01 / 21

Evaluate Evidence for
Population Change

Learn to analyze data, fossils, and genetic evidence that reveal how populations shift in allele frequency over generations.

Biology

What Is a Population?

A population is a group of organisms of the same species living in the same area at the same time. Populations are the smallest unit that can evolve: individual organisms grow and develop, but only populations change in allele frequency over generations.

HABITAT BOUNDARY Same species, same area, same time = Population

Allele Frequency: The Currency of Evolution

An allele frequency is the proportion of a specific allele among all copies of that gene in a population. If a population of 100 beetles has 60 copies of allele \(A\) and 40 copies of allele \(a\), then:

When allele frequencies change over time, evolution is occurring. Evidence for this change can come from direct observation, the fossil record, DNA analysis, or comparative anatomy.

Types of Evidence for Population Change

★ Fossil Record
Preserved remains show how traits in populations shifted across geologic time.
★ DNA & Molecular Data
Comparing gene sequences reveals how closely related populations diverged.
★ Direct Observation
Measurable changes in allele frequency within a few generations (e.g., antibiotic resistance).
★ Comparative Anatomy
Homologous and vestigial structures reveal shared ancestry and divergence.

The Hardy-Weinberg Null Model

To detect population change, scientists compare real data to a null model where no evolution occurs. The Hardy-Weinberg principle states that allele frequencies stay constant when five conditions are met:

If observed genotype frequencies deviate from Hardy-Weinberg predictions, at least one of the five conditions is being violated: the population is evolving.

Five Conditions for No Evolution

1
No mutation: No new alleles are created or changed.
2
Random mating: Individuals pair without preference for genotype.
3
No natural selection: All genotypes have equal fitness.
4
Infinite population size: No genetic drift (random fluctuations).
5
No gene flow: No migration of alleles into or out of the population.

Microevolution vs. Macroevolution

Microevolution Macroevolution
Scale Within a single population Across species or higher taxa
Timeframe Generations to centuries Thousands to millions of years
What changes Allele frequencies Body plans, new species
Evidence Allele surveys, field data Fossil record, phylogenetics
Example Pesticide resistance in insects Evolution of whales from land mammals

How to Evaluate Evidence

1
Identify the population and the trait or allele being tracked.
2
Determine the type of evidence: fossil, molecular, observational, or anatomical.
3
Compare data across time points. Has allele frequency, trait distribution, or morphology shifted?
4
Test against the null model. Use Hardy-Weinberg to check if the change is statistically significant.
5
Identify the mechanism: natural selection, genetic drift, gene flow, or mutation?

Example 1: Peppered Moths

0% 25% 50% 75% 100% 1850 1900 1950 1975 2000 Dark Moth Freq. Industrial Rev. Clean Air Acts Dark morph frequency

Example 2: Sickle Cell Allele

The sickle cell allele (\(\text{HbS}\)) causes a harmful blood disorder in homozygotes (\(\text{HbS}/\text{HbS}\)). Yet it persists at high frequency in malaria-endemic regions. Why?

\(\text{HbS}/\text{HbS}\)
Sickle cell disease: reduced fitness. Severe anemia and organ damage.
\(\text{HbA}/\text{HbS}\)
Sickle cell trait: highest fitness. Resistance to malaria without severe disease.
\(\text{HbA}/\text{HbA}\)
Normal hemoglobin: vulnerable to malaria in endemic regions.

Example 3: Testing Hardy-Weinberg

In a population of 500 flowers, 320 are red (\(RR\)), 160 are pink (\(Rr\)), and 20 are white (\(rr\)). Is this population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?

1
Find \(q^2\): \( q^2 = \frac{20}{500} = 0.04 \), so \( q = 0.2 \)
2
Find \(p\): \( p = 1 - q = 1 - 0.2 = 0.8 \)
3
Predict genotype frequencies: \( p^2 = 0.64 \), \( 2pq = 0.32 \), \( q^2 = 0.04 \)
4
Expected counts: \( 0.64 \times 500 = 320 \) \(RR\), \( 0.32 \times 500 = 160 \) \(Rr\), \( 0.04 \times 500 = 20 \) \(rr\)

Example 4: Detecting a Deviation

In 200 lizards: 50 are \(AA\), 40 are \(Aa\), and 110 are \(aa\). Test for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.

1
Count alleles to find \(p\) and \(q\):
Total alleles = \(2 \times 200 = 400\).
Allele A: \((2 \times 50) + 40 = 140\). So, \( p = \frac{140}{400} = 0.35 \).
Allele a: \((2 \times 110) + 40 = 260\). So, \( q = \frac{260}{400} = 0.65 \).
2
Calculate expected counts:
Expected \(AA\) (\(p^2 \times N\)): \(0.35^2 \times 200 = 24.5\).
Expected \(Aa\) (\(2pq \times N\)): \(2 \times 0.35 \times 0.65 \times 200 = 91\).
Expected \(aa\) (\(q^2 \times N\)): \(0.65^2 \times 200 = 84.5\).
3
Compare: Observed \(AA\) = 50 vs. Expected = 24.5. Observed \(Aa\) = 40 vs. Expected = 91. Huge mismatch!

Fossil Record: Time Capsules of Change

Oldest Older Recent Newest TIME S S M M L L XL S = Simple → XL = Complex (increasing body size over time)

Molecular Evidence: DNA Tells the Story

Species A Species B Species C Species D Common Ancestor Fewer DNA differences = more closely related 2% diff 5% diff

Common Mistakes

✕ Individuals Evolve
Individuals do not evolve. Populations evolve through changes in allele frequency over generations.
✕ Confusing Adaptation with Acclimation
Acclimation is a reversible individual response (e.g., tanning). Adaptation is a heritable population-level change.
✕ Assuming HW = No Change Ever
Hardy-Weinberg describes a single locus. A population can be in HW for one gene but evolving at another.

Evidence at a Glance

Evidence Type What It Shows Timescale
Fossil Record Morphological change over strata Millions of years
DNA / Molecular Sequence divergence, phylogenies Thousands to millions
Direct Observation Measurable allele frequency shifts Generations to decades
Comparative Anatomy Homologous/vestigial structures Millions of years
Biogeography Distribution patterns match ancestry Millions of years

Question 1 of 5

A biologist observes that the frequency of a dark fur allele in a mouse population changed from 0.3 to 0.6 over 10 generations. What does this demonstrate?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following is NOT a condition required for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?

Question 3 of 5

In a population of 1,000 individuals, 90 show the recessive phenotype. What is the frequency of the dominant allele (\( p \))?

Question 4 of 5

Researchers find that two island populations of the same bird species have very different beak sizes. DNA analysis shows few genetic differences overall. What best explains this?

Question 5 of 5

Which conclusion is best supported by this evidence?