01 / 20

Combined vs.
Independent Sufficiency

Master when statements are sufficient on their own versus only when combined together in Data Sufficiency.

GMAT Data Insights

What Is Data Sufficiency?

In a Data Sufficiency question, you are given a question plus two statements. Your job is not to solve the problem, but to decide whether the statements give enough information to answer it with one definite value.

The Five Answer Choices

A
(1) alone is sufficient, but (2) alone is not.
B
(2) alone is sufficient, but (1) alone is not.
C
Together they are sufficient, but neither alone is.
D
Each alone is sufficient.
E
Together still not sufficient (more data needed).

Independent Sufficiency

A statement is independently sufficient when it answers the question by itself, without help from the other statement. This points toward choice A, B, or D.

Statement (1) answers alone ✓ ANSWERED

Combined Sufficiency

Sometimes neither statement alone is enough, but putting both together pins down a single answer. This is choice C. The information from each statement interacts to remove ambiguity.

Statement (1) Statement (2) COMBINED = answered

The Core Rule

You only combine statements after determining that neither is sufficient on its own. The decision order is fixed:

1
Test (1) alone. Is it sufficient? Yes → answer is A or D.
2
Test (2) alone. Is it sufficient? This separates A, B, and D.
3
Only if both fail alone, combine them → answer is C or E.

The Decision Tree

Is (1) alone sufficient? Yes No Is (2) also sufficient? Yes → D · No → A Is (2) alone sufficient? No (B if Yes) Combine (1)+(2) sufficient? Yes → C · No → E

Key Distinction

Independent (A / B / D)
A single statement, on its own, narrows the answer to one value. The other statement is unnecessary for that part.
Combined (C)
Each statement alone leaves multiple possibilities, but together they overlap to leave exactly one answer.
Neither (E)
Even both statements together still allow more than one answer. The data is genuinely incomplete.

How to Apply It

1
Rephrase the question. Know exactly what one value you need to find.
2
Cover statement (2). Test (1) alone. Can you reach one answer?
3
Cover statement (1). Test (2) alone with fresh eyes.
4
Combine only if needed. Decide between C and E.

Worked Example 1

What is the value of \( x \)?
(1) \( x + y = 10 \)
(2) \( y = 4 \)

Worked Example 2

Is \( n \) an even integer?
(1) \( n = 2k \) for some integer \( k \)
(2) \( n + 1 \) is odd

Worked Example 3

What is the value of integer \( z \), where \( 0 < z < 10 \)?
(1) \( z \) is a multiple of 3
(2) \( z \) is even

When Combining Still Fails

What is the value of integer \( w \), where \( w > 0 \)?
(1) \( w \) is even
(2) \( w \) is less than 10

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the alone test
Combining statements first hides the fact that one may already be sufficient, leading you to C instead of A, B, or D.
✕ Carrying over info
When testing (2) alone, you must forget (1) entirely. Leftover assumptions inflate sufficiency.
✕ Stopping too early
If combined gives a range like \( \{2,4,6,8\} \), it is not sufficient. One answer means one value only.

Summary Table

(1) alone (2) alone Together Answer
Case 1YesNo—A
Case 2NoYes—B
Case 3YesYes—D
Case 4NoNoYesC
Case 5NoNoNoE

Question 1 of 5

What is the value of \( a \)?
(1) \( a - b = 5 \)
(2) \( b = 3 \). Which answer fits?

Question 2 of 5

Is \( p \) positive?
(1) \( p^2 = 9 \)
(2) \( p > 0 \). Which answer fits?

Question 3 of 5

What is integer \( m \), where \( 0 < m < 12 \)?
(1) \( m \) is a multiple of 4
(2) \( m \) is a multiple of 6. Which answer fits?

Question 4 of 5

Is \( x \) even?
(1) \( x = 6k \) for integer \( k \)
(2) \( 2x \) is even (always true for integer \( x \)). Which answer fits?

Question 5 of 5

What is integer \( t \), \( 1 \leq t \leq 20 \)?
(1) \( t \) is prime
(2) \( t \) is even. Which answer fits?