01 / 21

Ecosystem Change
and Recovery

Analyze evidence related to ecosystem disturbance, succession, and resilience to understand how biological communities respond to and recover from change.

AP Environmental Science

What Is an Ecosystem?

An ecosystem is a community of living organisms (biotic factors) interacting with their non-living environment (abiotic factors) as an integrated system. Energy flows and nutrients cycle through these interactions, maintaining a dynamic equilibrium.

Biotic Factors
Plants, animals, fungi, bacteria: all living components that interact through food webs and symbiosis
Abiotic Factors
Temperature, water, sunlight, soil, minerals: non-living conditions that shape habitat suitability

Types of Ecosystem Change

Ecosystem change occurs when the structure, composition, or function of an ecosystem is significantly altered. Changes can be natural or anthropogenic (human-caused), and they vary in scale, speed, and severity.

Natural Disturbances
Wildfires, volcanic eruptions, hurricanes, drought, flooding, disease outbreaks
Anthropogenic Disturbances
Deforestation, pollution, urbanization, invasive species introduction, climate change
Gradual Shifts
Climate trends, soil erosion, nutrient depletion, species migration over decades

Ecological Succession

Ecological succession is the predictable, sequential process by which a community of organisms colonizes and transforms an area over time after a disturbance. It is the primary mechanism of ecosystem recovery.

Time Pioneer Stage Pioneer species begin to establish Herbaceous Grasses, ferns, small herbs arrive Shrub Stage Bushes, shrubs shade out pioneers Climax Community Mature forest: stable, diverse Early Stage Intermediate Late Intermediate Climax Ecological Succession Over Time Biodiversity and complexity increase →

Primary vs Secondary Succession

The two main types of succession differ based on the starting conditions after a disturbance. Understanding this distinction is critical for predicting recovery timelines.

Primary Succession Secondary Succession
Starting Point Bare, lifeless substrate (no soil) Existing soil and seed bank remain
Trigger Volcanic eruption, glacial retreat Wildfire, hurricane, logging
Pioneer Species Lichens, mosses break down rock Grasses, herbs, fast-growing plants
Timeline Centuries to millennia Decades to centuries
Soil Formation Must be created from scratch Already present: recovery is faster

Resilience and Resistance

Two key properties determine how ecosystems respond to disturbance. They work together but describe different aspects of ecosystem stability.

Resilience
The ability of an ecosystem to recover and return to its original state after a disturbance. High resilience means faster, more complete recovery.
Resistance
The ability of an ecosystem to withstand a disturbance without significant change. High resistance means less initial damage.

Biodiversity Drives Stability

Research consistently shows that higher biodiversity is correlated with greater ecosystem resilience and resistance. This is one of the most important principles in ecology.

Species Richness (Biodiversity) Ecosystem Stability Threshold Low diversity = fragile ecosystem High diversity = robust ecosystem

Disturbance vs Stress

These terms are often confused but describe fundamentally different ecological processes. Distinguishing them helps you analyze evidence about ecosystem change more precisely.

Disturbance
A discrete, relatively sudden event that disrupts ecosystem structure. It removes biomass, kills organisms, or physically alters habitat. Examples: wildfire, tornado, flood, volcanic eruption.
Stress
A chronic, ongoing condition that reduces ecosystem productivity or health without sudden destruction. Examples: drought, nutrient depletion, chronic pollution, rising temperatures.

How to Analyze Evidence

When presented with data about ecosystem change, follow this systematic approach to build a strong, evidence-based analysis.

1
Identify the disturbance. Determine whether it is natural or anthropogenic, acute (disturbance) or chronic (stress).
2
Assess the damage. What biotic and abiotic factors were affected? Was soil destroyed? Were seed banks preserved?
3
Predict the succession type. If soil remains, expect secondary succession. If substrate is bare, expect primary succession.
4
Evaluate biodiversity data. Track species richness and diversity indices over time. Are pioneer species appearing? Are later-stage species returning?
5
Determine recovery trajectory. Is the ecosystem recovering toward its original state, or shifting to a new stable state (regime shift)?

Example: Yellowstone After Fire

In 1988, massive wildfires burned approximately 793,000 acres (36%) of Yellowstone National Park. Scientists have tracked the recovery for over 30 years.

