Evaluate Scientific Conclusions - GED Science
- What should scientists do when new, reliable evidence contradicts an accepted conclusion?
- Revise or replace the conclusion. Scientific knowledge changes as new evidence is gathered.
- A medicine helped 200 adults aged 20 to 30. What flaw arises if a researcher concludes that it works for children?
- Overgeneralization. Children were not studied, so the result cannot be extended to them.
- Why is anecdotal evidence weak support for a conclusion?
- It comes from personal stories or single cases, not from controlled, repeated measurements, so chance and bias are not ruled out.
- What is a scientific theory?
- A well-tested explanation of natural events supported by a large body of evidence; it is not a guess.
- What is replication in science?
- Repeating an experiment, often by other scientists, to check whether the same results occur; consistent results strengthen a conclusion.
- What is peer review?
- The evaluation of a study by other experts in the field before it is published, to check its methods and conclusions.
- Why does a larger sample size make a conclusion more trustworthy?
- It reduces the effect of chance and individual differences, so the results are more likely to represent the whole population.
- Ice cream sales and drownings both rise in summer, so a student concludes ice cream causes drowning. What is the flaw?
- It treats correlation as causation. A third factor, hot weather, increases both swimming and ice cream sales.
- When is a scientific conclusion supported by an experiment?
- When it follows directly from the data of a controlled test and does not claim more than those data show.
- A company that sells a supplement funds a study finding that the supplement works. What concern does this raise?
- Possible bias from a conflict of interest. Independent studies that replicate the result would make it more trustworthy.
- What is overgeneralization in a scientific conclusion?
- Extending a result to groups or conditions that were not tested.
- What is the difference between a scientific law and a scientific theory?
- A law describes what happens, often as an equation; a theory explains why it happens.