Weaken
Arguments
Learn to logically attack the link between evidence and conclusion — the most tested skill in GMAT Critical Reasoning.
Anatomy of an Argument
Every argument moves from premises (the evidence) to a conclusion (the claim). Connecting them is an unstated assumption — a hidden bridge the author takes for granted.
What Does Weaken Mean?
To weaken an argument is to make its conclusion less likely to be true — not impossible, just less believable. You attack the reasoning, never the facts of the premises.
Find the Logical Gap
Premises rarely prove a conclusion outright. There is almost always a gap — a leap of logic. The weakener's job is to widen that gap.
The Core Principle
Weaken vs. Disprove
A common trap: students hunt for the choice that completely destroys the argument. But weaken questions never require certainty — only a dent.
| Weaken | Disprove | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Lower likelihood | Prove false |
| Strength | Any negative effect | 100% conclusive |
| On the GMAT | Required | Not required |
| Test phrase | "most weakens" | rare |
A 4-Step Method
Ways to Attack
Worked Example 1
Conclusion: the logo caused the sales increase. Assumption: nothing else caused the rise.
Example 1: Alternate Cause
Worked Example 2
Conclusion: the course improves safety. Assumption: the two groups were otherwise comparable.
Worked Example 3
Conclusion: libraries fail to raise literacy. Assumption: the two cities are comparable apart from libraries.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Argument Type | Best Weakener |
|---|---|
| Causal (X causes Y) | Alternate cause, or Y without X |
| Survey / Statistics | Show the sample is unrepresentative |
| Plan / Recommendation | Show the plan has a flaw or side effect |
| Analogy | Show the two cases differ in a key way |
| Prediction | Show a factor that changes the future |
Question 1 of 5
A company installed motion-sensor lights in its parking garage last year. Since then, reported thefts in the garage have dropped by 50%. The facilities manager concludes that the motion-sensor lights are responsible for the decline in thefts.
Which option, if true, most weakens the manager's conclusion?
Question 2 of 5
A nutrition blog states: "Our readers who drink green tea daily report fewer colds than those who don't. Therefore, green tea boosts the immune system and prevents colds."
Which choice most weakens this argument?
Question 3 of 5
A city council member argues: "After we raised the minimum wage, the unemployment rate in our city fell. Clearly, raising the minimum wage created jobs."
Which option most undermines the council member's reasoning?
Question 4 of 5
An online survey of 500 users of a fitness app found that 90% felt healthier after one month. The app maker concludes that its program improves the health of typical adults.
Which choice most weakens the conclusion about typical adults?
Question 5 of 5
A manager argues: "Our competitor cut its customer-service staff and profits rose. Therefore, if we cut our customer-service staff, our profits will also rise."
Which choice most weakens this analogy-based prediction?