Identify Logical Flaws
in Arguments
Learn to spot the broken link between an argument's evidence and its conclusion — the core skill of GMAT Critical Reasoning.
The Anatomy of an Argument
Every argument has three parts. The author offers evidence (premises), relies on an unstated assumption, and reaches a conclusion. A logical flaw is a defect in how these parts connect.
What Is a Logical Flaw?
A logical flaw is a reasoning error that makes the conclusion unjustified — even if every stated fact is true. The premises may be perfectly accurate, but the leap to the conclusion is invalid.
Why This Skill Matters
The Core Rule
Common Flaw Types
Flaw vs. Weakener
Students often confuse these. Both questions probe a weak argument, but they ask for different things.
| Find the Flaw | Weaken | |
|---|---|---|
| Asks for | The error in the logic itself | New fact that hurts it |
| Source | Inside the argument | Outside information |
| Answer style | Describes the reasoning | States a new claim |
A Four-Step Method
Worked Example One
Step 3 — find the gap: The author treats correlation as causation. More injuries could simply mean more people cycling, not greater danger per rider.
Worked Example Two
Step 3 — find the gap: The sample is not representative. Readers of a fitness magazine are far more likely to exercise than the general population.
Worked Example Three
Step 3 — find the gap: The percentages compare different-sized groups. If there are far fewer drivers over 70 on the road, their crash rate per driver may still be lower.
Common Mistakes
Flaw Cheat Sheet
| Flaw Type | Tell-Tale Sign |
|---|---|
| Causation/Correlation | "A and B happen together, so A causes B" |
| Unrepresentative Sample | Conclusion about a group from a biased subset |
| Faulty Analogy | Two unlike situations treated as identical |
| Equivocation | A key word's meaning shifts mid-argument |
| Percent vs. Number | Shares confused with actual quantities |
Question 1 of 5
Argument: "Since the city installed brighter streetlights, nighttime crime in the downtown area has dropped by 30%. Clearly, brighter lighting deters criminals."
Which best describes the flaw in this argument?
Question 2 of 5
Argument: "We polled visitors leaving the new luxury car dealership. 90% said they plan to buy a new car this year. Therefore, the national car market is booming."
The reasoning is most vulnerable because it:
Question 3 of 5
Argument: "Last quarter, 15% of complaints to our company were about shipping. This quarter, only 9% were about shipping. Our shipping has clearly improved."
What must the argument overlook to be flawed?
Question 4 of 5
Argument: "Our rival's factory boosted output by switching to night shifts. We should switch to night shifts too — it will boost our output just as much."
The argument is flawed because it:
Question 5 of 5
Speaker: "All laws are designed to protect people. This new tax law is, in fact, a law. Therefore, this tax law protects people, so no one should oppose it."
Beyond the questionable premise, the conclusion's biggest leap is that it:
Putting It Together
You Can Now Spot the Flaw
Every argument is a chain. Find the weakest link, name the assumption, and you have identified the logical flaw.