Identify
Assumptions
The hidden bridge between evidence and conclusion. Learn to find the unstated ideas every argument depends on.
What Is an Assumption?
An assumption is an unstated idea that an argument takes for granted. The author never says it out loud, but the conclusion would collapse without it.
The Bridge Model
Two Kinds of Unstated Ideas
The Core Definition
If removing a statement makes the conclusion fall apart, that statement is an assumption the argument depends on.
The Negation Test
The most reliable tool for testing a candidate assumption: negate it and see what happens to the argument.
Assumption vs. Inference
| Assumption | Inference | |
|---|---|---|
| Position | Comes before conclusion | Comes after evidence |
| Role | Supports the argument | Follows from the argument |
| Stated? | Never | Drawn by reader |
| Question cue | "depends on" | "must be true" |
A 4-Step Approach
Worked Example One
Worked Example Two
Worked Example Three
Apply the Negation Test to the candidate: "Contractors will not require more management or training costs."
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Step | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
| Conclusion | What is being claimed? |
| Evidence | What facts are given? |
| Gap | What logic jump is made? |
| Test | If I negate it, does the argument die? |
Before You Practice
Question 1 of 5
Which best describes an assumption in an argument?
Question 2 of 5
The town installed brighter streetlights, and the number of nighttime traffic accidents dropped sharply the following year. Therefore, the brighter lights made the roads safer.
The argument depends on which assumption?
Question 3 of 5
When you use the Negation Test, a statement is a true assumption if, after negating it, the argument:
Question 4 of 5
A study found that employees who exercise regularly take fewer sick days. The company concludes that building an on-site gym will reduce its total number of employee sick days.
Which is a required assumption of the conclusion?
Question 5 of 5
A restaurant raised its prices and revenue still increased. The owner concludes that raising prices again will further increase revenue.
Which answer is a common WRONG choice because it is out of scope?