Years After Fire (1988-2020) Species Diversity Index 0 5 10 20 30 Fire Pre-fire Rapid early colonization Approaching pre-fire levels

Example: Mount St. Helens

The 1980 eruption of Mount St. Helens obliterated 230 square miles (147,200 acres) of forest, burying everything under volcanic ash and pyroclastic flows. No soil or life remained in the blast zone.

1
Type: Primary succession: the blast zone was stripped to bare rock and ash with no surviving soil or organisms.
2
Pioneer species: Lupines (nitrogen-fixing plants) were among the first colonizers, building soil from volcanic ash over decades.
3
40+ years later: Over 100 plant species and dozens of animal species have returned. However, the ecosystem is still far from its pre-eruption state.
4
Key evidence: Recovery is much slower than Yellowstone because soil must be created from scratch: the defining difference of primary succession.

Example: Coral Reef Bleaching

Coral bleaching events illustrate the interaction between acute disturbance and chronic stress, making them one of the most complex cases of ecosystem change to analyze.

Healthy Reef High biodiversity Symbiotic algae intact Bleached Reef Algae expelled White skeleton visible Heat stress Recovery Path Temps normalize Algae recolonize Regime Shift Prolonged stress Algae-dominated Outcome depends on duration and severity of stress Repeated bleaching events reduce resilience over time

Trophic Cascades and Recovery

Changes at one trophic level can cascade through the entire food web, dramatically altering ecosystem structure. Understanding these cascades is essential for predicting ecosystem recovery.

Apex Predators Wolves, sharks, eagles Herbivores Deer, elk, rabbits Producers Trees, grasses, algae Remove predators Herbivores increase Vegetation declines Yellowstone: Wolf reintroduction reversed overgrazing cascade

Indicators of Recovery

Scientists use multiple lines of evidence to determine whether an ecosystem is recovering. Look for these measurable indicators when analyzing data.

Species Richness
Number of different species present increases over time toward pre-disturbance levels
Trophic Structure
Return of multiple trophic levels: producers, herbivores, predators, decomposers
Nutrient Cycling
Restored decomposition, nitrogen fixation, and carbon cycling rates
Biomass Accumulation
Total living mass in the ecosystem increases, indicating energy capture and growth

Common Mistakes

Confusing Primary and Secondary
Primary succession starts on bare substrate (no soil). If soil remains after a disturbance, it is secondary succession, even if the area looks completely destroyed.
Assuming All Recovery Is Linear
Recovery can stall, reverse, or shift to a new stable state. A regime shift is not a failure of succession: it is a different outcome driven by changed conditions.
Ignoring Abiotic Factors
Students often focus only on species data. Soil quality, water availability, and temperature are equally critical evidence for assessing recovery potential.

Summary Comparison

Concept Definition Key Evidence
Primary Succession Colonization of bare substrate No prior soil; lichens/mosses first
Secondary Succession Recovery where soil persists Seed bank present; faster regrowth
Resilience Ability to recover after disturbance Speed and completeness of return
Resistance Ability to withstand disturbance Minimal change during the event
Regime Shift Permanent shift to new stable state Ecosystem does not return to original
Trophic Cascade Change at one level affects all others Predator removal causes overgrazing

Question 1 of 5

A volcanic eruption covers an island in lava, destroying all soil and organisms. Over time, lichens colonize the hardened lava, slowly breaking it down. What type of ecological process is occurring?

Question 2 of 5

After a wildfire burns through a temperate forest, grasses and wildflowers appear within one year, followed by shrubs and small trees within five years. Which piece of evidence best supports classifying this as secondary succession?

Question 3 of 5

A coral reef experiences repeated bleaching events over 15 years. Instead of recovering to a coral-dominated state, it becomes permanently dominated by algae. This outcome is best described as:

Question 4 of 5

When wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park, elk populations decreased, which allowed willow and aspen trees to regrow along riverbanks. This chain of effects is an example of:

Question 5 of 5

An ecologist studying a recovering forest finds that species richness has increased, but the community is dominated by a single fast-growing tree species with few other canopy trees. Which conclusion is best supported by this evidence?