Evaluate
Arguments
Learn to break apart an argument, identify its claim and evidence, and judge whether the reasoning truly holds up.
What Is an Argument?
In reading, an argument is not a fight. It is a writer's attempt to convince you of a position by stating a claim and backing it with evidence and reasoning.
The Three Building Blocks
Claim vs. Evidence
The Core Rule
If any one link breaks, the argument weakens. We can picture strength as a simple chain: \( \text{Strength} = \text{Relevance} \times \text{Sufficiency} \times \text{Logic} \). If any factor drops toward zero, the whole product collapses.
A Chain Is Only as Strong as Its Weakest Link
Strong vs. Weak Support
How to Evaluate an Argument
Worked Example 1
Claim: Our town should add bike lanes.
Evidence: A 30% accident drop in three comparable cities.
Reasoning: What worked in similar towns should work here.
Worked Example 2
Claim: This is the best diet.
Evidence: One neighbor lost weight.
Assumption: One person's result applies to everyone.
Worked Example 3
Claim: The new principal raised scores.
Reasoning flaw: Two things happening together does not prove one caused the other.
Common Mistakes
Evaluation Checklist
| Strong Argument | Weak Argument | |
|---|---|---|
| Relevance | Evidence fits the claim | Evidence is off-topic |
| Sufficiency | Enough proof given | One example only |
| Source | Credible, unbiased | Unknown or biased |
| Reasoning | Logic links clearly | Hidden gaps or flaws |
Question 1 of 5
In an argument, which element is the writer's main point that they want you to accept?
Question 2 of 5
"Reading aloud to young children boosts their language skills. A large study following 2,000 children for five years found that those read to daily had significantly larger vocabularies by age six."
What makes the evidence in this argument strong?
Question 3 of 5
"We should switch to the new software immediately. My coworker installed it on his laptop last week and says it runs faster than the old one."
Why is this argument weak?
Question 4 of 5
"Ice cream sales and drowning deaths both rise in summer. Therefore, eating ice cream must cause drowning."
What reasoning error appears in this argument?
Question 5 of 5
When you evaluate an argument, which question best tests the sufficiency of the evidence?