01 / 20

Evaluate
Arguments

Learn to break apart an argument, identify its claim and evidence, and judge whether the reasoning truly holds up.

GED Reasoning Through Language Arts

What Is an Argument?

In reading, an argument is not a fight. It is a writer's attempt to convince you of a position by stating a claim and backing it with evidence and reasoning.

The Three Building Blocks

CLAIM The main point EVIDENCE Facts, data, examples REASONING The logic link ASSUMPTION Unstated belief Together they support the writer's conclusion

Claim vs. Evidence

Claim
A statement the writer wants you to accept. It is debatable, an opinion or position, not a plain fact.
Evidence
The support, facts, statistics, expert quotes, or examples, offered to prove the claim is reasonable.

The Core Rule

If any one link breaks, the argument weakens. We can picture strength as a simple chain: \( \text{Strength} = \text{Relevance} \times \text{Sufficiency} \times \text{Logic} \). If any factor drops toward zero, the whole product collapses.

A Chain Is Only as Strong as Its Weakest Link

Relevant? Fits the claim Enough? Sufficient ✕ Logical? Sound link One broken link weakens the entire argument

Strong vs. Weak Support

Strong Evidence
Relevant, current, from a credible source, and large enough to back the claim. Example: a peer-reviewed study of 5,000 people.
Weak Evidence
Off-topic, outdated, biased, or a single story standing in for proof. Example: "My cousin tried it once and it worked."

How to Evaluate an Argument

1
Find the claim. What position does the writer want you to accept?
2
List the evidence. Which facts, examples, or data are offered as support?
3
Test relevance and sufficiency. Does the evidence fit the claim, and is there enough of it?
4
Check the reasoning. Look for gaps, hidden assumptions, or faulty logic.
5
Judge the strength. Decide if the conclusion truly follows from the support.

Worked Example 1

Claim: Our town should add bike lanes.
Evidence: A 30% accident drop in three comparable cities.
Reasoning: What worked in similar towns should work here.

Worked Example 2

Claim: This is the best diet.
Evidence: One neighbor lost weight.
Assumption: One person's result applies to everyone.

Worked Example 3

Claim: The new principal raised scores.
Reasoning flaw: Two things happening together does not prove one caused the other.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing Claim with Fact
Treating a debatable opinion as if it were proven truth.
✕ Accepting One Example
Letting a single anecdote stand in for sufficient evidence.
✕ Ignoring the Source
Not asking whether the evidence is credible or biased.
✕ Missing the Gap
Overlooking the hidden assumption between evidence and claim.

Evaluation Checklist

Strong Argument Weak Argument
RelevanceEvidence fits the claimEvidence is off-topic
SufficiencyEnough proof givenOne example only
SourceCredible, unbiasedUnknown or biased
ReasoningLogic links clearlyHidden gaps or flaws

Question 1 of 5

In an argument, which element is the writer's main point that they want you to accept?

Question 2 of 5

What makes the evidence in this argument strong?

Question 3 of 5

Why is this argument weak?

Question 4 of 5

What reasoning error appears in this argument?

Question 5 of 5

When you evaluate an argument, which question best tests the sufficiency of the evidence?

Putting It Together

1
Separate the parts: claim, evidence, and reasoning.
2
Test the evidence for relevance, sufficiency, and credibility.
3
Hunt for hidden assumptions and logic errors like correlation-causation.
4
Judge overall strength, a chain is only as strong as its weakest link.

You Can Now Evaluate Arguments