does not create new traits; it increases the frequency of traits that already exist in the population.
4
Environment determines value. A trait that is beneficial in one environment may be neutral or harmful in another.

How to Analyze Selection Scenarios

1
Identify the variation. What heritable trait differences exist in the population?
2
Identify the selection pressure. What environmental factor is affecting survival or reproduction?
3
Determine differential fitness. Which variant(s) have higher survival or reproductive success?
4
Predict the allele frequency shift. Over generations, the advantageous allele should increase in frequency.
5
Name the type of selection. Is it directional, stabilizing, or disruptive?

Example: Peppered Moths

Before Industry Light-colored bark Light moths: camouflaged ✓ Dark moths: visible to predators After Industry Soot-darkened bark Dark moths: camouflaged ✓ Light moths: visible to predators Pollution Directional selection: dark allele frequency increased

Example: Antibiotic Resistance

Before Antibiotic Mostly susceptible (blue) 1 resistant mutant (red) Antibiotic Applied After Antibiotic Susceptible: killed Resistant: survives Reproduce Next Generation All resistant Variation: resistance allele existed before the antibiotic The antibiotic did not create resistance: it selected for it

Example: Human Birth Weight

Human birth weight is a classic example of stabilizing selection. Babies that are too small or too large face higher mortality. The intermediate weight has the highest survival rate.

Birth Weight (kg) Survival Rate 2.0 2.7 3.4 4.1 4.8 Too small Too large Optimal range ✓

Example: Finch Beak Size

On some islands, seeds are either very small (soft seeds) or very large (hard seeds), with few medium seeds. Finches with small beaks eat small seeds efficiently, while those with large beaks crack hard seeds. Medium beaks do neither well.

Beak Size Small Medium Large Favored ✓ Favored ✓ Selected against

Adaptation Is Not Intentional

A critical misconception is that organisms "try" to adapt or that the environment "causes" helpful mutations. In reality, mutations occur randomly. The environment simply determines which existing variants have higher fitness.

✕
Incorrect: "Bacteria developed resistance because they were exposed to antibiotics."
✓
Correct: "Some bacteria already had a resistance allele. The antibiotic killed susceptible bacteria, leaving resistant ones to reproduce."

Common Mistakes

✕ Lamarckian Thinking
Saying organisms "develop" traits in response to need. Giraffes did not stretch their necks; those with longer necks already had higher fitness.
✕ Ignoring Variation
Forgetting that selection requires pre-existing differences. Without variation, no selection can occur regardless of pressure.
✕ Individual vs Population
Saying "the organism evolved." Individuals do not evolve; populations evolve as allele frequencies shift over generations.

Comparing Selection Types

Feature Directional Stabilizing Disruptive
Favored Phenotype One extreme Intermediate Both extremes
Distribution Shift Moves left or right Narrows (taller peak) Splits into two peaks
Variation Effect Decreases (one end lost) Decreases (extremes lost) May increase (two groups)
Classic Example Peppered moths Human birth weight Finch beak sizes
May Lead To Adaptation to change Trait maintenance Speciation

Question 1 of 5

A population of rabbits shows variation in fur thickness. After several harsh winters, the population shifts toward thicker fur. What type of selection is occurring?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best explains why genetic variation is essential for natural selection to occur?

Question 3 of 5

A student says: "Bacteria evolved antibiotic resistance because they were exposed to the drug." What is wrong with this reasoning?

Question 4 of 5

In a forest ecosystem, medium-sized seeds are abundant while very small and very large seeds are rare. Which type of selection would this food source exert on a seed-eating bird population with variation in beak size?

Question 5 of 5

A population of lizards lives on an island where a new predatory bird species arrives. The lizards vary in running speed. After 20 generations, the average running speed of the population has increased. Which correctly identifies the selection pressure and the variation acted upon?