Integrate Text And Data - GED Reasoning Through Language Arts
- A study finds a drug improved memory slightly but caused headaches in many users. Which summary is most accurate: "a clear success" or "a modest benefit with a notable drawback"?
- "A modest benefit with a notable drawback." It reflects both findings; "a clear success" ignores the side effect.
- A report says thefts rose 50 percent; the raw numbers went from 2 to 3. What is the key caution about this claim?
- The base is very small. A 50 percent jump is only one additional theft, so the percentage makes the change sound larger than it is.
- Why does a small sample size weaken a conclusion drawn from survey data?
- A few responses may not represent the larger group, so the results can easily differ from the true pattern.
- A text says sales "doubled." The data show sales rose from 200 units to 400 units. How do the data relate to the claim?
- They support it: 400 is exactly twice 200.
- A writer claims "most residents" back a new tax. A survey shows 45 percent support it. How does the survey relate to the claim?
- It contradicts the claim. Most means more than half, and 45 percent is less than half.
- Tutored students passed at 80 percent; untutored students passed at 60 percent. How do the pass rates compare?
- The tutored group's pass rate was 20 percentage points higher.
- A memo claims a program raised attendance. Which data best test this: participants' attendance before and after, or the program's budget?
- Attendance before and after. It measures the outcome the claim is about; the budget does not.
- When text and data are combined, what makes a conclusion accurate?
- It states only what both the text and the numbers support, including mixed results, and does not go beyond them.
- Why is a comparison (control) group important when data are used to show a program worked?
- It shows what happened without the program, so any difference can more reasonably be credited to the program rather than to other factors.
- What is the difference between correlation and causation?
- Correlation means two things change together; causation means one actually produces the other. Data showing correlation alone do not prove causation.
- What is a trend in a data set?
- A general direction of change over time, such as a steady rise or decline.