01 / 20

Algebraic
Constraint Testing

Decide if a statement is sufficient by testing whether \( x \) can take more than one value under its constraints.

GMAT Data Insights

What Is Data Sufficiency?

In a Data Sufficiency (DS) question, you are given a question and two statements. Your job is not to answer the question, but to decide whether each statement gives enough information to answer it.

The Five DS Answer Choices

A
Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but (2) is not.
B
Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but (1) is not.
C
Both together are sufficient, but neither alone is.
D
Each alone is sufficient.
E
Together still not enough — more data needed.

What Is Constraint Testing?

Constraint testing means treating each statement as a set of restrictions on the variable, then asking: can the variable take more than one value that still satisfies everything?

1 2 3 4 one value → SUFFICIENT two values → INSUFFICIENT

The Core Rule

Symbolically, if the question asks for the value of \( x \) and a statement allows the solution set \( S \), then it is sufficient exactly when \( |S| = 1 \), that is, \( S = \{x_0\} \).

Two Question Types

Value Questions
"What is \( x \)?" Sufficient only if the constraint pins \( x \) to exactly one number.
Yes/No Questions
"Is \( x > 0 \)?" Sufficient if every allowed value gives the same yes-or-no answer — even if \( x \) itself varies.

How to Apply It

1
Identify the question type. Value or Yes/No?
2
Write the constraint algebraically. Convert the statement into an equation or inequality.
3
Test boundary cases. Try negatives, zero, fractions, and integers.
4
Seek a counterexample. Two valid values with different answers prove insufficiency.
5
Conclude. One answer always → sufficient; otherwise → insufficient.

Example 1: A Value Question

Question: What is the value of \( x \)?
Statement (1): \( x^2 = 16 \)

Test the constraint. The equation \( x^2 = 16 \) has solutions \( x = 4 \) and \( x = -4 \).

Example 1: Adding a Constraint

Statement (2): \( x > 0 \). Alone, this allows infinitely many values, so it is insufficient.

Combine (1) and (2): \( x^2 = 16 \) gives \( \{-4, 4\} \), and \( x > 0 \) eliminates \( -4 \). Only \( x = 4 \) survives.

Example 2: A Yes/No Question

Question: Is \( x > 0 \)?
Statement (1): \( x^2 > 4 \)

The constraint \( x^2 > 4 \) means \( x > 2 \) or \( x < -2 \).

Example 2: Single Definite Answer

Statement (2): \( x^3 > 0 \). Since cubes preserve sign, \( x^3 > 0 \) holds exactly when \( x > 0 \).

Every value allowed by statement (2) gives the same answer: Yes. The variable still varies, but the answer never changes.

Example 3: The Trap of "Looks Sufficient"

Question: Is the integer \( n \) even?
Statement (1): \( n^2 \) is even.

If \( n^2 \) is even, then \( n \) must be even (an odd squared is odd). Test boundaries: \( n = 2 \to n^2 = 4 \) even, \( n = -4 \to n^2=16 \) even — all such \( n \) are even.

Common Mistakes

✕ Forgetting negatives
Treating \( x^2 = 16 \) as only \( x = 4 \). Always remember \( x = -4 \) too.
✕ Solving the question
You only need to know if the answer is fixed, not to compute it.
✕ Ignoring fractions
Forgetting test values like \( x = 0.5 \) which often break sufficiency.
✕ Combining too early
Always test each statement alone before combining them.

Sufficiency Summary

Value QuestionYes/No Question
Asks forA specific numberA definite yes or no
Sufficient when\( |S| = 1 \)Same answer for all of \( S \)
Insufficient whenTwo or more valuesOne value gives Yes, another No
StrategyCount solutionsTest sign / boundary cases

Quick Recap

1
Sufficient = one definite answer for all allowed values.
2
Two valid values with different answers = insufficient.
3
Test boundaries: negatives, zero, fractions, integers.
4
Yes/No needs a single answer, not a single value.

Question 1 of 5

Question: What is the value of \( x \)? Statement: \( x^2 = 9 \). Is this statement sufficient?

Question 2 of 5

Question: Is \( x > 0 \)? Statement: \( x^3 = 27 \). Is this statement sufficient?

Question 3 of 5

Question: Is \( x > 0 \)? Statement: \( x^2 > 4 \). Is this statement sufficient?

Question 4 of 5

Question: Is the integer \( n \) odd? Statement: \( n^2 \) is odd. Is this statement sufficient?

Question 5 of 5

Question: What is \( x \)? (1) \( x^2 = 25 \). (2) \( x < 0 \). Which answer applies?