Analyze
Source Arguments
Learn to evaluate the reasoning and credibility behind what you read, so you can judge whether a claim truly holds up.
What Is an Argument?
In everyday speech, an "argument" is a dispute. But in reading and writing, an argument is something more useful: a claim backed up by evidence and reasoning. The author wants you to believe or do something, and they offer support to convince you.
The Three Parts of an Argument
Why Analyzing Arguments Matters
Every day you read ads, news stories, social media posts, and editorials that try to persuade you. Some are well supported. Others rely on weak evidence or unstated assumptions. Analyzing the argument lets you separate solid reasoning from persuasion that only sounds convincing.
What Makes a Source Credible?
Credibility is how much you can trust a source. A credible source has the knowledge, evidence, and honesty to be believed. To judge it, look at who wrote it, why they wrote it, and how well they support their claims.
The Core Test of Reasoning
An argument's reasoning is valid only when the conclusion truly follows from the evidence. We can picture this like a chain: each link must hold for the whole chain to support the conclusion.
A Sound Reasoning Chain
Fact vs. Opinion
Strong evidence is built on facts, statements that can be checked and proven. Persuasive writing often slips in opinions, statements of belief that cannot be verified. Knowing the difference is the first step to judging evidence.
How to Analyze an Argument
Example 1: A Strong Argument
Example 2: A Weak Argument
Example 3: Spotting Bias
The evidence is a study, which sounds credible. But who paid for it? When a source has a financial interest in the outcome, its evidence may be slanted. This is bias, and it should make you cautious.
Common Mistakes
Strong vs. Weak Arguments
| Strong | Weak | |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence | Verifiable facts & data | Opinion & anecdote |
| Source | Expert, unbiased | Unknown or biased |
| Reasoning | Conclusion follows | Leaps & gaps |
| Tone | Measured, specific | Emotional, vague |
Question 1 of 5
In a reading argument, what is a claim?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement is a fact rather than an opinion?
Question 3 of 5
"You should switch to GlowBright toothpaste right away. A survey paid for by GlowBright found that 9 out of 10 people preferred it. My cousin uses it and her smile has never looked better, so it clearly works for everyone."
What is the biggest weakness in this argument?
Question 4 of 5
Which source would most likely be the most credible for a claim about a new medication's safety?
Question 5 of 5
An argument's reasoning is sound when:
You Can Now Analyze Arguments
You have learned to break an argument into its claim, evidence, and reasoning, to tell facts from opinions, and to judge a source's credibility and possible bias.