Evaluate Cross
Source Consistency
Learn to check whether two or more data sources agree, conflict, or simply describe different things before drawing conclusions.
What Is Cross Source Consistency?
On the GMAT Data Insights section, a single prompt often gives you more than one source: a table, a chart, an email, and a paragraph of text. Each source carries its own slice of information.
Cross source consistency asks: do the sources agree with one another, or does one source contradict what another claims?
Multiple Sources, One Question
Why It Matters
The Core Rule
Consistency is not the same as identical. Two sources can report different numbers and still be consistent if those numbers describe different things (different periods, units, or scopes).
Three Possible Outcomes
Different vs. Contradictory
| Merely Different | Truly Contradictory | |
|---|---|---|
| Describes | Different things | The same thing |
| Can both be true? | Yes | No |
| Example | Q1 vs Q2 revenue | Two Q1 revenue figures |
| Verdict | Consistent | Inconsistent |
A 4-Step Approach
Worked Example One
Source A (table): Total units sold in 2023 = 4,200.
Source B (email): "We sold 3,900 units in 2023, our best year yet."
Worked Example Two
Source A (chart): North region revenue = $2.1M.
Source B (memo): "Total company revenue was $5.4M."
Worked Example Three
Source A: "Profit margin rose to 12% in Q4."
Source B: Q4 revenue = $800K, Q4 profit = $72K.
Common Mistakes
Summary Checklist
| Check | Question to Ask | If Met |
|---|---|---|
| Same claim? | Do both refer to one quantity? | Proceed to compare |
| Same scope? | Same period, units, group? | Values are comparable |
| Coexist? | Can both be true at once? | Consistent |
| Conflict? | Same scope, unequal value? | Inconsistent |
Ready to Practice
You now know the core distinction: different data is not the same as contradictory data. Consistency is about whether claims can be true together, given the same scope.
Question 1 of 5
Two sources are consistent when:
Question 2 of 5
Source A: North revenue = $2M. Source B: Total company revenue = $6M. These sources are:
Question 3 of 5
Source A states Q3 profit margin was 15%. Source B gives Q3 revenue = $500K and Q3 profit = $60K. Are they consistent?
Question 4 of 5
Which step should come first when checking cross-source consistency?
Question 5 of 5
Source A: 2022 units = 4,000. Source B: "Our 2022 sales reached 4,500 units." This is best described as:
You've Got Consistency
Remember: same claim, same scope, can they coexist? Master those three questions and cross-source problems become routine.