Evaluate Plans
and Strategies
Learn to identify the information that would help judge whether a proposed plan will actually achieve its goal.
What Is an Evaluate Question?
A plan or strategy is a proposed action designed to reach a stated goal. An Evaluate question asks you to find the piece of information that would best help you decide whether the plan will succeed.
Anatomy of a Plan Argument
Why It Matters
The Variance Test
A correct Evaluate answer must satisfy the variance test: its two possible answers must pull the conclusion in opposite directions.
The Two-Sided Swing
Evaluate vs. Strengthen/Weaken
A 4-Step Approach
Worked Example 1
Which question is most useful to evaluate the plan?
Worked Example 2
Best evaluating question? "Will the added sales from free shipping more than offset the shipping costs the store absorbs?"
Worked Example 3
Watch the trap. "Did the old fertilizer raise yields in past years?" looks relevant, but it tells us about the past, not the new fertilizer's effect.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Correct Answer | Wrong Answer | |
|---|---|---|
| Form | A question or factor | Restated plan or fact |
| Variance test | Swings both ways | One-sided or flat |
| Relevance | Ties to the goal | Out of scope |
| Timeframe | Tests the plan ahead | Backward-looking |
Let's Practice
You'll see five Evaluate questions. For each, find the option whose answer would best help you judge whether the plan reaches its goal. Run the variance test on every choice.
Question 1 of 5
Plan: A library plans to extend its evening hours to increase the total number of visitors per week.
Officials believe later hours will let more working adults stop by after their jobs end.
Which question would be most useful in evaluating the plan?
Question 2 of 5
Plan: A company will give employees free fitness memberships in order to reduce the number of sick days taken.
Management assumes healthier employees will miss less work.
Which question best evaluates whether the plan will work?
Question 3 of 5
Plan: A bakery will lower the price of its bread by 20% to increase its weekly revenue from bread sales.
Note: revenue equals price multiplied by quantity sold, so \( R = P \times Q \).
Which question is most relevant to evaluating the plan?
Question 4 of 5
Plan: A town will build a new bike lane to reduce car traffic on its busiest road during rush hour.
Planners expect commuters to switch from cars to bicycles.
Which question would most help evaluate the plan?
Question 5 of 5
Plan: A streaming service will add a cheaper ad-supported tier to grow its total subscriber count.
Executives believe price-sensitive viewers will sign up for the new tier.
Which question best evaluates whether total subscriptions will grow?
You've Got the Variance Test
For every Evaluate question: spot the plan and goal, find the assumption, and pick the answer whose yes/no responses swing your verdict. Run it on every choice and the trap answers fall away.