01 / 21

Identify Method
of Reasoning

Learn to describe how an argument is built, not just what it claims, including the tricky boldface question type.

GMAT Verbal Reasoning

What Is Method of Reasoning?

A Method of Reasoning question asks you to describe how an argument makes its case, not whether it is true. You analyze the structure of the argument: what role each statement plays and how they fit together.

Anatomy of an Argument

Premise 1 Supporting evidence Premise 2 Supporting evidence Intermediate Conclusion Supports the main point Main Conclusion The final claim

Why This Skill Matters

Structure Focus
You answer based on how ideas connect, not on outside facts.
No Truth Test
The answer never depends on whether a claim is actually correct.
Boldface Bonus
Mastering roles unlocks the hardest GMAT boldface questions.

The Core Rule

Each answer choice is a generic description of an argument move. Match the description to the passage's structure word-for-word. The match must be exact, like a key in a lock.

Common Reasoning Methods

Analogy
Draws a comparison between two similar cases to support a claim.
Counterexample
Offers a case that contradicts a general claim to weaken it.
Eliminating Alternatives
Rules out other explanations to support one conclusion.
Cause and Effect
Argues that one event produces another.
Generalization
Uses specific cases to support a broad conclusion.

The Boldface Variant

In boldface questions, two portions of the passage are printed in bold. Your job is to describe the role each bold portion plays in the argument's structure.

Boldface Portion 1 e.g. evidence the author opposes Boldface Portion 2 e.g. the author's main conclusion

Method vs. Other Questions

Method of Reasoning Strengthen / Weaken
GoalDescribe the structureChange the argument
Outside factsNever neededOften introduced
Right answerReports a moveAdds new info
FocusHow it arguesWhether it holds up

A 4-Step Approach

1
Find the main conclusion. Identify the single claim everything else supports.
2
Label each part's role. Premise? Evidence? Counterpoint? Intermediate conclusion?
3
Predict the structure in your own words before reading the choices.
4
Match exactly. Eliminate any choice whose verbs misdescribe what the passage does.

Worked Example 1

Structure: The argument cites a common belief, then presents study evidence against it, and finally draws a conclusion that rejects the belief in a narrowed form.

Example 1 Answer

This description matches each move: the common belief, the evidence, and the narrowed conclusion. A choice saying it "proves the belief is entirely false" would be too strong and wrong.

Worked Example 2: Boldface

Bold 1 = a prediction the author argues against. Bold 2 = the author's main conclusion.

Example 2 Answer

Note the relationship: Bold 1 is opposed, Bold 2 is the conclusion. Watch for trap answers calling Bold 1 "evidence the author endorses" — the author actually rejects it.

Worked Example 3

Structure: This uses reasoning by analogy — it argues that because two cases are alike in relevant respects, what worked for one will work for the other.

Common Mistakes

✕ Judging Truth
Picking an answer because the argument seems right or wrong, instead of describing it.
✕ Wrong Role Labels
Calling a counterpoint "evidence the author supports" when it is actually opposed.
✕ Too Strong Verbs
Choosing "proves" or "disproves" when the passage only "suggests."

Boldface Role Cheat Sheet

Signal Phrase Likely Role
"Some argue / critics claim"Opposed position
"However / but / yet"Turning point to author's view
"Therefore / thus / so"Conclusion
"Because / since / for"Premise / support

Question 1 of 5

A method-of-reasoning question primarily asks you to identify:

Question 2 of 5

What role does the first boldface portion play?

Question 3 of 5

The argument's method of reasoning is best described as:

Question 4 of 5

A choice describing the argument as "proves conclusively that the policy will fail" is suspect when the passage only said the policy "may have drawbacks." This is an example of:

Question 5 of 5

Which describes the roles of the two boldface portions?